Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Plasma frequency — where it appears

The natural frequency at which the electrons of a plasma oscillate about its ions, ωp = √(ne²/ε₀m). Waves below it cannot propagate and are reflected, which is why the ionosphere reflects short-wave radio and why metals reflect visible light.

Named by 10 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A click that arrives sorted by pitch. Arrival time against frequency for a broadband pulse travelling 40 megametres along a magnetic field line through a plasma of 1e+8 electrons per cubic metre in a field of 300 nanotesla — the magnetosphere, roughly. The gyrofrequency is 8.4 kilohertz and the plasma frequency 90 kilohertz, so this is the regime where a right-hand circularly polarised wave travels happily below both of them. It does not travel at one speed. The group velocity is 2c√ω(ω_c − ω)^(3/2)/(ω_p ω_c), which is zero at zero frequency and zero again at the gyrofrequency and peaks in between — at 2.10 kilohertz here, which is a quarter of the gyrofrequency, found by searching the drawn function rather than quoted. Everything either side of that peak is slower, so the curve has a nose: 3.21 s at 500 Hz, 2.20 s at 2000 Hz, 3.59 s at 5000 Hz. The branch below the nose is the classic whistler — a lightning stroke in one hemisphere reaching a receiver in the other as a note gliding downward over about a second, which is what gave the phenomenon its name — and the branch above it arrives as a rising tone at the same time. Both are observed, and a recording that shows the two joined at the nose is how the gyrofrequency along the path is read off directly. Read the other way it is an instrument: the product of the delay and the square root of the frequency is 79 s·Hz^½ here, nearly constant across the low end of the band, and it measures the electron content of a path through the magnetosphere that nothing else could reach.

The whistle that arrives sorted

A lightning stroke in one hemisphere reaches a receiver in the other as a note gliding downward over about a second. Nothing dispersed the sound; there was no sound. A radio pulse travelled forty megametres along a magnetic field line through a plasma whose group velocity depends on frequency, and arrived with its frequencies separated by up to three seconds.

astrophysics · Plasma oscillation Snell's law with space and time exchanged. Two constructions on the same diagram of frequency against wavenumber, with the light lines of a medium of index 1 and of index 1.5. On the left, a boundary in space: the wave crosses a still surface, the frequency is conserved, and the horizontal line at the incident frequency meets the new medium's line at a wavenumber 1.5 times larger — the familiar shortening of the wavelength. On the right, a boundary in time: the whole medium changes at once, the wavenumber is conserved, and the vertical line at the incident wavenumber meets the new medium's line at a frequency 0.667 times the old one. The vertical line also meets the new line's negative-frequency branch, which is a wave running backwards: a reflection in time. A spatial boundary reflects into the same frequency and a temporal one into the same wavelength.

The reflection that needs no surface

Change the refractive index of a whole medium at one instant and a wave already travelling through it splits in two, one part running on and one running back, though there is no surface anywhere for it to reflect from. A boundary in time is Snell's law with space and time exchanged: the wavelength is kept and the frequency changes, momentum is conserved and energy is not.

optics · Refraction The orbits of an electron in a travelling wave. The possible motions of an electron in a plasma wave whose phase moves at γₚ = 10 and whose field is 0.2 of the cold wave-breaking field, drawn as its energy against its position in the wave over two wavelengths — the level curves of H = γ − βₚ u − ε cos ψ, which the electron's motion conserves. Inside the separatrix (thick) an electron is trapped: it slides back and forth through the wave, gaining energy while it outruns the wave and losing it while the wave outruns it. The separatrix reaches γ = 99 at its top, near 4γₚ²ε = 80, starting from electrons moving at the wave's own speed. Outside it, electrons that are too slow are overtaken by the wave and those that are fast enough outrun it; neither gains energy on average.

The wave an electron rides to a gigaelectronvolt

A laser pulse fired into a thin plasma pushes its electrons aside and leaves them oscillating behind it, a wave of charge travelling at nearly the speed of light. The field in that wave is a thousand times stronger than any metal accelerator can hold, and an electron caught in it at the right moment is carried along like a surfer, gaining a gigaelectronvolt in a few centimetres. Then it outruns the wave. The distance it can ride, and the energy it can gain, are both set by how nearly the wave keeps pace with it — which is to say, by relativity.

relativity · Relativistic dynamics A mirror for X-rays that works only at a glance. The fraction of 8 keV X-rays reflected by a smooth surface of gold and of silicon, against the grazing angle between the ray and the surface, in milliradians, with absorption included (solid) and without it (dashed). Below the critical angle √(2δ) — 10.02 mrad (0.57°) for gold, 3.88 mrad (0.22°) for silicon — the X-rays are totally reflected from outside the material, because its index is below the vacuum's; above it almost nothing is. Absorption rounds the edge and keeps the plateau a little below one. A mirror for X-rays is therefore a surface met at less than a degree, and it reflects well only while it is met that way.

The index that falls below one

Glass bends light because light is slower in it. X-rays are not slower in glass, or in anything: every material's refractive index for them is slightly less than one, by a few parts in a million. Everything about X-ray optics follows from that small number with the wrong sign. A lens that focuses them must be thinner in the middle than at the edges, and so weak that dozens are stacked in a row. A mirror reflects them only if they arrive at a glancing angle of less than a degree — totally, from the outside, the reverse of the way a diamond traps light — which is why the mirrors of an X-ray telescope are long, nested barrels rather than dishes.

optics · Refraction Two ways to be wrong, and the apparatus that sees each. The fractional sag of the potential at the centre of a charged spherical shell below the shell's own, on a logarithmic axis, against the shell's radius in metres, also logarithmic, for two different departures from Coulomb's law. If the force fell as 1/r^(2+ε) with ε = 10⁻¹⁶, the sag is 3.07·10⁻¹⁷ whatever the shell's size (dashed): the law has no length in it, so neither does its failure. If the photon had a mass of 10⁻¹⁴ eV, the sag is (μR)²/6 (solid): 4.3·10⁻²⁰ for a centimetre shell and 4.3·10⁻¹⁶ for a metre. A mass introduces a length, and the signal grows as the square of the apparatus compared with it — so the strongest bounds on a photon mass come from the largest fields, not the most sensitive laboratories.

The mass that would make Gauss's law leak

Gauss's law says the flux out of any closed surface counts the charge inside, whatever the surface's size. If the photon had even a tiny mass, that would stop being true: the field of a charge would die off exponentially beyond a length ħ/mc, the flux through a large sphere would fall short of the charge, and the inside of a charged shell would no longer be field-free. There are two different ways Coulomb's law could fail, and they are caught by opposite strategies. A wrong exponent has no length in it and shows equally in any apparatus; a mass has a length, and shows as the square of the apparatus's size. That is why the tightest limit on the photon's mass comes not from a laboratory but from the magnetic field the solar wind carries past Pluto.

electromagnetism · Gauss's law Rays at a frequency the ionosphere cannot stop head-on. Ray paths at 14 MHz launched at angles from 10° to 75° from the vertical into a Chapman layer peaking at 300 km with a critical frequency of 8 MHz, over a flat Earth. A wave sent straight up at 14 MHz passes through: it is above the layer's plasma frequency everywhere. A ray at φ₀ from the vertical turns back where the plasma frequency equals f cos φ₀ — the secant law — so only rays more oblique than arccos(8/14) = 55.2° return. Those that do land beyond about 1133 km; nothing comes down closer than that: the skip zone, a ring of silence round a transmitter that is audible much further away. Vertical scale exaggerated about six times.

The frequency the sky returns only at a slant

The ionosphere turns back any radio wave below its plasma frequency, about eight megahertz on a summer afternoon, and lets anything above it out into space — if the wave is sent straight up. Send a fourteen-megahertz wave up at a slant and it comes back down, a thousand kilometres away. Only the part of the wave's motion across the layer has to be stopped, and that part is the frequency times the cosine of the angle. The rule turns one frequency into a range of them, sets the highest frequency that can reach any given distance, and leaves a ring of silence round every short-wave transmitter, inside which it cannot be heard at all.

astrophysics · Plasma oscillation Light from a charge that crosses into glass at a steady speed. The transition radiation emitted as an ultrarelativistic charge crosses from vacuum into a dense medium, per unit solid angle, against the angle to the path in units of 1/γ, for photons at three frequencies: one tenth, three tenths and one times γωₚ, where ωₚ is the medium's plasma frequency. The scale is αħγ²/π² per unit frequency. Nothing is emitted straight ahead; the light comes out in a narrow hollow cone with its brightest ring at γθ = 0.98, 0.88, 0.68 for the three. At a tenth of γωₚ the peak is about ten times higher than at γωₚ. The charge never accelerates: it is the field's sudden change of shape at the surface, from the flattened disc it carries in vacuum to the one the medium's electrons allow, that is radiated.

The light a charge makes by changing medium

A charge moving at constant speed in a straight line radiates nothing in a vacuum, and nothing in glass either if it is slower than light there. Let it cross from one into the other and it radiates at the boundary, though it neither turns nor slows. The field it carries has one shape in each medium and has to be rebuilt as it crosses, and what is shed in the rebuilding is light. The energy shed grows in proportion to the particle's Lorentz factor, the one property of a fast particle that almost nothing else measures at high energy, and this is why detectors stack hundreds of plastic foils in a particle's path to collect one or two X-rays.

astrophysics · Radiating charge A sound that survives only in a hot-electron plasma. The damping of an ion-acoustic wave at kλD = 0.3, as the fraction of its amplitude lost per radian of oscillation, −γ/ω, against the ratio of electron to ion temperature, for hydrogen and argon plasmas, on logarithmic axes: from the kinetic dispersion relation (solid) and from the weak-damping formula (dashed), which is valid only where the damping is small. With equal temperatures the wave loses 0.45 of its amplitude per radian in hydrogen — it is gone within a cycle. At Tₑ/Tᵢ = 10 the loss is 0.031; at 100 it is 0.0126, set by the electrons alone. Argon's floor is lower, 0.0020, because its ions are heavier and its electrons a smaller fraction of a sound wave's speed.

The sound a plasma carries on its electrons' heat

Sound in a gas needs two things: something heavy to be pushed, and a pressure to push it. In an ordinary gas the same molecules supply both. In a plasma they can be split — the ions carry the inertia and the electrons, a thousand times lighter and often a hundred times hotter, carry the pressure — and the result is a sound that travels at a speed set by one particle's temperature and the other's mass. It travels only while the two temperatures stay far apart. Warm the ions to match the electrons and the sound dies within a cycle, with nothing to rub against.

astrophysics · Plasma oscillation Two beams that each stay straight, and wind each other into whirlpools. Phase space of a one-dimensional particle simulation: every dot is an electron, plotted at its position along a periodic box one fastest-growing wavelength long (10.26 v₀/ωₚ) and its velocity, in units of the beam speed. One beam starts at +v₀, the other at −v₀, with a 0.0001 ripple in position. At t = 18/ωₚthe beams are visibly rippled; by 26 the ripple has grown into overturning, and by 40 the two beams have wound round each other into a single vortex, filamented into strands. When growth first stops, at ωₚt = 25.2, the wave's field is 0.56 m v₀ωₚ/e; electrons trapped in it bounce at 0.59 ωₚ, faster than the 0.354 ωₚ at which it was growing, and it traps any electron within ±1.92 v₀ of the wave's speed — zero, by symmetry — so both beams are inside its separatrix; total energy was conserved to 0.31%.

The two beams that unravel each other

A cold beam of electrons, alone, is perfectly stable: disturb it and it rings at its plasma frequency and carries the ringing downstream. Send a second beam through it the other way and the pair is not stable at all. A ripple of the right length grows by a factor of e in less than half a plasma period, takes a third of the beams' drift energy into an electric field, and then winds both beams into a single whirlpool in which their drift is gone. Neither beam can do it. The growth exists only in the pair, and a beam a millionth as dense as the plasma it crosses is enough to start it.

astrophysics · Plasma oscillation Two descriptions of gold that agree everywhere but at zero. How strongly gold answers a slowly varying field, (ε(iξ) − 1)ξ²/ωₚ² in the two forms of its permittivity at imaginary frequency ξ, against ξ on a logarithmic axis: the plasma model (dashed), which ignores the electrons' collisions and gives exactly 1, and the Drude model (solid), which includes them at the measured rate ħγ = 35 meV and falls to zero below about γ = 5.3·10¹³ per second. The Lifshitz force samples this curve only at the Matsubara frequencies 2πlkT/ħ (dots, 300 K): the first, 2.47·10¹⁴ per second, lies above γ, and there the two descriptions differ by 18 per cent, at the next by 10, and less beyond. At l = 0, ξ = 0, they part completely: 1 against 0. Everything the two models disagree about is in that one point.

The static field a metal may or may not reflect

The Casimir force between two gold plates at room temperature has been computed two ways for twenty-five years, and the two answers differ by forty per cent at three micrometres. Both use the same measured optical properties of gold. They part company over a single number: whether gold reflects a magnetic field that does not change in time. Common sense and every electrical engineer say it does not, since a static field passes straight through a copper sheet. The most precise force measurements say it does. The disagreement is not about the Casimir effect at all; it is about what a metal's electrons do with a fluctuation slower than their collisions.

electromagnetism · Retardation

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Refractive indexGroup velocityDispersion relationLandau dampingPhase velocityPhotonPlasma oscillationSnell's lawTotal internal reflectionBoundary conditionCasimir effectCircular polarisation

All concepts