Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Yield stress — where it appears

The stress a material must be given before it flows at all, below which it behaves as a solid however long it is left. It converts into a length, τ_y/ρg sin α, which is the thickest layer that can rest on a slope — 16 mm of toothpaste on a vertical wall, and the thickness at which a lava flow stops.

Named by 7 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Four answers to one push. Shear stress against shear rate for four fluids. The straight line through the origin is the Newtonian definition and is the only one of the four for which the word viscosity names a number. The Bingham fluid does not move at all until the stress passes 0.4, which is why toothpaste holds a shape on a brush and why wet concrete can be stood in a heap.

The fluid that answers back

For water, stress is proportional to how fast it is sheared, and the constant of proportionality is its viscosity. For paint, blood, ketchup and cornflour in water, it is not — and once the proportionality goes, so does the idea that viscosity is a number a substance has.

fluids · Rheology The thickness a paste can hold on a slope. The greatest thickness a yield-stress fluid can rest at without flowing, against the angle of the surface it is resting on, on a logarithmic vertical axis, for four materials. A layer of thickness h puts a shear stress ρgh sin α on its own base; it stays put while that is below the yield stress and flows when it is not, so the critical thickness is τ_y divided by ρg sin α and it depends on nothing else — not on the viscosity, not on how long it is left, not on how it was put there. On a vertical wall the numbers are 1.4 mm of ketchup, 9.2 mm of mayonnaise, 15.7 mm of toothpaste, 15.1 mm of basaltic lava, which is why toothpaste stays on a brush and ketchup does not stay on a plate held up. Read the other way it is a measurement: a lava flow that came to rest 3 centimetres thick on a 30° slope had a yield stress of about 400 pascals, and that is how the rheology of a flow nobody was standing next to is recovered from its shape a thousand years later. The model stops where the layer is thin enough for surface tension to matter and where the material's yield stress depends on how long it has been left alone, which for most of these it does.

The paste that holds up its own hill

Toothpaste stands on a brush and ketchup does not stand on a plate, and the difference is a single number with the units of a pressure. Below it a material does not flow slowly — it does not flow. That threshold turns a rheological property into a length, and the length is why a lava flow's thickness says what the lava was made of.

fluids · Rheology The slope a heap of grains settles at. The steepest slope a cohesionless heap can hold, against the friction between its grains. A slab of thickness h on a slope is pushed down it by the weight's along-slope component and held by friction acting on the weight's across-slope component, and both are proportional to the same ρgh — so the thickness cancels and the criterion is tan θ = μ. Checked here at thicknesses of 2 mm, 50 mm, 2000 mm, the ratio of driving to holding stress differs by 2.2e-16, which is zero. That is why the quantity is an angle: nothing about the size of the pile, the size of the grains, the density or the strength of gravity survives into it, and a heap of sand on the Moon stands at the same slope as one on Earth. The marked materials are glass beads at 24°, dry sand at 33°, crushed gravel at 40°. The band between the two curves is the hysteresis: a slope steeper than 31.0° will keep flowing once started, and one shallower than 35.0° will not start — so a pile has a range of stable angles rather than one, and which it is found at depends on how it was built.

The angle that does not know the size of the heap

Pour sand and it makes a cone with a definite slope, and pouring more makes a larger cone with the same slope. The reason the answer is an angle rather than a length is a cancellation — the force pulling a surface layer downhill and the friction holding it back are both proportional to its weight, so everything about the size of the pile divides out — and everything that puts a length back in is a story about cohesion.

fluids · Granular matter A field strings a suspension into chains. 48 identical polarisable spheres, two radii apart at least, scattered at random through a periodic cell twenty radii square — 38 per cent of its area — and the same spheres after the field (vertical) has been on long enough for the viscous liquid to let them move. Each moves in proportion to the dipolar force from all the others and is stopped only by contact. At the start no two are touching; at the end 45 are bonded end to end along the field and 48 of the 48 spheres belong to chains, lying along the field lines and kept apart sideways because side-by-side dipoles repel. Chains that reach from one electrode to the other are what make the liquid resist shear, and they form in the milliseconds it takes a sphere to travel its own diameter.

The liquid a field turns solid

Stir fine starch or glass beads into silicone oil and the result pours like cream. Put a few kilovolts across it and within milliseconds it holds its shape and will not flow until it is pushed hard. Nothing in it is charged. Each particle becomes a dipole in the field, dipoles pull on each other end to end and push apart side by side, and so the particles string themselves into chains from one electrode to the other — a solid made of forces that exist only while the voltage is on.

electromagnetism · Dielectrics The same paste stopping or running, according to the push. A thixotropic paste, sheared hard and then held under a constant stress: its viscosity against time, on a logarithmic axis, for stresses of 1.5, 1.8, 2.0, 2.4 Pa. Its structure builds at rest and is broken by flow, and the model's critical stress is 1.89 Pa. Below it the paste's viscosity climbs without limit: it slows, its structure builds faster than the slowing flow can break it, and it creeps to a stop, its viscosity growing in the end as the 1.5 power of time. Above it the viscosity falls: it speeds up, breaks its structure faster, and runs at a steady rate. After a thousand seconds the viscosities stand at 514.1, 238.3, 2.0, 1.5 Pa s: stresses a few per cent apart have gone opposite ways — a bifurcation, not a smooth change — and the paste hesitates longest when the stress is closest to the critical value.

The paste that forgets it was stirred

A jar of clay slurry left on a shelf sets like a jelly; shaken, it pours. That is thixotropy, and the tempting description — its viscosity falls when it is stirred — misses what makes it strange. A thixotropic paste has no viscosity at a given rate of stirring until it has been told how long it has been stirring, and under a steady push it cannot settle on a slow flow at all. Push slightly less than a critical stress and it creeps to a halt; push slightly more and it runs. Between the two there is nothing, and a paste made to flow slowly splits into a layer that flows and a layer that does not.

fluids · Rheology The force to pull a foot out of packed sand. The suction that resists pulling a foot (a sole of 250 cm², 10 cm long) straight up out of sand, as water is drawn through the sand into the space the foot leaves — Darcy's law with a Kozeny–Carman permeability — against the pulling speed, on logarithmic axes, for compacted sand (fraction 0.6) of three grain sizes and for loose sand (0.41) of 0.1 mm; the dotted line is a 70 kg person's weight. The force is proportional to the speed and inversely to the square of the grain size. Pulled at a centimetre a second from compacted 0.1 mm sand, a foot resists with 2.5 kN, 4 times the person's weight; the speed at which the suction equals that weight is 2.71 mm/s. In the loose sand before it compacted, the same pull would need 15 per cent of the force; with clay filling the pores of the compacted sand, as in natural quicksand, a thousand times more, and the speed a body's weight can pull at falls to microns a second.

The sand that lets a body in and will not let it out

Quicksand cannot swallow anyone: liquefied, it is nearly twice as dense as water, and a person in it floats with their chest clear. What makes it dangerous is the opposite asymmetry. Going in is easy, because a step breaks the gel holding the grains apart and the sand turns liquid. Coming out is hard, because the sand settles and packs around whatever sank, and a trapped foot can only rise as fast as water can seep through the packed grains to fill the space it leaves. Pulling harder barely helps; letting water in does.

fluids · Rheology How a layer of grains moves down a slope. The velocity through a steady layer of 0.5 mm glass beads 20 grains deep flowing down slopes of 22°, 25° and 28°, against height above the rough base in grain diameters; the dashed curve is a Newtonian liquid's parabola, scaled to the 25° surface speed. Because every depth must have friction tan θ, every depth has the same inertial number, and the shear rate grows with the square root of the pressure above it: Bagnold's profile, u ∝ h^(3/2) − (h − z)^(3/2). Its surface speeds are 8.0, 41.0, 113.7 cm/s; compared with a liquid's parabola the shear is spread more evenly through the depth, because the shear rate falls off only as the square root of the depth below the surface rather than in proportion to it.

The sand whose friction depends on how fast it flows

A heap of sand stands at its angle of repose and starts to slide a few degrees steeper; between those angles there are steady avalanches, and their speed is decided by one number. The inertial number compares how long a grain takes to fall into a gap opened under it with how long the flow takes to open the gap. Friction rises with it, from the static value to a ceiling, and that single dependence explains why grains flow steadily on only a twelve-degree window of slopes, why a flowing layer has the velocity profile Bagnold measured, and why a deeper avalanche is faster — but not as a liquid would be.

fluids · Granular matter

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

RheologyThixotropyViscosityConstitutive lawFrictionGranular matterShear stressSuspensionAngle of reposeApparent viscosityArchimedes principleAvalanche

All concepts