Mechanics

The ball that forgets how rough the floor was

Set a ball down sliding without spin and friction does two things at once: it slows the ball and it spins it up, until the two motions agree and the ball rolls. On ice that takes a long time and on felt a short one, but the speed the ball finally rolls at is the same — five-sevenths of what it started with — and so is the heat the skid produced. Friction decides where the rolling begins and nothing else. The reason is a quantity friction cannot touch, and the same reasoning explains why a bowling ball skids straight down the oil and then hooks.

Assumes: The quantity that survives a change of shape · The force that takes what it needs

A snooker ball struck through its centre leaves the cue sliding, not rolling. For a short distance it skids across the cloth with no spin at all; then, as friction works on it, it begins to turn, and within a few tenths of a second it is rolling smoothly and the skid is over. A bowling ball does the same over a much longer distance, and so does a ball bowled along a pavement or a cylinder slid down a ramp. The transition from sliding to rolling is one of the most common events in mechanics, and one of the least looked at, because it is over so quickly.

It contains a small surprise. Friction is plainly what makes the ball roll, and plainly something that takes energy. One would expect a rougher surface to take more energy and leave the ball slower. It does not. A ball set down sliding at five metres a second, on ice, on cloth or on rubber, rolls away at the same speed every time, and turns the same share of its energy into heat on the way. The roughness decides only how long the skid lasts and how far it goes.

Two speeds that friction pushes together

A sliding ball has two velocities worth naming. Its centre moves at vv. The point of the ball touching the floor moves, relative to the centre, at RωR\omega backwards if the ball spins forward at ω\omega, so the contact point moves over the floor at u=v−Rωu = v - R\omega. Rolling without slipping is the condition u=0u = 0: the contact point is momentarily at rest, as the force that takes what it needs put it, and static friction does no work.

While uu is not zero, kinetic friction acts at the contact, with magnitude μmg\mu mg, against the slip. On a ball sliding forward without spin, that force points backwards. It slows the centre, at μg\mu g; and because it acts at the bottom of the ball, a distance RR below the centre, it exerts a torque μmgR\mu mgR that spins the ball forward. For a ball whose moment of inertia is κmR2\kappa mR^2 — κ=2/5\kappa = 2/5 for a uniform solid sphere, 2/32/3 for a thin shell, the dependence on where the mass sits that the mass and where it sits laid out — the rim speed RωR\omega grows at μg/κ\mu g/\kappa.

Friction decides when the ball rolls, not how fast. A solid ball set down sliding at 5 m/s without spin, on three surfaces of friction coefficient 0.1, 0.2 and 0.4. Friction slows the centre (solid) and spins up the rim (dashed) until the two speeds meet and the ball rolls. They meet at 3.571 m/s, five-sevenths of the start, on every surface; the stickier surface only gets there sooner, in 0.36 s against 1.46 s.
Fig. 1 A solid ball set down sliding at 5 m/s without spin, on surfaces of friction coefficient 0.1, 0.2 and 0.4. Friction slows the centre (solid) and spins up the rim (dashed) until the two speeds meet and the ball rolls. They meet at 3.571 m/s, five-sevenths of the start, on every surface; the stickier surface only gets there sooner, in 0.36 s against 1.46 s.

The two speeds approach each other linearly, one falling at μg\mu g and the other rising at μg/κ\mu g/\kappa, and they meet when the slip has gone. Doubling the friction doubles both slopes, which halves the time, and leaves the meeting point exactly where it was. For a solid sphere the meeting point is v0/(1+κ)=5v0/7v_0/(1 + \kappa) = 5v_0/7. The figure’s three pairs of lines are the same triangle drawn at three horizontal scales.

The quantity friction cannot reach

That the answer does not contain μ\mu is not a coincidence of the arithmetic. It follows from asking about the right quantity about the right point.

Friction acts at the contact point. Gravity and the floor’s normal force act along the vertical line through it. So about the contact point — strictly, about a fixed point on the floor that the contact passes over, which is enough because the contact moves parallel to the force — none of the forces on the ball has a lever arm, and the ball’s angular momentum about that point does not change during the skid. The quantity that survives a change of shape made angular momentum’s conservation the reason a skater spins faster with arms drawn in; here it is the reason a skid has a predictable end.

The angular momentum of a ball about a point on the floor is its spin, κmR2ω\kappa mR^2\omega, plus the moment of its centre’s motion, mRvmRv. At the start that is mR(v0+κRω0)mR(v_0 + \kappa R\omega_0). At the end, rolling, Rω=vR\omega = v, so it is mRv(1+κ)mRv(1 + \kappa). Setting them equal:

vroll=v0+κRω01+κ.v_\text{roll} = \frac{v_0 + \kappa R\omega_0}{1 + \kappa}.

Nothing about the surface enters. Any friction law at all — a coefficient that varies with speed, a patch of chalk on the cloth, a damp spot on a lane — gives the same final speed, provided the friction acts at the contact and the ball does not leave the floor. The friction law decides the history; the conservation law decides the outcome.

Spin set by the cue, and the height that needs no skid

The formula has a second variable, the starting spin, and it is the one a snooker player controls. Writing s=Rω0/v0s = R\omega_0/v_0 for the ratio of rim speed to centre speed at the start, the rolling speed is (1+κs)/(1+κ)(1 + \kappa s)/(1 + \kappa) times the starting speed: a straight line.

The rolling speed is fixed the moment the ball leaves the cue. The speed a ball finally rolls at, as a fraction of its starting speed, against the spin it starts with (rim speed over centre speed: positive is topspin, negative backspin), for a solid ball and a thin shell. The answer is (1 + κs)/(1 + κ), a straight line with no friction in it. A solid ball with no spin keeps 5/7; one struck level with a point 7/5 of the radius above the table starts with exactly rolling spin and keeps all its speed; backspin of 2.5 brings it to a stop, and more brings it back.
Fig. 2 The speed a ball finally rolls at, as a fraction of its starting speed, against the spin it starts with (rim speed over centre speed: positive topspin, negative backspin), for a solid ball and a thin shell. A solid ball with no spin keeps 5/7; one struck level with a point 7/5 of the radius above the table starts with rolling spin and keeps all its speed; backspin of 2.5 brings it to a stop, and more brings it back.

A cue striking horizontally a height hh above the ball’s centre gives it a velocity J/mJ/m and a spin Jh/κmR2Jh/\kappa mR^2, so s=h/κRs = h/\kappa R. For a solid ball, striking at h=2R/5h = 2R/5 — at seven-fifths of the radius above the table — gives s=1s = 1, which is rolling: the ball leaves the cue rolling and never skids, and loses nothing to friction. That height is the ball’s centre of percussion, the point the point that takes the blow without a jolt found on a bat, where an impulse produces no reaction at the pivot. A ball resting on a table pivots about its contact point, and the point where a blow produces no tendency to slip there is the same point where a blow on a bat produces no sting in the hand. Billiard cushions are built at roughly that height for the same reason: a ball meeting a cushion there rebounds without being driven into the cloth or lifted off it.

Below the centre the spin is backwards. A snooker player’s screw shot strikes low, giving backspin; the ball skids forward, friction slows it and unwinds the backspin, and if s<−1/κ=−2.5s < -1/\kappa = -2.5 the backspin outlasts the forward motion and the ball comes back. A stun shot, struck to give s=−2.5s = -2.5 exactly, stops the cue ball dead after a skid, which is what a player wants when it strikes an object ball squarely and should stay where it was. A thin shell, with κ=2/3\kappa = 2/3, needs less backspin to stop, s=−1.5s = -1.5, and loses less of its speed when struck without spin: it keeps 3/53/5 against the solid ball’s 5/75/7. Hollow balls and solid ones skid differently, and a player who swapped one for the other would feel it.

Where the energy goes, and why that does not depend on friction either

A ball that loses two-sevenths of its speed of centre but gains spin has lost some kinetic energy, and the loss is the heat the skid makes at the contact. It too is fixed.

The heat the skid makes does not depend on the friction either. The fraction of a sliding ball's kinetic energy that friction turns into heat before the ball rolls, κ(1 − s)²/((1 + κ)(1 + κs²)), against the starting spin s, for a solid ball and a thin shell. A solid ball set down without spin loses 2/7 of its energy; one with rolling spin loses none; one with enough backspin to stop loses all. A slippery surface rubs for longer at a smaller force and makes exactly the same heat as a rough one.
Fig. 3 The fraction of a sliding ball’s kinetic energy that friction turns into heat before the ball rolls, κ(1−s)2/((1+κ)(1+κs2))\kappa(1 - s)^2/((1 + \kappa)(1 + \kappa s^2)), against the starting spin ss, for a solid ball and a thin shell. A solid ball without spin loses 2/7 of its energy; one with rolling spin loses none; one with enough backspin to stop loses all.

The start has energy 12mv02(1+κs2)\tfrac12 mv_0^2(1 + \kappa s^2) and the end 12mvroll2(1+κ)\tfrac12 mv_\text{roll}^2(1 + \kappa), and the difference, divided by the start, comes out as κ(1−s)2/((1+κ)(1+κs2))\kappa(1 - s)^2/((1 + \kappa)(1 + \kappa s^2)), with no μ\mu in it. On a slippery surface the friction force is small but acts over a long skid; on a rough one it is large but acts briefly. The work it does, force times sliding distance, is the same. The heat goes into the cloth and the ball’s surface at the contact, which is why a cue ball struck hard and stunned leaves a faint mark on new cloth, and why bowling lanes wear where balls skid.

The same is true of a collision that ends in rolling, and the essay the bounces that add up to a stop met a sum that likewise came out independent of how it was approached. The pattern is general. When the end state is fixed by a conservation law, the energy dissipated on the way is fixed with it, and the dissipative process — friction, viscosity, an inelastic collision — chooses only the timetable.

A ball dropped on a moving floor, and the same sevenths again

The conservation argument does not care whether the floor is still, only that it is not accelerating. Put a ball down at rest on a conveyor belt moving at VV. In the belt’s own frame, which is as good an inertial frame as the room’s, the ball arrives sliding backwards at VV without spin, and so it rolls away backwards at 5V/75V/7. Back in the room, its centre ends up moving forwards at V−5V/7=2V/7V - 5V/7 = 2V/7, rolling backwards relative to the belt beneath it. A ball dropped on a treadmill is carried along at two-sevenths of the belt’s speed, whatever the belt is made of.

The same two-sevenths appeared in the ball a turntable will not throw off, where a ball rolling on a spinning record moved in circles at 2/72/7 of the table’s rate. That is the rolling version of this problem with the floor turning instead of translating, and the fraction is the same κ/(1+κ)\kappa/(1 + \kappa) for the same reason: the friction can redistribute the ball’s motion between its spin and its centre, but only along the line its conservation law allows. For a thin shell the fraction is 2/52/5, and the turntable’s circles and the treadmill’s drift would both be faster.

There is a second, quieter consequence, and it explains the stun shot. The angular momentum about the floor is mRv0(1+κs)mRv_0(1 + \kappa s), and it vanishes when s=−1/κs = -1/\kappa. A ball struck with exactly that much backspin has nothing for the friction to redistribute: it must end with no motion of any kind, and it does, after a skid in which the backspin and the forward travel die together. Any less backspin and some forward rolling survives; any more and the ball comes back. The threshold is −2.5-2.5 for a solid ball and −1.5-1.5 for a shell, and players who learn it as a feel for how low to strike are learning a ratio of moments of inertia. A player moving from a game with solid balls to one with hollow ones would find every such threshold shifted, and would have to learn them again.

Skidding on oil

Bowling is the case in which the skid is long enough to watch and the friction is deliberately varied along it. A lane is not uniformly slippery: the front part, from the foul line for something like the first twelve metres, is oiled, and the back part, leading to the pins, is dry. Oil gives a friction coefficient of order 0.04 and dry wood or synthetic lane surface of order 0.2. A bowling ball, 21.7 centimetres across, is not uniform inside, but treated as uniform it has κ=0.4\kappa = 0.4, and the figures use that.

The oil keeps the ball skidding until the back of the lane. Speed and contact slip of a bowling ball released at 8 m/s with 300 rpm, down an 18.3 m lane whose first 12.2 m are oiled. On the oil the friction is so small that the slip falls only slowly, and 4.0 m/s of it remains where the oil ends; on the dry boards it falls five times faster and the ball rolls at 16.3 m, just before the pins. On a fully dry lane the same ball would roll within about 8 m if released without spin.
Fig. 4 Speed and contact slip of a bowling ball released at 8 m/s with 300 rpm, down an 18.3 m lane whose first 12.2 m are oiled. On the oil the slip falls only slowly, and 4.0 m/s of it remains where the oil ends; on the dry boards it falls five times faster and the ball rolls at 16.3 m, just before the pins.

A ball released at eight metres a second without spin on a fully oiled lane would, by the skid-distance formula 12v02/49μg12v_0^2/49\mu g, need forty metres to start rolling — more than twice the lane. On a fully dry lane it would roll within eight. The oil pattern is there to make the ball skid through the front of the lane and roll only near the end. Bowlers release the ball with spin, typically a few hundred revolutions a minute, about an axis turned away from square to the lane, and the figure follows such a ball. On the oil the slip barely changes; at the edge of the oil, four metres a second of it remains; on the dry boards friction works five times as hard, and the ball rolls a couple of metres before it reaches the pins.

A hook is a parabola

The direction of the friction matters as much as its size. In two dimensions the slip is a vector, the velocity of the contact point across the floor, and kinetic friction points against it. Working through the equations of motion of a sphere gives a result that is the key to the whole of bowling: the slip vector shrinks at a constant rate and does not turn. Friction slows the centre in the direction against the slip and spins the ball so as to reduce the slip in that same direction, and for a sphere the two effects are parallel. The friction therefore keeps one direction throughout the skid on any one surface, and the ball moves under a constant force.

A hook is a parabola that ends where the skid ends. The path of a bowling ball seen from above, released at 8 m/s heading 20 cm/s away from the centre line, with 300 rpm of spin about an axis turned 0.8 rad from square to the lane (solid) and square to it (dashed). Across scale exaggerated about fourteen times. Friction always points against the slip, and the slip keeps its direction, so in each stretch of the lane the ball moves under a constant sideways push: a parabola, gentle on the oil and sharp on the dry boards. It reaches 25 cm on the other side of the line. Once rolling, nothing pushes sideways and the path is straight.
Fig. 5 The path of a bowling ball seen from above, released at 8 m/s heading 20 cm/s away from the centre line, with 300 rpm about an axis turned 0.8 rad from square to the lane (solid) and square to it (dashed). Across scale exaggerated about fourteen times. On each surface the ball moves under a constant sideways push — a parabola, gentle on the oil and sharp on the dry boards — and reaches 25 cm on the other side of the line. Once rolling, the path is straight.

A body moving under a constant force follows a parabola, as a projectile does, and that is what a hook is: a parabola on the oil, with a small sideways acceleration of 0.04g0.04g times the sideways share of the slip, then a tighter parabola where the oil ends, with five times the curvature, then a straight line from the moment the ball rolls. The release angle and the axis of spin are chosen so that the ball goes out towards the edge on the oil and comes back across the lane on the dry boards into the pocket between the head pin and the next. With the spin axis square to the lane, the dashed path, there is no sideways slip to speak of and the ball travels almost straight on its initial heading.

The ball does not curve because it spins; it curves because it slips, and only while it does. That is a different mechanism from the swerve of a football or a cricket ball in the air, which the push that comes out sideways might suggest by analogy, and at bowling speeds the air plays almost no part.

What the model leaves out

The figures treat friction as a constant coefficient times the normal force, kinetic while the ball slips and absent once it rolls. Real friction on oiled lanes depends on the oil’s thickness, which bowlers’ balls change as they carry oil down the lane and dry the front; real cloths have a nap that makes the coefficient depend on direction. None of that alters the rolling speed, which needs only that the friction act at the contact. It alters where the skid ends.

The ball is taken as a uniform sphere. Real bowling balls have dense, asymmetric cores designed to give them unequal moments of inertia about different axes, so the spin axis migrates during the skid, and the planar analysis no longer holds exactly: the slip direction can turn, and the hook is not a perfect parabola. Snooker and pool balls are close to uniform and the planar result applies well.

The model also ignores rolling resistance, the slow loss a rolling ball suffers from the deformation of the surface ahead of it that the push a millimetre ahead of the axle measured, and the spin about the vertical axis, which produces a twisting friction at the contact that slowly kills side spin. Both act after the skid, or alongside it at a much smaller rate. And the conservation argument fails if the ball leaves the surface, as a ball struck downward into the cloth may for a moment; a jumping ball exchanges angular momentum with the table in the bounce.

Still open: what the core of a bowling ball does to the hook

A bowling ball with an asymmetric core has three different moments of inertia, and a ball spinning about any axis except a principal one precesses as it rolls, which changes the axis — and with it the direction of the slip — continuously during the skid. Manufacturers design cores to control this, and players drill balls with the core oriented to suit their release. Predicting the full three-dimensional path, with an evolving oil pattern, an asymmetric core and a contact whose friction depends on how much oil the ball has already carried, is done numerically and checked against tracking data on real lanes; how well such models predict where the hook will begin, from one shot to the next on a lane that is changing as it is used, is still being measured.

Kinetic friction acts at the contact point, so a sliding ball’s angular momentum about that point is conserved through its skid and its rolling speed is fixed the moment it leaves the cue — (v0+κRω0)/(1+κ)(v_0 + \kappa R\omega_0)/(1 + \kappa), five-sevenths of the starting speed for a solid ball without spin, with two-sevenths of its energy turned to heat, on felt or ice alike — while the friction decides only how long the skid takes; and because a sphere’s slip shrinks without turning, the skid on each surface is a constant-force motion, which is why a bowling ball runs a gentle parabola on the oil, hooks sharply on the dry boards and goes straight the moment it rolls. The floor sets the timetable, and the start sets the ending.

Part 14 of 14

This essay is one argument about Rotation. The others:

What links here

Essays that reach for this one mid-argument — the half of a link its own author cannot write down.

The objects named here

The third axis, after the field and the reading path: the things themselves, and every essay that touches each one.

Angular momentumCentre of percussionKinetic frictionMoment of inertiaRolling without slipping