Theme

Approximations that lie — part 3 of 3

The small-angle assumption, the frictionless plane, the point mass — where each is fine, and precisely where it stops being.
How fast each point of a fast wheel moves. The speed through the ground of each point on the rim of a rolling wheel, in units of the speed of light, against the point's angle round the rim measured from the bottom, for axles moving at 0.5c, 0.8c, 0.95c. The dashed curves are the everyday answer, 2v sin(α/2), which puts the top at twice the axle's speed and would carry it past light. Composed relativistically, the bottom is still at rest and the top moves at 2v/(1 + v²/c²): 0.800c, 0.976c, 0.999c, always below c. Every point of the rim stays slower than light, and the fast part of the wheel is flattened into a broad plateau over the top. Relativity

The wheel whose top cannot go twice as fast

The top of a rolling wheel moves at twice the speed of its axle, and the bottom is momentarily at rest — two facts every cyclist's spokes show, blurred at the top and sharp at the bottom. Roll the wheel at a large fraction of the speed of light and the second fact survives exactly while the first cannot: the top moves at 2v/(1 + v²/c²), never as fast as light. Caught at one instant of the ground's time the spokes are bent, and over one turn the wheel advances not the circumference measured from its axle but γ times it — the rim's own length, laid down on the ground by a contact point that does not move.

A pile of glass plates, added two ways. The transmission of light at normal incidence through a pile of N glass plates (index 1.5) in air, on a logarithmic axis, against N. Dashed: Stokes's 1862 result for light whose reflections add as intensities, T = (1 − R)/(1 + (2N − 1)R) with R = 0.040 per surface, which falls only as 1/N: 0.107 at 100 plates, 0.029 at 400. Solid: the same pile with the reflections added as waves and every plate and gap of random thickness, as ⟨ln T⟩ over 200 random piles (red) and for one pile (grey). It falls in a straight line, by 0.0843 per plate, an exponential decay with a localisation length of 24 plates: 10⁻³ at 100 plates and 10⁻¹⁴ at 400. Interference with random phases does not average away; it traps. Waves

The pile of glass that stops every colour

A sheet of window glass reflects about eight per cent of the light that falls on it. A pile of a hundred sheets, George Stokes calculated in 1862, should still let through a tenth, because each extra sheet only adds a little more reflection to the total. That is right for sunlight, whose colours are too mixed to interfere. For a single colour, with every sheet and every gap a slightly different thickness, the same pile lets through a thousandth, and a pile of four hundred a hundred-millionth of a millionth. Interference with random phases does not average away into the intensity sum. In one dimension it traps every wave, at every wavelength, however weak each reflection is.

Two ways for a swing to die. A mass on a spring released 10.6 dead-band widths from rest, against time in units of 1/ω. Red: sliding on a dry surface, whose friction is a constant force; each swing is exactly a cosine, and the turning points fall in a straight line by two dead-band widths per half-cycle until the mass stops, 2.5 cycles after release, at −0.60. Blue: the same mass with viscous damping (damping ratio 0.05), whose force is proportional to speed; the swings shrink by the same fraction each cycle, along an exponential, and never stop. The period is the same in both and the same as with no damping at all to within the viscous case's 0.13 per cent. Mechanics

The swing that dies in a straight line

A pendulum in air loses the same fraction of its swing every cycle, so its amplitude falls along an exponential and, in principle, never quite reaches zero. A mass on a spring sliding over a dry surface does something else. Its friction is a fixed force, so it loses a fixed amount of amplitude every half-swing — the swings shrink in a straight line — and it stops completely, after a countable number of swings, somewhere inside a band around its natural position whose width is the friction divided by the stiffness. Where in that band it stops depends on where it started, which is why a barometer with friction in it is tapped before it is read.

Where the level goes when a floating ice cube melts. The change in level when a 30 g ice cube floating in a glass 7 cm across has melted completely, against the density of the liquid it floats in (the liquid must be denser than ice, 917 kg/m³, or the cube sinks). In fresh water the level does not move: the meltwater exactly fills the volume the ice displaced. In seawater it rises 0.21 mm and in saturated brine 1.3 mm, because the ice was displacing a denser liquid than it melts into; in castor oil, which is lighter than water and does not mix with it, the level falls 0.32 mm as the meltwater sinks beneath the oil. The change is the meltwater's volume minus the displaced volume, m/ρw − m/ρ, spread over the glass. Fluids

The floating ice that still raises the sea

An ice cube melting in a glass of water leaves the level exactly where it was, and the reason is exact: a floating body displaces its own weight, and the meltwater has that weight. The same argument is often used to say that melting sea ice and ice shelves cannot raise the sea. It nearly works. The ice was floating in salt water and melts into fresh, which is lighter, so the meltwater overfills the hole by almost three per cent — and the ice that really fills the sea is the part of a grounded glacier above the thickness at which it would float.

The share of its energy a particle can hand to one electron. The largest fraction of its kinetic energy a muon, a pion, a proton or an alpha particle can give a free electron in one collision, against its Lorentz factor γ, on logarithmic axes. A slow proton can give at most 0.22 per cent, 4m/M, which is why a proton slows down through tens of thousands of gentle collisions rather than a few hard ones. The share rises as γ grows and reaches a half at γ = 916 for a proton and 101 for a muon — near M/2m, where the electron's energy in the centre-of-momentum frame has grown comparable to the projectile's, so that the two meet as equals and a head-on reversal can hand the electron most of the energy. Relativity

The kick a fast particle can give an electron

A slow proton crossing matter can give any one electron at most a fifth of a per cent of its energy, because an electron struck head-on by something two thousand times heavier rebounds at no more than twice the heavier one's speed. That rule of thumb fails at relativistic speeds, and fails upward: the electron's speed is capped below light, but its energy is not, and the largest kick grows as the square of the projectile's Lorentz factor until, above a teraelectronvolt, one collision can take more than half of everything a proton carries.

Insulating a thin wire makes it lose more heat. The heat lost per metre from a wire 2 mm across held 40 K above the air, against the outer radius of the PVC insulation round it (k = 0.19 W/m K), with the surface losing 10 W/m²K to still air by convection and radiation, on a logarithmic radius axis; dashed, the bare wire. The first layers of insulation increase the loss, from 2.51 to a maximum of 12.11 W/m at an outer radius of 19 mm — the critical radius k/h — because they add surface faster than they add resistance. Beyond the critical radius the loss falls again, but so slowly — the resistance of the insulation grows only as the logarithm of its radius — that it does not get back down to the bare wire's until the PVC is 178 km thick. Any sheath a cable could carry makes it lose more heat, not less. Thermodynamics

The insulation that makes a wire lose more heat

Wrap a hot water pipe in glass wool and it loses less heat. Wrap a thin electrical wire in PVC and it loses more — four times more, at the best thickness — and runs cooler for it. The insulation adds a resistance to heat flowing through it, but it also adds surface for the heat to leave from, and around a thin enough cylinder the surface wins. The crossover is a radius, k/h, set by the insulation and the air; below it, more insulation means more heat lost, and a small enough ball cannot be insulated by anything wrapped round it.

A tilt that reaches zero at a definite time. The tilt of the disk against time from 10°, when the losses are set to end the motion after 100 s, for two ways of losing energy: viscous air squeezed out of the thin wedge under the rim (red), which takes energy faster the smaller the tilt, so that α³ falls in a straight line; and a steady rolling resistance at the contact (blue), which takes energy in proportion to the contact rate, so that α to the power 3/2 does. Both fall slowly at first and steeply at the end, and both reach zero tilt at a definite time rather than approaching it for ever: at 99 s, one second before the end, the tilt is 2.15° under the air model and 0.46° under rolling resistance. The disk's energy, (3/2)Mgaα, runs out in a finite time, and with it the tilt. Mechanics

The disk that spins faster as it stops

A coin spun on a table settles with a whirr that rises in pitch and then stops dead. Everything about it is losing energy, yet the rattle gets faster to the very end. The point where the rim touches the table races round faster and faster as the coin tips flatter, while the coin's face, and the head on it, turns more and more slowly. Two plausible mechanisms of loss both predict that the tilt reaches zero, and the rattle infinity, at a definite instant — a singularity a coin on a kitchen table runs into every time.

A ring pushed and pulled, and pushed a little more. Over two cycles of the alternating supply, for a ring whose reactance equals its resistance (ωL/R = 1): the flux through the ring (grey), which also sets the radial field that pushes the ring along the core; the voltage induced round the ring (dashed); the current, which lags that voltage by 45° because of the ring's own inductance (blue); and the force along the axis, current times radial field (red). The force pushes the ring away from the coil for part of each half-cycle and pulls it back for the rest; with the lag, the pushes outweigh the pulls, and the average (dotted) is 0.250 of the peak flux–current product. With no lag the pushes and pulls would cancel exactly. The ring jumps because its current is late. Electromagnetism

The ring that jumps because its current is late

Slip an aluminium ring over the iron core of a coil, switch on the alternating current, and the ring leaps off the top. The usual explanation is Lenz's law: the ring's induced current opposes the change, so the ring is repelled. But an alternating field changes both ways every cycle, and an induced current that simply opposed the change would be pushed and pulled equally and stay put. The ring jumps only because its current runs late, held back by its own inductance — which is why a cooled ring jumps far higher and a ring with a saw cut through it does not move.

Pushed forward, and left at rest. The path of an electron, initially at rest, overtaken by a 6-cycle pulse of linearly polarised light travelling to the right, for peak field strengths a₀ = 0.5, 1, 2, where a₀ = 1 is the strength at which the electron's quiver becomes relativistic; lengths in wavelengths of the light, the vertical axis along the electric field. While the pulse passes, the electron quivers across the beam and is pushed along it. When the pulse has gone it is at rest again — not moving, with none of the light's energy — but displaced forward by 0.14, 0.56, 2.25 wavelengths respectively, a distance growing as a₀². The quiver's width grows only as a₀: at a₀ = 2 the electron is pushed forward several times further than it swings sideways. Relativity

The light that moves an electron and pays it nothing

A pulse of light strong enough to throw an electron forward at a large fraction of the speed of light passes over it, and the electron is left exactly as it was found — at rest, with none of the light's energy — except that it is somewhere else. The reason is two quantities the electron cannot change while a plane wave is passing, and the same two quantities fix the figure eight it traces inside the wave and the angle at which it leaves a real, focused beam carrying the energy it managed to keep.

Where the thread's line meets the floor. A spool resting on the floor on its rims of radius R, its thread wound round a hub of radius r = 0.5R and leaving the hub's underside tangentially, pulled up and to the right at 20°, 60° and 78° above the horizontal; the dashed lines continue each thread's line back down to the floor. The spool turns about the contact point, and the sense of the turn is set by where the thread's line meets the floor. At 20° it meets the floor behind the contact point, on the far side from the hand, and the spool rolls towards the hand. At 60°, where cos θ = r/R, it passes exactly through the contact point; the pull has no turning effect there, and the spool stays still while the hand pulls. At 78° it meets the floor in front of the contact point, between the spool and the hand, and the spool rolls away from the hand, paying the thread out. Mechanics

The spool that rolls towards the hand pulling it

Pull gently on the thread of a cotton reel lying on its side on a table, with the thread coming off the underside of the hub, and the reel rolls towards the hand, winding the thread up as it comes. Raise the thread and at one particular angle the reel will not move at all however hard it is pulled; raise it further and the reel rolls away, paying the thread out. Which way it goes is decided by a single line — where the thread's direction, extended, meets the table — and the same line decides which way a bicycle goes when its lower pedal is pulled backwards.

The ladder that leaves the wall. A 4-metre ladder released from rest at 15° from the vertical, its foot on a frictionless floor and its top against a frictionless wall, drawn at equal intervals of time from release to the moment it lies flat, computed by integrating its motion; the dots trace its centre. While both ends touch, the centre moves exactly on a circle of radius L/2 about the corner (dashed). The top leaves the wall when it has come down to 2.58 m, two-thirds of its starting height of 3.86 m; from then on the centre's horizontal speed is fixed, it leaves the circle, and the ladder falls clear of the wall with its foot still sliding. The fall takes 1.34 seconds. Mechanics

The ladder that lets go of the wall

A ladder whose foot slips on a smooth floor slides down a smooth wall — and partway down, its top comes away from the wall and the ladder falls the rest of the way clear of it. The point where it lets go of the wall is not set by its length, its mass or how steeply it started: it is always two-thirds of the height the top started at. The reason is a wall that can push but cannot pull, and the number falls out of energy alone, without a single force being calculated in advance.

The circle of electrons a wave can talk to. Electron velocities along and across the magnetic field, in units of c. Shaded: a horseshoe of 10 keV electrons (speed 0.195c), the shape a beam takes when it is driven down into a strengthening field, with the electrons moving up along the field missing. Curves: the electrons a wave travelling across the field can exchange energy with, for wave frequencies of 0.995, 0.980, 0.960 times the cyclotron frequency. Because a faster electron is heavier and circles more slowly, at Ω/γ, each resonance is a semicircle of radius c√(1 − ω²/Ω²): 0.100, 0.199, 0.280c. A wave at 0.981Ω resonates with the horseshoe's middle. Astrophysics

The radio that only heavier electrons can make

Above every aurora the Earth broadcasts a gigawatt of radio that no one on the ground can hear. It comes out just below the frequency at which electrons circle the field there, and it is a maser — amplified by the electrons themselves. The surprise is what makes the amplifier work. Without relativity it could not: summed over every electron, a wave at the circling frequency is always absorbed. The few per cent by which a fast electron is heavier, and circles more slowly, is not a correction to the mechanism. It is the mechanism.

Fringes that identical nuclei add. The cross-section for two identical spinless nuclei repelling each other, divided by the classical answer — the Rutherford counts for the nucleus hit and the nucleus thrown, added — against the scattering angle in the centre-of-mass frame, for Sommerfeld parameters η = 1, 4 and 16 (η is half the closest approach in units of the wavelength over 2π). Because the detector cannot tell which nucleus it caught, the two amplitudes add before squaring, and the cross term oscillates in angle: at 90° the two paths are mirror images and the rate is exactly twice the classical one at every energy. Between 30° and 90° the curve completes about 2 oscillations for η = 4 and 7 for η = 16 — their number grows in proportion to η, which is to say in proportion to 1/ħ. Quantum

The scattering quantum mechanics returns unchanged

Rutherford worked out how alpha particles bounce off a nucleus by treating them as tiny planets on hyperbolic orbits, two years before Bohr's atom and fifteen before quantum mechanics. He had no right to be exactly correct, and he was: the full quantum calculation returns his formula without a single correction, at every energy. Coulomb's force is the one force for which that happens. Make the two nuclei identical, though, and quantum mechanics adds fringes no orbit can produce — doubling the rate at right angles for one kind of particle and halving it for the other.

The spring falls from the top down. Snapshots of the falling spring, every fifth coil, at 0.00, 0.05, 0.09, 0.14, 0.18, 0.23, 0.26, 0.29 seconds after release, for a spring that hangs 1 m; the dashed line is the height of the bottom coil before release. The coils collapse onto one another from the top, and the collapsed block falls on the coils below; everything below the block hangs exactly as it did before the spring was let go, the bottom coil included. Only when the block reaches the bottom, 0.261 s after release, does the bottom begin to fall, and then the whole collapsed spring falls together. Mechanics

The spring whose bottom does not know it has been dropped

Hang a soft spring from its top, let go, and its bottom end stays exactly where it was — not falling slowly, not falling at all — while the top races down to meet it. A spring that hangs a metre takes about a quarter of a second to collapse, and only then does the bottom start to fall. Nothing holds it up. The centre of mass falls freely from the first instant, as it must, and the bottom simply has not been told: the news that the top has been released travels down the spring as a front of collapsing coils, and nothing below the front can feel anything until the front arrives.

A floor that has to hit a rod nobody dropped. The normal force on the lower end of a uniform rod at 63° with μ = 1.6, sliding outward at √(gl) and not yet turning, against time on a logarithmic axis, for a floor whose contact stiffness is 10⁴, 10⁵ and 10⁶ times mg/l. The rigid equations have no solution here, and the compliant floor shows why: the end digs in, the deeper it digs the harder friction twists it further down, and the force climbs until the sliding stops. The stiffer the floor, the higher and briefer the spike — 20, 56, 163 times the rod's weight, ending after 41, 18, 7 thousandths of √(l/g) — a collision with no approach. Mechanics

The rod that friction cannot decide about

Newton's laws, a rigid rod and Coulomb's law of friction are the first things a mechanics course teaches, and in 1895 Paul Painlevé showed that together they can fail to give any answer at all. A rod sliding on a rough enough floor, at the right angle, has no motion consistent with the three — or has two. The way out is not a new law but a forgotten fact: real contacts give a little. With that, the rod jams, and the floor delivers a sudden blow to a rod that nothing struck — an impact without a collision, which is how a stick of chalk comes to hop.

The force to pull a foot out of packed sand. The suction that resists pulling a foot (a sole of 250 cm², 10 cm long) straight up out of sand, as water is drawn through the sand into the space the foot leaves — Darcy's law with a Kozeny–Carman permeability — against the pulling speed, on logarithmic axes, for compacted sand (fraction 0.6) of three grain sizes and for loose sand (0.41) of 0.1 mm; the dotted line is a 70 kg person's weight. The force is proportional to the speed and inversely to the square of the grain size. Pulled at a centimetre a second from compacted 0.1 mm sand, a foot resists with 2.5 kN, 4 times the person's weight; the speed at which the suction equals that weight is 2.71 mm/s. In the loose sand before it compacted, the same pull would need 15 per cent of the force; with clay filling the pores of the compacted sand, as in natural quicksand, a thousand times more, and the speed a body's weight can pull at falls to microns a second. Fluids

The sand that lets a body in and will not let it out

Quicksand cannot swallow anyone: liquefied, it is nearly twice as dense as water, and a person in it floats with their chest clear. What makes it dangerous is the opposite asymmetry. Going in is easy, because a step breaks the gel holding the grains apart and the sand turns liquid. Coming out is hard, because the sand settles and packs around whatever sank, and a trapped foot can only rise as fast as water can seep through the packed grains to fill the space it leaves. Pulling harder barely helps; letting water in does.

A hydrogen atom tilted by a laser field. The potential energy of hydrogen's electron along the direction of a laser's electric field at the field's peak, in atomic units (one unit of energy is 27.2 eV, one of length 0.053 nm), for peak intensities of 3 × 10¹³ and 10¹⁴ W/cm² and at the barrier-suppression intensity, 1.37 × 10¹⁴; the dashed line is the bound level, 13.6 eV below the ionisation limit. The field tips the Coulomb well into a barrier on one side. At 3 × 10¹³ W/cm² the barrier is 15 atomic units thick at the level — 0.8 nm — at 10¹⁴, 6; at the suppression intensity its top has fallen to the level and the electron can leave without tunnelling at all. The barrier is real only for the fraction of the laser's period that the field stays near its peak. Quantum

The atom a light wave opens like a wall

Red light cannot free an electron from hydrogen: each photon carries 1.55 electronvolts and the electron is bound by 13.6. Make the light intense enough, though, and the atom ionises anyway — by absorbing nine photons at once, or, at higher intensity, by having its potential tipped over by the light's electric field until the electron tunnels out through the side. Which of the two happens is decided by a single ratio, found by Leonid Keldysh in 1964: how long the electron needs to get through the barrier, against how long the field holds still. The tunnelling side of that ratio is where attosecond physics begins.

Light that turns with the molecules it passes. Through a layer of liquid crystal whose molecules turn steadily through 90° from the entrance face to the exit (dashed line), the direction of the light's polarisation against depth, for linearly polarised light entering along the molecules, in a thick cell and a thin one; u = 2dΔn/λ measures the layer's birefringence against the wavelength. In the thick cell the polarisation turns with the molecules, never more than a few degrees behind, and leaves rotated by 90°: 100.0 per cent of the light passes an analyser set along the exit molecules. In the thin cell the light barely notices the twist; its polarisation lags further and further behind and leaves turned only part of the way, with 31 per cent passing. Mauguin saw the first case in 1911: a birefringent medium that twists slowly enough drags the light's polarisation round with it. Optics

The twist that carries light round a corner

Between two crossed polarisers, a sandwich of liquid crystal a few micrometres thick turns black to white. Its long molecules lie flat, but turned a quarter-turn from one face of the layer to the other, and polarised light entering along the molecules at one face comes out along them at the other — rotated by ninety degrees and able to pass the second polariser. Charles Mauguin found in 1911 that a slowly twisting birefringent layer drags light's polarisation round with it. Sixty years later the effect became the liquid-crystal display. The layers in those displays, though, are too thin to drag anything: the light inside them wanders off and comes back, at exactly the right thickness.

The bending a falling column must carry, along its height. The bending moment at each height of a uniform column toppling about its base, in units of its weight times its length, at tilts of 10°, 30°, 60° from upright. Every curve peaks at a third of the height, at mgL·sinθ/27: 0.0064, 0.0185, 0.0321. The base and the top carry none. The same column held still at the same tilt would carry its greatest moment at the base, mgL·sinθ/2 — 0.250 at 30°, 13.5 times as much. Falling relieves the bending by a factor of 13.5 and moves it a third of the way up. Mechanics

The chimney that breaks a third of the way up

A tall brick chimney felled by demolition rarely reaches the ground in one piece. It snaps partway up, early in its fall, and the top falls behind the rest. Nothing has hit it. The cause is a free-body diagram: as the column rotates about its base, the material near the top must be dragged round faster than its own weight would take it, and the material lower down holds back. The bending this needs is largest a third of the way up, at a thirteenth and a half of what the same column would carry standing still at the same tilt — and brick, which carries no tension, cracks there after only a few degrees of lean.

The strong coupling, run from the proton to the Planck mass. The inverse of the strong interaction's coupling, 1/αₛ, against energy on a logarithmic axis, run at one loop from its measured value at the Z mass (1/8.47, dot), with its slope changing at the charm, bottom and top masses as each quark joins in. On this plot the running is a set of straight lines: the coupling weakens by a fixed amount for each factor of ten in energy, about 2.57 per decade above the top mass. At the Planck mass, 1.22 × 10¹⁹ GeV, 1/αₛ is 52.5 — a coupling of 0.0191. Run down instead, it reaches zero — the coupling runs off to infinity — at 143 MeV, the three-flavour scale of the strong interaction at this order. Nineteen decades of energy are crossed by a line that falls from 52 to 0. Astrophysics

The nineteen decades a slow coupling buys

A proton is ten million million million times lighter than the Planck mass, and that ratio, squared, is why gravity between two protons is 10³⁶ times weaker than the electric force between them. It looks like a number demanding an explanation, and it has one. Almost none of the proton's mass comes from the masses of its quarks; it comes from the strong force, whose strength changes with energy by a logarithm. A coupling of about 1/50 at the Planck mass, weakening by a fixed step for every factor of ten in energy, takes nineteen factors of ten to become strong — and the proton's mass is where it does.

Charges released on a field line do not stay on it. A positive and a negative charge (left and right) with their field lines (thin), and the paths of a light positive test charge released at rest from four points 0.32 charge-separations from the positive charge, at 20°, 40°, 55°, 70° from the axis (thick), each beside the field line through its own starting point (dashed). Each path sets off exactly along its line — at rest, the acceleration is the only thing with a direction — and then swings wide of it, because the charge carries its velocity round the bend while the line turns. All four miss the negative charge and leave the frame, never to return, although the field line from every starting point ends on it. Electromagnetism

The path a charge takes is not its field line

A field line is drawn by stepping along the direction of the force, and it is natural to read it as the route a charge would take. It is not. A field line is the curve whose direction is the force; a charge's path is the curve whose bending is the force, and the two agree only where the charge starts from rest. A charge released beside a dipole sets off along its line and then swings wide of it, carried by the speed it has gained; a charge launched round a point charge circles it on an ellipse that crosses every line. Only two things make a charge keep to its line: enough friction that it never has a speed of its own, or a magnetic field.

Thrown across a uniform field, a fast charge does not draw a parabola. The paths of a charge launched across a uniform electric field (which points up the page) at 0.30, 0.60, 0.90, 0.99 of the speed of light, from the exact relativistic motion (solid), beside the parabolas Newton's law gives for the same launches (dashed); lengths are in units of mc²/qE, the distance over which the field does work equal to the charge's rest energy. Near its launch each exact path is a parabola, but one with the inertia γ₀m in place of m, so it is deflected less than Newton says — 1.05, 1.25, 2.29, 7.09 times less for the four. Further out each turns steeply along the field: one unit across, the 0.3c charge is 11.6 units along where Newton says 5.6, because its sideways speed has fallen while the field kept pushing. Each exact path is a hyperbolic cosine. The field adds to the momentum along it while the sideways momentum stays fixed, and the charge's growing energy is a growing inertia that slows its sideways progress. Relativity

The throw a uniform field bends into a chain

Throw a stone sideways across the Earth's gravity and it draws a parabola. Throw a charge sideways across a uniform electric field and, at low speed, it does the same. At high speed it draws a different curve, a hyperbolic cosine — the shape of a chain hanging between two posts, stretched — and the reason is that nothing pushes it sideways yet its sideways speed falls. Its sideways momentum is fixed, the field keeps adding energy, and energy is inertia. The charge gets only logarithmically far across the field however long it flies, and its sideways distance turns out to be a reading of its own clock.

Four regimes along one line of mixed states. The weight p of the singlet in Werner's mixture of a singlet and complete noise, from 0 (pure noise) to 1 (a perfect singlet), divided by what is known about it. Below p = 1/3 the state is separable: it can be made by handing out unentangled pairs. Above 1/3 it is entangled, by the partial-transpose test. Yet up to at least p = 1/2 — Werner's explicit model of 1989 — and, by a later argument through Grothendieck's constant, up to about 0.66, a local hidden-variable model reproduces the outcomes of every pair of projective measurements on it, so no Bell experiment of that kind can reveal the entanglement. Above 1/√2 ≈ 0.707 the CHSH inequality is violated. Between about 0.66 and 0.71 (and, by more recent searches, between about 0.68 and 0.70) it is not known whether any Bell inequality is broken. Quantum

The entangled pair a list of answers can imitate

Entanglement and the violation of a Bell inequality are usually spoken of as the same thing, and they are not. Mix a perfect singlet with random noise and the pair stays entangled until the noise is two-thirds of the mixture. It stops violating the CHSH inequality much sooner, when the noise passes three-tenths. In between lies a family of genuinely entangled states whose every measurement can be reproduced by particles carrying instructions fixed in advance — Reinhard Werner wrote the instructions down in 1989. The entanglement in those states is real and can be spent, on teleportation for one thing. It simply cannot be seen by asking two distant analysers what they find.

The extra work in letting the gas expand further. Pressure against volume, the volume in units of the combustion chamber and the pressure on a logarithmic axis, for two ideal engines that compress the charge by the same ratio of 10 and add the same heat: an Otto cycle that expands by 10 too and throws away gas still at 3.8 bar (dashed), and an over-expanded cycle that lets the burned gas expand 26.8 times, until it is back at the 1 bar it came in at (solid). The shaded region between the expansion line and the intake pressure, beyond the Otto engine's stroke, is where the extra work is done (on this logarithmic axis its area is not to scale): 136 kJ per kilogram of charge, raising the efficiency from 55.3 to 63.6 per cent. It is taken from gas that an Otto engine releases through its exhaust valve still pushing. Thermodynamics

The engine that expands further than it compresses

A petrol engine's efficiency is usually quoted as a function of its compression ratio, and its compression ratio is held near ten because a higher one makes the fuel detonate. But the efficiency does not come from the compression. It comes from the expansion — from how far the burned gas is allowed to push the piston before it is thrown away — and an ordinary engine expands its gas exactly as far as it compressed it, simply because the same cylinder does both. Let the gas expand further than it was compressed and most of what a higher compression ratio would have given comes back with no knock at all. The price is paid in power, and it is why the most efficient petrol engines on the road are built this way.

Two measures of how uncertain a split state is. For the two-peaked state, against half the separation of the peaks in units of their width: Heisenberg's product σₓσₚ divided by its minimum ħ/2 (solid), and the entropic sum Hₓ + Hₚ minus its minimum ln(πeħ) (dashed), both computed from the state's distributions. As the peaks separate the product grows without limit, 8.1 times the minimum at the right of the figure, because the variance counts the empty space between the peaks as uncertainty. The entropic excess levels off at 2 ln 2 − 1 = 0.386 (0.386 at the right): the position's entropy gains ln 2, one bit, for not knowing which peak, and the momentum's gives back 1 − ln 2 because its fringes pack it into narrow bands. The entropic relation says what is true of the state: it is a fraction of a coin toss away from a minimum-uncertainty packet, however far apart the two places are. Quantum

The sharpness a variance cannot see

Heisenberg's inequality is a statement about standard deviations, and a standard deviation is a poor measure of how sharply something is known. A particle that is certainly in one of two narrow places a metre apart has a position spread of half a metre, and satisfies the inequality with room to spare while being sharply localised. Measure uncertainty by information instead — by the Shannon entropy of each distribution — and the relation tightens: the sum of the two entropies has a floor that the split state cannot get under either, and the floor survives in places where the variance form says nothing at all.

A chaotic rotor heats without limit, and its quantum version stops. The mean kinetic energy of a rotor kicked once a period by a potential of strength K = 5, against the number of kicks, starting at rest. Classically (an ensemble of 4,000 rotors with random angles) the motion is chaotic and the momentum random-walks, so the energy grows in a straight line, 6.3 per kick, near the K²/4 = 6.25 a random walk of kicks K sin θ gives. Quantum mechanically, with an effective Planck constant ƛ = 1 and 0.5, the energy follows the classical line for a while and then stops, fluctuating about 58 and 123: the smaller ƛ lets it follow the classical growth for longer and climb further before it stops. Nothing in the quantum rotor's equations damps it; the growth stops by interference. Quantum

The heating a quantum rotor refuses

Kick a freely turning rotor hard, at regular intervals, and classical mechanics says its motion becomes chaotic and its energy grows without limit, the momentum random-walking upward with every kick. Do the same to a quantum rotor and it follows the classical heating for a while, then stops — not because anything damps it, but because the waves of its momentum states interfere so as to cancel further spreading. The correspondence principle, which promises classical behaviour when quantum numbers are large, is broken here in the most direct way: by a quantum system that refuses to get hot.

The same damped motion in two phase planes. A cloud of damped oscillators that start on a small circle of positions and velocities, drawn at times 0, 2, 4, 6 (outlines) with the centre's path. Left: position against the physical momentum mẋ. The cloud spirals inward and shrinks: its area falls as e^(−γt), to 0.30 of its start by t = 6, as friction squeezes every motion towards rest. Right: position against the canonical momentum of the Caldirola–Kanai Lagrangian, p = e^(γt)mẋ. The same cloud keeps exactly its starting area while it is stretched out of shape, as Liouville's theorem requires of any Hamiltonian flow. The friction has been hidden in the definition of momentum: the canonical momentum grows exactly as fast as the real one decays. Mechanics

The friction an action can hold only by changing its clock

The principle of least action generates every conservative law of motion from a single integral, and it has no place for friction: there is no ordinary Lagrangian whose equation of motion is a damped oscillator's. Multiply the Lagrangian by an exponential of time and friction appears — but only by redefining momentum so that it grows as fast as the real momentum decays. The phase-space area the principle conserves is then no longer the one that counts motions, and quantised, the damped oscillator becomes more sharply known than the uncertainty principle allows. Friction belongs to a system and the surroundings it loses energy to, and an action for the system alone can only fake it.

How fine a grid has to be to polarise. The fraction of the power transmitted by a grid of thin parallel wires, against the ratio of the wire spacing d to the wavelength, on logarithmic axes — for the field along the wires with three wire radii (solid), and for the field across the wires with the thickest (dashed), from the quasi-static theory of strip gratings, valid while the spacing is under about half a wavelength. Across the wires nearly everything passes at every spacing. Along them the leak is about four times the square of (d/λ)·ln(d/2πa): 0.1% of the power at a spacing of a hundredth of a wavelength, 10% at a tenth, 64% at four-tenths, for wires of radius 3% of their spacing. Thicker wires block better because the inductance of the grid falls. The diamond marks Hertz's grid of 1888, 4% leaking along the wires; a visible-light polariser needs the same ratio at a wavelength of half a micrometre, which means wires about 140 nanometres apart. Optics

The grid that stops the light along its wires

A row of parallel wires looks like a fence, and a fence ought to let through a wave that shakes along its slats. A grid of wires does the opposite. A field along the wires drives electrons up and down them, the currents re-radiate, and the wave is reflected; a field across the wires can move charge only through a wire's width, and passes. Heinrich Hertz used such a grid in 1888 to show that his new waves were polarised. The same grid, shrunk two hundred thousand times to wires 140 nanometres apart, polarises visible light in projectors — and every sheet of polarising plastic is the same idea made from chains of iodine.

The bend that depends on when the planet was there. The difference, in microarcseconds, between the quasar's deflection computed from Jupiter's position when the light passed it — its position as seen from the Earth, 53 minutes earlier — and from its position at the moment of observation, over the day of the 2002 pass. In those 53 minutes Jupiter moves 40998 km, 0.57 of its own radius, and the deflection, a vector of 1.14 mas pointing away from the planet, turns and shrinks by up to 46 µas — about one twenty-fifth of itself. That small term was what the experiment was designed to see. The VLBA measured 51 ± 9 µas, the value general relativity predicts for a deflection pointing away from the position light reveals. Astrophysics

The bend a moving planet gives

Jupiter bends starlight by sixteen thousandths of an arcsecond at its edge, a hundredth of what the Sun manages, and in 2002 radio telescopes spread across a continent measured the bend on a quasar three and a half arcminutes from the planet. The experiment was designed to see something smaller still: the fact that Jupiter moves, by half its own width in the time light takes to reach the Earth, so that the bend depends on where the planet was when the light went past. The measured term was announced as the speed of gravity, and the argument over whether it was anything of the kind is the clearest lesson there is in what an experiment's number is a number of.

Where the charge goes on a conducting egg. The surface charge on three conducting spheroids of the same length, a sphere and spheroids 3 and 10 times as long as they are wide, drawn as a band whose thickness is proportional to the charge per unit area at each point. On the sphere it is uniform. On an ellipsoid the density is exactly proportional to the fourth root of the surface's Gaussian curvature, and so it is 3 and 10 times as dense at the tips as at the waist — not the 9 and 100 times by which the tips' curvature exceeds the waist's, and not the ratio of their mean curvatures either. The charge does crowd to the sharp ends, but by how much is set by the whole shape, not by any property of the surface at the point. Electromagnetism

The charge that follows no local rule

Charge on a conductor crowds where the surface curves sharply, and every high-voltage engineer rounds the edges for that reason. But curves sharply by what measure? On a conducting egg the density is exactly the fourth root of the surface's Gaussian curvature, so a tip a hundred times more curved than the waist carries only ten times the charge. On two spheres joined by a wire it is the square root, and on a flat disc the density goes without limit at the rim, where no curvature is defined. No local rule can be right, because where charge sits is decided by the whole shape at once.

The resistance a pan offers the coil. The surface resistance — the square root of πfμρ — of five pan materials against frequency, on logarithmic axes, with the band where induction hobs work, 20 to 100 kHz, shaded. All five rise as the square root of the frequency. At 25 kHz carbon steel offers 9.9·10⁻⁴ Ω and ferritic stainless 0.0024 Ω, while austenitic stainless, which is not magnetic, offers 2.7·10⁻⁴ Ω, aluminium 5.1·10⁻⁵ Ω and copper 4.1·10⁻⁵ Ω. For the same coil current the heating goes as this resistance, so steel heats 19 times as hard as aluminium. Matching steel with aluminium by frequency alone would need 377 times the frequency — 9 MHz, where the hob's own electronics and coil would be the problem. Electromagnetism

The pan a better conductor will not heat

An induction hob heats a pan with currents the pan carries itself, driven by a field oscillating twenty-five thousand times a second, and it will heat a cast-iron skillet furiously while an aluminium saucepan, which conducts electricity six times better, barely warms. The better conductor is the worse load. What a pan presents to the coil is a surface resistance that goes as the square root of permeability times resistivity, and on that measure iron beats aluminium twenty times over. The same arithmetic explains why kitchen foil on the same hob can catch fire, and why a steel tip heated this way switches itself off at a fixed temperature.

The push that makes an electron swing. An electron in a band of width 4J, pushed by a constant force F = 0.25 J per lattice spacing, over two Bloch periods h/Fa. Above: its crystal momentum, which grows steadily as Newton's law says it should, and is folded back each time it reaches the edge of the Brillouin zone, ±π/a. Below: its position, in lattice spacings, which does not grow steadily at all. The electron's velocity is the slope of the band, and the slope reverses at the zone edge, so it moves forward, slows, stops 16 lattice spacings along — 4J/F — and comes back, oscillating instead of accelerating. A free particle with the band-bottom effective mass, pushed by the same force, is dashed: the two agree only for the first fraction of a period. The electron is not stopped by anything; it is turned round by the lattice, which takes the momentum the force gives it. Quantum

The push that makes an electron swing

Push a free electron with a steady force and it accelerates for as long as the force lasts. Push an electron in a crystal with the same force and, according to the band theory every transistor depends on, it should do something else entirely: move forward, slow, stop, come back and do it again, oscillating on the spot at a frequency set by the force and the lattice spacing. Felix Bloch's oscillation was predicted in 1928 and not seen for sixty-four years, because in a real metal the electron is knocked off course ten thousand times before it completes one swing. It was found in crystals built with a thirty-times-larger spacing, and in lattices made of light where nothing scatters at all.

A longer road against a faster car. For a proton with 0.1% more momentum than the design proton in a ring 628 m round, the change in its time per turn, in picoseconds, against the Lorentz factor: from its longer orbit, which adds about 56 ps a turn at every energy; from its higher speed, which subtracts 605 ps at γ = 2 but only 5.2 ps at γ = 20, because near the speed of light more momentum buys almost no more speed; and the net, computed exactly. The speed wins below γₜ = 6.1 and the path wins above it. In special relativity a body can always be given more momentum, but its speed is capped, and that is the whole cause. Relativity

The energy above which faster arrives later

In a racing circuit a faster car laps sooner. In a proton synchrotron it does too, at first — and then, past a definite energy, the faster proton laps later. Extra momentum sends a proton round a slightly longer orbit and makes it slightly faster, and relativity decides which wins: at low energy the speed does, but near the speed of light more momentum buys almost no more speed, and the longer road takes over. At the crossing, called transition, a spread of momenta stops producing a spread of arrival times, the bunch stops oscillating in time, and the accelerating wave has to jump from one slope to the other in a few turns. The first machine to try it did so in 1959.

Every toss already decided. The outcome of a coin toss as a map of how it was launched: the upward speed in metres per second across, the spin in radians per second up, with the region where the coin shows the face it started with shaded and the region where it shows the other face left clear. A coin spinning about a diameter and caught at the height it left is in the air for 2v/g and turns 2vω/g radians, so the boundaries are the hyperbolae vω = nπg/2, one for every half-turn. Near the origin the bands are wide: a slow toss with little spin is easy to control, and a conjuror's "honest" toss lives there. Nothing in the map is random. Every point is a definite outcome, and the bands are smooth curves — there is no fractal boundary, no region where a tiny change has an unpredictable effect. What makes a toss a fair bet is only how narrow the bands become further out. Mechanics

The toss that is random without chaos

A coin toss is the textbook random event and the textbook deterministic one at the same time. Its flight is a few lines of Newtonian mechanics with no chaos anywhere: two tosses that start almost alike stay almost alike, drifting apart only in proportion to time. Its outcome is fixed the moment it leaves the thumb, by a map of launch speed and spin carved into bands of heads and tails. It is a fair bet because the bands, at a real toss, are only a few per cent wide and no hand repeats itself that well — and it is not quite fair, because a coin wobbles as it flips, and the wobble keeps its starting face up a little more than half the time: 50.8 per cent, predicted in 2007 and counted in 2023 over 350,757 tosses.

Three throws in a spinning room. Balls thrown at 5 m/s from the floor of a station 10 m in radius, spun at 0.99 rad/s (9.5 turns a minute) so that its floor presses with one g, as seen by someone standing in it: at 45° spinward, at 45° antispinward and straight up; with the Earth's parabolas for the two 45° throws dashed. Distances along the floor and heights in metres. On the Earth both 45° throws land 2.55 m away. In the station the spinward throw lands 1.52 m away and the antispinward one 3.06 m away, and the ball thrown straight up comes down 1.30 m ahead of the thrower, spinward. Nothing acts on any of the balls in flight. Each flies straight across the station while the floor turns beneath it, and what the thrower sees as gravity bending the path is the room rotating. Mechanics

The throw a spinning station bends

A space station spun fast enough presses its floor up against its crew with the force of the Earth's gravity, and from the inside it can feel like home. Throw a ball, and the illusion fails. Nothing acts on the ball once it leaves the hand: it flies in a perfectly straight line across the station while the floor turns beneath it, and what the thrower sees as a parabola is a chord of a circle seen from a turning room. In a station ten metres across, a ball thrown up a metre comes down a metre ahead of the hand, a ball thrown with the spin falls short and one thrown against it carries long, and a dropped spanner lands a metre behind the point beneath it. How big a station must be to feel like the Earth is a question projectiles answer.

The focus that moves out of the eye. Parallel rays from a distant object entering a simplified eye 24 mm long, in millimetres along its axis: in air the eye's 61 dioptres bring them to a focus 21.9 mm behind its principal plane, on the retina; under water its 18 dioptres would bring them to a focus 73 mm behind, about three times the length of the eye. On the retina itself the underwater rays have converged only a third of the way, and every point of the scene is spread into a disc the size of the pupil's shadow. The eye is not out of focus by a little, as a short-sighted eye is; it is missing most of a lens. Optics

The eye that loses its lens in water

Eyes opened under water see only a blur, and the reason is not water in the eye or salt or murk. The human eye does two-thirds of its focusing not with its lens but with the curved front of its cornea, whose power comes from the jump in refractive index between air and tissue. Water is almost as dense optically as the cornea, and the jump all but disappears: about forty-three of the eye's sixty dioptres vanish, and the focus moves to three times the eye's own length behind the retina. A mask gives the cornea back its air; a small pupil and a hard squint buy back a little; animals that hunt in both worlds have flattened their corneas and given the work to the lens.

Two fields that part company in the middle. The direction of the electric field of two opposite charges, on the left, and of the magnetic field of a loop of current cut across, on the right, each with a dipole moment pointing up the page. Outside, the arrows of the two pictures are nearly the same and become identical with distance. In the middle, drawn darker, they point opposite ways: the field between the two charges runs from the positive to the negative, downward, against the moment, and the field through the loop runs upward, with it. Field lines of the magnetic dipole close through the middle; those of the electric dipole begin and end there. No measurement made from a long way off can tell them apart. Electromagnetism

Two dipoles that agree everywhere but inside

A pair of opposite charges and a small loop of current make the same field at any distance worth measuring. Between the charges that field points one way, and through the loop it points the other. Shrink both to a point and the disagreement does not vanish: it becomes a term concentrated at the origin, and hydrogen's 21-centimetre line depends on it. The level order of the hydrogen atom says which kind of dipole a proton is.

The band of speeds in which a bicycle rides itself. The growth rates of the small motions of a riderless bicycle against forward speed, from the four roots of the linearised equations for a benchmark machine, with the published eigenvalues reproduced before anything else was drawn. A positive rate means the motion grows. Below 4.29 m/s a pair of roots has positive real part: the weave, a swaying of the steering and lean together, grows. Above 6.02 m/s one real root turns barely positive: the bicycle slowly falls over into a spiral, the capsize. Between these speeds, in the shaded band, all four roots have negative real parts, and a shove dies away on its own with no hand on the bar. Nothing is stabilising the machine except the coupling of lean to steer. Mechanics

The bicycle that steers itself upright

Give a riderless bicycle a shove and, at the right speed, it wobbles and straightens up, and rides on with nobody on it. People have long credited the gyroscopic wheels or the trail of the fork. A machine built in 2011 had neither, and it stayed up. Four numbers, the roots of a quartic, tell the whole story of when a bicycle rides itself, and they do not contain a simple reason.

A fountain in proportion to the drop. The height of the arch above the jar against the drop below it, for three values of α, the share of each link's momentum that the pile supplies. A steady chain has one tension at the top of the arch, equal to its momentum flux λv². Going down either leg the tension falls by the weight of chain below. At the jar the tension must be (1 − α)λv²; at the floor, with the floor taking all of the arriving momentum, it is zero. That gives v²α = gh₁ and h₁ = h₂ α/(1 − α), a straight line through the origin, and no arch at all if α = 0. A measured α near 0.12 gives 27 cm of fountain at a 2 m drop, and this proportion, about a seventh of the drop, is what the experiments found. Mechanics

The chain that climbs out of the jar

Pull the end of a long bead chain over the rim of a jar and let it fall to the floor, and the rest follows, as a siphon does. That much is unsurprising. What a video showed in 2013 was stranger: the chain does not run over the rim. It leaps up from the jar in a standing arch, tens of centimetres above it, with nothing supporting it. The explanation took a year and turned on something a string does not have: a link is stiff, so the pile has to push back.

The rings the full solution finds. The light scattered back by water drops of about 10 µm radius, at 550 nm, from the exact Mie series with around 134 terms for each drop, averaged over a ten per cent spread of sizes so that the fine ripple each single drop has is washed out. Instead of the smooth, weak background of the ray picture, the intensity rises sharply toward 180° through a series of rings about one and a half degrees apart, each brighter than the last, to a first ring 1.5° from straight back. These are what an observer sees round the shadow of an aircraft on a cloud, or round a shadow on a mist at a mountain top: the glory. It is present in the same mathematics that gives the rainbow, and it takes the whole series, with its surface-wave terms, to find. Optics

The rings no ray can reach

Look down from an aircraft at a cloud, and round the aircraft's shadow there may be coloured rings, centred exactly on the point opposite the Sun. Mountain climbers have seen them round their own shadows for centuries, and every drop in that cloud is a sphere of water. Yet ray optics says that a drop of water cannot send light straight back. Its best ray falls fourteen degrees short. The glory lives entirely in those fourteen degrees.

A cooling planet, read from the top. Temperature against depth in a body cooling by conduction from a uniform start at 3870 °C, with a surface held at nought, at four ages: the exact error-function solution for a half-space. Cooling reaches downward as the square root of time, so after a hundred million years the upper few hundred kilometres have cooled and the interior knows nothing about it. The gradient at the surface is what a mine measures, and it falls as the inverse root of time. A thermal gradient therefore gives an age, and this is what Kelvin saw in 1862. He assumed the Earth was a solid conductor from the start, on a good basis, as everyone believed then, and these curves are the mathematical consequence of that belief. Thermodynamics

The age a cooling Earth gives

In 1862 William Thomson, later Lord Kelvin, took a thermometer reading from the bottom of a mine and a piece of mathematics from Fourier and computed the age of the Earth: about a hundred million years. Geologists, needing far longer, had no physics with which to reply. The arithmetic was right. The usual story blames radioactivity for overturning it, but half the heat is not radioactive, and the error lay in assuming the inside of the planet stays still.

One ellipse, turned as it is drawn. A Kepler ellipse of eccentricity 0.4, and the orbit of the same body with an added inverse-cube force that multiplies its angle by 5/4, integrated directly in the plane. Every distance from the centre happens at the same moment as on the ellipse; only the direction differs, so the orbit is the ellipse swung round as it is traced. It closes after four radial periods and five turns. Astrophysics

The one extra force that only turns the orbit

Add a force that falls as the cube of the distance to any orbit under any central force, at exactly the right strength, and the body keeps every distance from the centre at every moment. Only its direction changes, multiplied by a constant. Newton proved it in 1687, and it is why one measured precession can never name the force that caused it.

The current climbs a stair, one round trip a step. Current through the lamp against time for rails with a light-second out to each joined end. It starts at V/(2Z₀+R) = 7.1 mA as soon as the fields have crossed the metre between battery and lamp, stays flat until the reflected fronts return two seconds later, and then rises by steps of about 14 mA at each return. It reaches half of the final 400 mA after about 38 seconds. A time-stepped line gives the same stair as the algebra. Electromagnetism

The lamp that lights before the loop is round

Put a battery and a lamp a metre apart, and connect them with wires that run a light-second out and a light-second back. Close the switch. The lamp begins to carry a current after 3.3 nanoseconds, not two seconds. It is a small current, set by the impedance of the wires, and it climbs to the full value in steps. What reaches the lamp first is a field that never went round.

The same stone, and two different answers. Spin against time from the same stone started at plus and minus 1.5 rad/s, with nothing else changed. One direction stops and reverses at 2.8 s. The other takes until 33.8 s, which is 12 times as long and longer than a real stone keeps turning. A mirror would swap the two, and the mirror image of this stone is a different stone. Mechanics

The stone that turns back against its spin

A polished stone, shaped like half an elongated egg, will spin smoothly one way. Spin it the other way, and within seconds it shudders, stops and turns back, as if its angular momentum had changed its mind. Nothing has broken any law. The trick is a misalignment of about a degree between the axes of its weight and the curve of its base, and with that gone, so is the behaviour.

The middle of an atom gets smaller as it gets heavier. The radius holding half an atom's electrons, in the Thomas–Fermi model, against atomic number: 0.41 Å at Z = 10 and 0.20 Å at Z = 90, shrinking with charge. Marked above are van der Waals radii of the noble gases, which measure where an atom's outside begins and which grow from 1.54 to 2.2 Å over a ninefold increase in electrons. An atom ninety times heavier is about the same size because the crowd inside is drawn in as the crowd outside is added. Quantum

The atom that does not grow with its electrons

A uranium atom has ninety-two electrons and hydrogen one, and uranium is not ninety-two times the volume or anything like it. An atom's middle shrinks as Z to the minus a third while its outside hardly moves, so that nearly all atoms are about the same size. A rough equation from 1927, with no shells and no periodic table in it, explains that, and turns out to be exact in the limit nobody can build.

Two effects that have to add up to nothing. The rate of a clock at sea level, against latitude, relative to a clock at the pole. Being carried at 465 m/s at the equator slows a clock by 1.20 parts in 10¹². The equator's greater height in the well, on the ellipsoid and with the Earth's flattened gravity, makes it run fast by 1.20. Their sum, on this two-term model of the Earth's field, is flat to 9 × 10⁻¹⁵, which is about the size of the terms left out. The international value for that shared rate, computed here for checking, is 6.969290 × 10⁻¹⁰. Relativity

The clocks the sea keeps together

A clock at the equator is moving at 465 m/s and a clock at the pole is not. Einstein said in 1905 that the moving one must run slow. It does not, at sea level, by any amount anyone has detected. The planet has bulged by exactly what it takes to make the difference vanish, and the agreement is not a coincidence. A sea has run downhill until the speed term and the height term add up to the same thing everywhere.

A vane pushed by gas, and only while the gas is thin. The net push on a 1 cm vane per kelvin between its faces, against pressure, from the free-molecule result Δp = p ΔT/2T at low pressure and an interpolation that falls away above the point where the mean free path reaches the vane's size, about 0.67 Pa. The peak is about 335 times the pressure of bright sunlight on the same face. A bulb at ordinary pressure does nothing and a very hard vacuum does nothing either; the toy needs the range between. Thermodynamics

The vane that turns the wrong way

The glass toy with four vanes spinning in sunlight looks as if light is pushing it. It runs in the wrong direction for that. The black faces retreat, where light's own pressure would push back the silver ones. Light's pressure is about three hundred times too feeble, in any case. The rotor is driven by gas, and only at a pressure where the gas's mean free path is about the size of the vane.

The heat runs round in a circle through the wire. A section through a wire moving down through ice, not to scale. Under the wire pressure is high and the melting point is slightly below zero, so ice melts there, and that needs heat. Above it, water at low pressure re-freezes at slightly higher temperature, which gives heat out. The heat has to get from above the wire to below it, and it goes through the wire, so the rate of cutting is set by how fast that one short circuit conducts. The water squeezes round in a thin film. Ice closes behind the wire and it leaves the block whole. Thermodynamics

The wire that goes through the ice and leaves it whole

Hang a weight on a wire over a block of ice, and the wire sinks slowly through it, leaving the block in one piece behind. The usual explanation is that pressure melts the ice under the wire. That is true and misses the point, because the pressure changes the melting point by a few thousandths of a degree. What limits the speed is how fast the wire can carry heat, and a copper wire goes through 160 times faster than a nylon line.

A better glass is harder to hit. The half-width of the resonance in cents, and its ring-up time, against Q at 600 Hz. One falls as the other rises, and their product is fixed. A glass of Q = 100 has a window of ±8.6 cents, inside what a steady voice can hold, and it gains only a hundredfold. A glass of Q = 1000 gains ten times as much, and asks for ±0.9 cents held for over a second. Where a voice's steadiness crosses the window is about the Q at which a voice stops being able to use a further increase, and that is near Q = 173. Waves

The glass a voice can break

A singer can shatter a wine glass, and it is not done by loudness. A good glass answers a tone a thousand times more strongly than a steady push, and it charges for that three times over: the note must be within about a cent, it must be held for over a second, and the glass must be flawed enough to fail. A voice's vibrato turns out to matter far less than its aim.

A drawer that slides freely and then sticks for good. A drawer 60 cm wide whose sides engage 42 cm of runner when closed, μ = 0.35, pulled by one end of a long front, 25 cm from its centreline, and by a handle 6 cm off centre. As it comes out the engaged length shrinks. For the end pull the needed force starts at about 1.7 times a centred pull and runs to infinity after 24.5 cm, where L = 2μe = 17.5 cm: there it jams, however hard it is pulled. With the handle near the middle the same drawer comes out to its stops with the force barely changing. Mechanics

The drawer that jams when pulled by one handle

A wide drawer pulled by a handle at one end comes out a little way and then stops dead, and pulling harder makes it worse. The reason is a pair of corners and a ratio. When the engaged length of the runners falls below twice the friction coefficient times the offset of the pull, no force of any size will move it. The same inequality is the designers' rule for sliding bearings, the reason a peg jams in a hole, and the reason a tighter fit does not help.

One slope that every jump lands on gently. The paths of a jumper leaving a take-off pointed 10° down at five speeds, a point mass with no air, and the landing surface integrated so that each path meets it with a speed into it of √(2g × 0.5 m), as if dropped half a metre. Its shape is not designed by eye: it is the solution of a differential equation that takes, at each point, the one slope that gives that impact. Each path is drawn dashed, with its landing marked. Mechanics

The jump that lands as softly from any distance

A ski jumper flies a hundred metres and lands without injury, while a fall from a few metres onto flat ground breaks bones. The difference is the shape of the ground. A landing slope that runs nearly parallel to the flight path turns most of the fall into speed along the slope, and a slope can be computed, point by point, so that every jumper from the same take-off hits it as hard as a drop of half a metre, whatever their speed.

Magnifying past the brightest image to see more. How far above its threshold a small galaxy 1′ across, with a contrast of 0.6 against a dark sky, stands against magnification in a 200 mm telescope, by the model threshold. At low power it is below threshold: bright but too small for the eye to add up. Visibility rises steeply as it grows, keeps rising past 28.6×, where the image starts to dim, because growing still lowers the threshold faster than dimming raises it, and peaks at 128×, with a 1.6 mm exit pupil. It is above threshold only between 68× and 234×: invisible at the brightest image the telescope can give, and visible at a dimmer, larger one. Optics

The faint thing more magnification shows better

No telescope can make a nebula's surface brighter than the naked eye sees it, and above a certain magnification every further step makes the image dimmer. Yet observers looking for the faintest small galaxies push the magnification up, and they are right to. The eye does not detect brightness. It detects contrast against a threshold, and that threshold falls steeply as an object grows. A dimmer, larger image can cross it where a bright, small one cannot.

Two like charges that pull together when close. The force between two equal conducting spheres both carrying positive charge, against the gap between them, on a signed logarithmic scale, for charge ratios of 1, ½, ⅕ and 1/20. Equal charges repel at every gap. Unequal ones repel when far apart, as Coulomb's law says, and attract once the gap falls below a distance that grows as the charges become more unequal: 0.043 of a radius for a ratio of ½, 0.40 for ⅕, 1.56 for 1/20. The more strongly charged sphere induces a patch of the opposite sign on the near side of the weaker one, and close up that patch wins. Electromagnetism

The like charges that attract at close range

Like charges repel: it is the first rule of electricity anyone learns, and for point charges it never fails. For two charged metal spheres it fails whenever they are close and their charges are unequal. The stronger sphere pulls electrons to the near side of the weaker one, the weaker sphere's own charge is pushed round to its far side, and below a certain gap the induced attraction beats the repulsion. Only one ratio of charges never attracts, and it is the ratio the spheres would share if they touched.

Twenty-one degrees of air that feels like nineteen. The operative temperature in a room whose air is at 21 °C, with −5 °C outside, against how well its outside walls are insulated, for rooms in which outside walls fill 30, 60 and 100 per cent of the surroundings. An uninsulated solid brick wall, U about 2, has its inside face at 14.2 °C; a corner room with two such walls feels 18.4 °C, and a person in it reaches for the thermostat. A modern insulated wall, U of 0.2, sits within half a degree of the air and the room feels like its thermometer. Thermodynamics

The room that is cold at twenty-one degrees

A thermometer on the wall of an old stone house in winter reads twenty-one degrees, and everyone in the room is cold. The thermometer is right about the air. A seated person loses about two-thirds of their heat by radiation to the walls, ceiling and windows, and a body measures the temperature of what surrounds it more than the air it sits in. Warming that air to make up for cold walls costs nearly three degrees of air for each degree of comfort.

Each centimetre of depth is a weight on the chest. The suction the breathing muscles must produce to draw air from the surface, against the depth of the chest below it, ρgd, beside the strongest suction healthy adults can make for a moment and the much smaller load they can sustain breath after breath. A metre of water is 9.8 kPa, about the most a typical adult can manage in a single all-out effort. A load that can be kept up for minutes, about 1.5 kPa, is reached at 15 cm. That is the snorkel's real depth limit, and it has nothing to do with the tube. Fluids

The snorkel that cannot be made longer

A snorkel is about thirty-five centimetres long, and the obvious improvement — a longer one, so a swimmer could stay a metre or two down and breathe from the surface — has been drawn in notebooks since antiquity and does not work. Two separate limits close on it. The chest has to expand against the water's weight while the air it draws is at the surface's pressure, a load no breathing muscle can sustain much below a few tens of centimetres; and the tube's own volume is breathed back and forth, so a longer tube delivers less fresh air with every breath.

A bridge that never feels the boat crossing it. The weight of water an aqueduct 300 m long, 6.5 m wide and 2.7 m deep carries, against the position of an 80-tonne boat crossing it, with ten kilometres of canal joined to it. The boat pushes its own weight of water out of the aqueduct, and the water spreads along the whole reach, raising it by 1.2 millimetres. The load stays at 5265 tonnes whether the boat is on the aqueduct or not; a road bridge would gain the vehicle's whole weight. The aqueduct is designed for its water alone, and a boat crossing it is invisible to the structure. Fluids

The bridge that does not feel the boat

An aqueduct carries a canal across a valley, and a barge of eighty tonnes crosses it. The aqueduct carries no more weight with the barge on it than without, because a floating barge pushes out exactly its own weight of water, and the water goes elsewhere. Boat lifts are built on the same fact: a caisson of water weighs the same whatever floats in it, so two caissons balance whatever boats they carry, and the only thing that needs measuring is the water level.

The orbit a stretched sheet draws. A ball released sideways on a stretched elastic sheet dimpled by a central weight, at three-quarters of the speed for a circular orbit, seen from above, integrated from the exact equation of motion for a frictionless ball on the surface. A sheet under a point load sags logarithmically, which gives a force falling as 1/r, not 1/r², and the orbit is a rosette whose closest approaches come 131° apart, near the 127° of a 1/r force, never an ellipse. The demonstration shows orbits; it does not show Kepler's. Astrophysics

The sheet that cannot keep Kepler's orbits

A stretched elastic sheet with a heavy ball in the middle is the most popular picture of gravity there is: marbles roll round the dip like planets round a star. But a sheet pulled down by a point load sags as the logarithm of the distance, which is the potential of gravity in two dimensions, not three. Its marbles feel a force falling as 1/r, trace rosettes whose closest approaches are 127° apart instead of ellipses, and take a period proportional to their radius. The surface that does draw Kepler's orbits is a funnel shaped as −1/r, and only where it is shallow.

An attractive surface that reflects slow atoms. The probability that an atom approaching a surface is reflected by the surface's attraction alone, before reaching the surface, against its wavenumber in units of the length β₄ = √(2mC₄)/ħ set by the attraction, from the Schrödinger equation solved with everything reaching the surface absorbed. Fast atoms fall in and stick. Slow ones are turned back by a potential that only ever pulls them forward, with a reflection that approaches one as R ≈ 1 − 4.0 kβ₄. For atoms near a solid β₄ is a fraction of a micrometre, and kβ₄ = 0.1 is reached at speeds of millimetres per second. Quantum

The cliff a slow atom bounces off

A ball rolling towards the edge of a cliff goes over it, and so does every classical particle that meets a drop in potential energy. A quantum particle may bounce back. The faster its potential energy falls, the more of its wave is reflected, and as the particle slows the reflection rises towards certainty, however gently the drop is shaped. Slow atoms approaching a surface that attracts them, and would capture them if they arrived, are turned back by that attraction alone, in a region where nothing pushes them away.

Every pure spin owes at least two bits. The total uncertainty, in bits, of the answers to three questions about a spin-½ — is it up along x, along y, along z — for pure states round two great circles of directions. A spin along z answers the z question with certainty and the other two as coin tosses: 0 + 1 + 1 = 2 bits, the least any pure state can have. A spin tilted equally towards all three axes is uncertain about every question and sums to 2.232 bits, the most. Every pure state lies between, a narrow band: the three questions together cannot be answered with less than two bits of doubt. Quantum

The third question pairwise bounds miss

Ask a spin-½ whether it points up along x, along y and along z, and quantum mechanics guarantees that the three answers together carry at least two bits of uncertainty. No pairwise uncertainty relation says so: added up across the three pairs they promise only one and a half bits, and the best general formula for many questions promises 1.755. The true floor is higher than any bound built from its parts, the familiar variance relation cannot see it at all, and an entangled partner can remove it entirely.

Light bent by a mass, exactly and to two orders. The deflection of a ray passing a mass, against its impact parameter in units of GM/c², integrated exactly from the Schwarzschild orbit equation and compared with the first-order 4GM/c²b and with the series carried to second order. Far out the three agree. At b = 10 the exact bend is 0.590 radians and the first-order term misses it by 32 per cent; adding the second-order term brings it within 12 per cent. Near b = 3√3 GM/c², the photon sphere, the exact bend grows without limit while every term of the series stays finite. Astrophysics

The second term in the bending of light

Starlight grazing the Sun is bent by 1.75 arcseconds, and the formula that gives it, four times GM over c² times the impact parameter, is the first term of a series. The second term is eleven millionths of an arcsecond at the Sun's edge. It is too small to have been seen, and it is not small enough to ignore: it is half the size of the change any surviving rival to general relativity could make, so a measurement good enough to test the theory further must compute it first. It also has the odd property that its size depends on which distance it is written in.

Sunlight through a drop on a leaf, and through one held above it. Vertical sunlight traced through a drop sitting on a leaf with a contact angle of 40°, one at 90° (a hemisphere), and a whole drop held up on hairs with its bottom one radius above the leaf. A drop sitting on the leaf bends the light inwards, but the leaf intercepts it long before it converges: the dashed lines show where it was heading, several base radii below the surface. Only the drop held clear of the leaf brings the light to a focus on it. Optics

The drop that cannot burn the leaf it sits on

Gardeners are often told not to water plants in sunshine, because the drops act as little lenses and scorch the leaves. A drop of water is a lens, and a strong one. But a drop sitting on a leaf has its back against the leaf, and the leaf intercepts the light long before it can converge: for any contact angle at all, the focus lies at least 2.83 footprint radii below the surface, and the brightest light under the drop is under twice direct sunlight. Only a drop held clear of the surface, on hairs, puts its focus on the leaf — and there, it concentrates sunlight more than a thousandfold.

The eye's focusing range shrinks steadily from childhood. How many dioptres of extra focusing power the eye can add for near work, against age, by Hofstetter's three lines through Duane's measurements. The mean falls 0.3 D a year from about 16 D at eight, without a break. Print at 40 cm needs 2.5 D, and holding it comfortably for long needs about twice that; the mean line crosses 5 D at 45, which is when reading first gets hard, and 2.5 D at 53, when it cannot be done at all. Nothing happens at forty-five except that a falling line crosses a fixed one. Past sixty the measured range levels off near half a dioptre, the eye's depth of focus. Optics

The focus the eye loses a little every year

Somewhere in their forties nearly everyone starts holding books further away, and the change feels sudden: one year print is fine, a year or two later the arms are not long enough. Nothing sudden has happened to the eye. The range over which its lens can change its power has been shrinking by about a third of a dioptre a year since childhood, along a nearly straight line. What arrives at forty-five is the moment that line crosses the two and a half dioptres a book at forty centimetres asks for, twice over. The near point, being one over that range, races away just as the range runs out.

Friction decides when the ball rolls, not how fast. A solid ball set down sliding at 5 m/s without spin, on three surfaces of friction coefficient 0.1, 0.2 and 0.4. Friction slows the centre (solid) and spins up the rim (dashed) until the two speeds meet and the ball rolls. They meet at 3.571 m/s, five-sevenths of the start, on every surface; the stickier surface only gets there sooner, in 0.36 s against 1.46 s. Mechanics

The ball that forgets how rough the floor was

Set a ball down sliding without spin and friction does two things at once: it slows the ball and it spins it up, until the two motions agree and the ball rolls. On ice that takes a long time and on felt a short one, but the speed the ball finally rolls at is the same — five-sevenths of what it started with — and so is the heat the skid produced. Friction decides where the rolling begins and nothing else. The reason is a quantity friction cannot touch, and the same reasoning explains why a bowling ball skids straight down the oil and then hooks.

The phase slides to the edge of the swing, and the gain stops. The phase at which a proton crosses the accelerating gap, measured from the crest of a 100 kV swing, against the energy it has gained, turn by turn. Every turn the proton arrives a little later than the last, by 2π(γ − 1). Starting on the crest, it slides to the edge of the swing and stops gaining at 7.7 MeV; starting near the trough, it sweeps the whole swing and stops at 10.9 MeV; with the voltage reversing 1.14% slower than the slow proton circles, the phase first runs back and then forward, and the limit doubles to 21.8 MeV. Relativity

The cyclotron that falls out of step

A charge in a magnetic field goes round at a rate that does not depend on how fast it is going: a faster particle runs a bigger circle in the same time. That coincidence is the whole of the cyclotron — a voltage reversing at one fixed rate can kick the particle every half turn for ever. Relativity breaks it. A proton's rate of going round falls one per cent for every nine and a half MeV it gains, each turn it arrives a little later at the gap, and after a hundred or so turns it is arriving when the voltage pushes the wrong way. The ceiling this sets rises only as the square root of the voltage, and getting past it took two ideas that are still how accelerators work.

Three kilograms on the scale, and the lungs account for 1.3 of them. The weight under water of a 75 kg person who is 18% fat, broken into its parts. The body's tissue alone would weigh 4.51 kg submerged; the 1.3 L of air the lungs cannot empty holds up 1.29 kg of that, and gas in the gut another 0.10, so the scale reads 3.12 kg. The measurement of body fat is made from this reading, and the lungs' air alone is worth 41% of it. Fluids

The weighing that is mostly a measurement of air

To measure how much of a body is fat, a person is weighed in air and then again lying under water after breathing out as hard as possible. The difference is Archimedes' principle applied to a human being, and it gives the body's volume and so its density. The reading under water for a 75 kg person is about three kilograms — and the air that no amount of breathing out can expel from the lungs is holding up 1.3 kilograms of it. Every tenth of a litre of that air misjudged moves the answer by two-thirds of a percentage point of fat. The weighing is an exquisite measurement of something else.

A soil is a distribution of pore sizes, read as a curve. Water content against suction for class-average sand, loam, silt loam and clay, from van Genuchten curves with Carsel and Parrish's parameters. Sand's pores are almost all wide, so it is nearly empty by field capacity, holding 0.05 of its volume. Clay's are very fine, so it is still wet at the wilting point, holding 0.27 — water a plant cannot extract. Between the two lines, field capacity at 33 kPa and wilting at 1.5 MPa, silt loam gives up 0.14 of its volume, loam 0.08, clay 0.08 and sand 0.001. Fluids

The water a soil keeps from the plant

Two days after a soaking rain a field has drained all the water it is going to drain, and soil scientists call what remains its field capacity. A plant then draws water out until it can pull no harder, and wilts; what is left is the wilting point. Both are suctions, and every suction is a pore size: field capacity is the water held in pores narrower than 4.4 micrometres, the wilting point the water in pores narrower than a tenth of a micrometre. A clay soil can be visibly damp, a quarter water by volume, and give a plant nothing — because the soil it is in equilibrium with is in equilibrium with air at 98.9 per cent humidity.

A kernel is a pressure cooker with a ten-bar lid. The pressure at which water boils against its temperature, from 90 to 200 °C. Water sealed in a container cannot boil off; it heats, and its vapour pressure climbs this curve until the container fails. A domestic pressure cooker holds about 2.0 bar absolute and cooks at 121 °C. A popcorn kernel's hull holds about ten — 10.0 bar at 180 °C, the temperature at which kernels are measured to pop — and the water inside it is then 80 degrees hotter than water can be in an open pan. Thermodynamics

The kernel that is a pressure cooker until it bursts

A popcorn kernel is a drop of water sealed in a nearly steam-tight shell. Heated, the water cannot boil off; it climbs water's boiling curve instead, and by the time the shell gives way, near 180 °C, the steam inside is at about ten bar — five times what a kitchen pressure cooker holds. When the shell fails the water is eighty degrees hotter than water can be at one atmosphere, and the stored heat turns half of it to steam in an instant. Almost all of that energy leaves as steam. The foam it leaves behind takes a few per cent; the leap across the pan, about a millijoule.

Past the skin's vapour pressure, the steam pays its latent heat to the skin. The heat flowing into skin at 37 °C from sauna air at 80 °C, against the air's vapour pressure, for skin wet with sweat and for dry skin, with a convective coefficient of 8 W/m²K. Below 6.26 kPa sweat can evaporate and wet skin is cooled; above it vapour condenses on the skin, wet or dry, and every gram delivers 2.4 kJ. A typical Finnish sauna at 10% humidity, 4.7 kPa, sends 164 W/m² into sweating skin. A 0.2 L ladle on the stones of a 10 m³ room adds 3.3 kPa and the flux becomes 547 W/m² — 3.3 times as much — at the same air temperature. Thermodynamics

The ladle that makes a sauna hotter without warming it

Throw a ladle of water on the stones of a Finnish sauna and a wave of heat rolls down from the ceiling and stings the skin — while the thermometer on the wall barely moves. The heat is real and it is not in the air's temperature. Skin at 37 °C has its own vapour pressure, 6.3 kilopascals; air with less vapour than that lets sweat evaporate and cools the skin, air with more condenses on it and pays it 2.4 kilojoules for every gram. A ladle carries the room across that line. What skin feels is the wet-bulb temperature of the air, and a thermometer cannot read it.

All themes