The drop that cannot burn the leaf it sits on
Assumes: The bend at the boundary, and what it is really about · The angle a liquid makes with what it sits on
A common piece of gardening advice says never to water plants in the middle of a sunny day, because the drops left on the leaves will act as lenses and burn them. It sounds like physics. A water drop is round, water bends light, and anyone who has started a fire with a magnifying glass knows what a lens in sunlight can do. The advice is repeated in books and on seed packets and has the authority of something everybody knows.
It was tested in 2010 by a group in Budapest, who put glass spheres and water drops on leaves in sunshine and traced the light through them. They found that drops sitting on smooth leaves did essentially nothing, and that burning was possible only in a special case: drops held up off the surface by hairs, as on certain ferns. The reason is a matter of where the focus is, and it can be worked out exactly. A drop on a leaf is a lens whose back is pressed against the thing it would burn.
A drop is a lens with one curved face
The bend at the boundary set out Snell’s law, by which light crossing from air into water bends towards the perpendicular to the surface, because water slows it by a factor of 1.333. A curved surface bends rays at different heights by different angles, and a convex surface tilts them all towards its axis. That is a lens.
A drop sitting on a flat leaf is a spherical cap. Its shape is set by surface tension, which pulls it into a section of a sphere, and by the contact angle at its edge, which the angle a liquid makes traced to the balance of the three surface tensions where water, leaf and air meet. On a clean, wettable leaf the angle might be forty degrees and the drop a low dome; on a waxy, water-repellent leaf it might be a hundred and fifty degrees or more, and the drop almost a full sphere sitting on a small footprint. Sunlight from overhead enters through the curved top. It does not leave through a second curved surface, as it would through a glass lens; it travels through the water straight to the flat base where the drop meets the leaf, and enters the leaf there.
A single curved surface of radius between air and water brings rays near its axis to a focus a distance
behind the surface, for water’s index of 1.333. That is a long way. A hemispherical drop, the case in the middle of the figure, has its curved top one radius above the leaf, so its focus lies four radii below the top and three below the leaf, deep inside the plant and far beyond it. The rays are converging when they reach the leaf, but they have hardly begun to: they cross the leaf’s surface spread over nearly the whole footprint of the drop.
Every contact angle misses
It might seem that the right contact angle would bring the focus up to the surface: a drop rounder than a hemisphere has its top higher above the leaf, and a sharper curvature. Both help. Neither is enough.
The arithmetic is short. A cap of contact angle on a footprint of radius is part of a sphere of radius , and its top stands above the leaf. The focus is below the top, so its depth below the leaf is , or in footprint radii,
That is never zero, because the cosine is never less than minus one. For flat drops it is very large: a twenty-degree drop focuses nearly twelve footprint radii down. It falls as the drop rounds up and reaches its smallest value, , where , at 109.47 degrees. Past that angle the drop is becoming a sphere sitting on an ever smaller footprint, and although its focus in absolute terms stays a radius or two below the leaf, the footprint shrinks faster, so the depth in footprint radii climbs again.
The angle at which the focus comes nearest, the tetrahedral angle, has no special meaning here; it is an accident of the cosine. What matters is the conclusion. No drop that sits on a leaf, with its base in contact, focuses sunlight on the leaf’s surface. The geometry forbids it for every shape that surface tension can give.
The index a liquid would need
The 4 in that formula is water’s. For a material of refractive index , a single curved surface focuses at , and the depth of the focus below the leaf becomes
A denser medium bends light more and pulls the focus in. Glass, with an index of 1.5, makes the numerator , still always positive; a glass bead resting on a leaf focuses at least footprint radii below it. The numerator can reach zero only if is less than one, which needs an index above 2. Diamond, at 2.42, could focus on its own base if it were a drop with a contact angle of 135 degrees. No common liquid comes near: water is 1.33, the densest oils about 1.5, and the most refractive liquids made for microscopy around 1.8. The impossibility is not a property of water; it is a property of every liquid there is.
The same weakness is why the eye that loses its lens in water goes out of focus under water: most of the eye’s focusing is done at the cornea’s front surface, by the jump in index from air to tissue, and water’s own index is so close to the cornea’s that the jump almost disappears. A curved water surface is a modest lens in air and almost no lens in anything denser, and a leaf, full of water itself, is denser than air.
How bright it gets under a drop
The paraxial focus is a statement about rays near the axis. A real drop also bends the outer rays, more strongly, and they converge sooner, so the light under a drop is not uniform. To see how bright the brightest patch is, the light has to be traced in three dimensions: through the curved surface, across the water, to the base, with the Sun treated as a disc half a degree across rather than a point, and with the fraction of light reflected at each surface taken from Fresnel’s formulas.
For the drops that gardening advice is about, on ordinary leaves that water wets, the answer is close to nothing. Under a forty-degree drop the brightest light is 1.2 times direct sunlight. Under a hemisphere it is 1.8 times. A leaf in full sun already absorbs direct sunlight all day; a patch receiving less than twice as much, for the minutes before the drop evaporates, is not scorched. In fact the leaf under a drop is better off than the leaf beside it, because it is wet and in contact with a body of water that has to be heated through before anything else can be.
Only the most water-repellent leaves change this. A drop on a superhydrophobic surface, with a contact angle above 150 degrees, is a nearly complete sphere resting on a small footprint, and its strongly curved surface gathers light into a bright ring near the edge of that footprint, over thirty times direct sunlight at 165 degrees. But such leaves are exactly the ones on which water does not stay: the drop that leaves in the same time however hard it lands showed drops bouncing off a lotus leaf in a fraction of a second, and a drop that does settle rolls off at the slightest tilt, carrying dirt with it. The leaves on which drops sit long enough to matter are the ones on which they cannot focus.
A drop held clear is a burning glass
Lift the drop off the leaf and everything changes. A complete sphere of water in air is a ball lens: light enters one curved face and leaves through another, and both faces converge it. Its focus, for rays near the axis, lies at
from its centre, one radius beyond its back surface. Hold a water drop one radius above a leaf, and the focus is on the leaf.
That is what hairs do. They are also what makes the glow round the shadow of a head on dewy grass. The full moon that is too bright described that glow, the heiligenschein, in which drops held clear of the blades focus sunlight onto the surface behind them and the lit spot sends light back out through the same drop, towards the Sun and so towards an observer whose head is in the way. The drop that burns and the drop that glows are the same optics, read from the leaf’s side and from the observer’s.
Many leaves are covered in fine hairs, and some, like those of the floating fern Salvinia, have hairs shaped to hold water drops suspended at their tips, a fraction of a millimetre above the leaf’s surface. The Budapest experiments found burn marks on such leaves under drops that had sat in sunshine. The arithmetic says why.
A drop touching the leaf at a single point, at zero height on the figure, already concentrates about thirty times, much as the most water-repellent sitting drops do. As it is lifted, the converging cone of light leaving its lower surface meets the leaf at a smaller and smaller spot, and the concentration climbs steeply, peaking at nearly fifteen hundred times direct sunlight when the drop’s lowest point is about 0.9 radii above the leaf. That is a little short of the paraxial focus, one radius, because a sphere’s outer rays focus short of its inner ones; the brightest spot is where the converging rays from the whole aperture are most crowded, not where the rays near the axis meet.
The ray picture behind that number is the one what a lens is doing used for a thin lens, applied to a lens that is anything but thin: every ray bends twice, and the rays far from the axis bend much more than a thin-lens formula allows, which is why the bright core sits inside a broad, dim skirt rather than at a point. The rays that enter near the drop’s edge also reflect inside it before leaving, and those, sent backward at about forty-two degrees, are the ones that the angle the rainbow has to be traced; a drop held in sunlight is a burning glass and a rainbow at once.
Fifteen hundred suns is a large number but not a limit. The brightness no lens can increase showed that the most any optical system can concentrate sunlight in air is 46,200 times, the ratio that makes the Sun fill the whole sky seen from the focus. A water sphere falls thirty times short of that, partly because of its spherical aberration, which spreads the focus, and partly because the spot cannot be smaller than the image of the Sun, about a hundredth of the drop’s radius across. A perfect lens of the same size would do better; a drop is the lens nature makes.
Concentration is not temperature
A thousandfold concentration sounds like a burn. Whether it is depends on how hot the spot gets, and that depends on a fact about heat that makes small burning glasses weak ones.
The power a drop collects grows as its area, the square of its radius. The spot it focuses into grows as its radius, because every length in the optics scales together. Heat flowing away from a small hot spot into a large cool body leaves it at a rate proportional to the spot’s size times the temperature difference; for a disc of radius heated with total power on the surface of a material of conductivity , the steady rise at the centre is of order
So the temperature rise scales as the square of the radius divided by the radius: in proportion to the drop’s size. A one-millimetre drop held at its best height above a wet leaf raises the spot by roughly ten kelvin, before any heat is lost to evaporation or to the air. A three-millimetre drop could manage about three times that, but drops that large are too heavy to be held up by hairs.
This is the general reason small burning glasses are feeble. A magnifying glass ten centimetres across in the same geometry would, by the same scaling, raise its spot by a thousand kelvin if nothing limited it, which is why it chars paper in seconds. A drop a millimetre across concentrates sunlight just as strongly, and its spot is a hundred times smaller, which lets the heat out a hundred times faster relative to the power. A spot of light on a leaf a few tens of micrometres across, ten or twenty kelvin above its surroundings for the minutes a drop lasts, can damage cells, which is what the burn marks on hairy leaves show; it does not set anything alight.
What the tracing leaves out
The figures put the Sun overhead, which is the case the advice is about and the one with a single axis of symmetry. A low Sun shines into a sitting drop from the side, and the converging light then meets the leaf at a slant beside the drop rather than beneath it. For low dome-shaped drops the effect is small, since their focus is far below the leaf in every direction, but for rounder drops the slanting light can be brought closer to the surface, and a low Sun can bring a round drop’s brightest light nearer the surface than an overhead one does, a case these figures do not trace. The figures also treat the leaf as flat, the drop as a perfect spherical cap and the water as clear. Real drops on real leaves are distorted by gravity, which flattens large drops, and by the leaf’s veins and texture, which pin their edges irregularly; a millimetre-sized drop is close to spherical, because surface tension dominates gravity at sizes below the capillary length, and the larger drops gravity flattens focus even further down.
The temperature estimate is the crudest part. It treats the leaf as a thick slab of water-like tissue, while a real leaf is a fraction of a millimetre thick, with air spaces inside it that conduct heat poorly, and backed by air. A thin leaf conducts heat away from a spot less well than a thick slab would, which raises the temperature; transpiration and evaporation from the surrounding drop cool it, which lowers it. Which wins depends on the leaf. The scaling with the drop’s radius survives all of that; the ten kelvin is an order of magnitude.
Still open: how often hairs and sunshine conspire
That drops held on hairs can scorch leaves is established, by experiment and by the optics above. How often it happens outside a laboratory is less clear. It needs a hairy leaf whose hairs hold drops at the right height, a clear sky, the Sun at a suitable angle, and drops that last long enough before evaporating. Floating ferns, whose hairs are evolved to hold water away from the surface, seem the most vulnerable, and there are reports of damage on others. How much of the scorching gardeners attribute to watering in sunshine is caused this way, and how much is ordinary heat stress or the salts left by evaporating hard water, has not been measured.
The habit worth carrying away is to ask where the focus is before asking how strong the lens is. A drop sitting on a leaf is a lens whose back is pressed against the leaf, and its focus lies footprint radii below the surface — never less than , for any contact angle — so the brightest light under it is under twice direct sunlight; only a drop held up on hairs, its lowest point about a radius above the leaf, focuses on the surface, concentrating sunlight about 1,500 times into a spot so small that it warms by about ten kelvin for a millimetre drop rather than by hundreds. The gardener’s lens is real. It is pointed at the wrong place.
Part 12 of 13
This essay is one argument about Refraction. The others:
The objects named here
The third axis, after the field and the reading path: the things themselves, and every essay that touches each one.
Ball lensConcentration ratioContact angleFocal lengthHeat conductionRefraction