Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Nucleation — where it appears

The formation of the first small bubble or droplet of a new phase, which has an energy barrier to pay before the transition can proceed. The barrier exists because a small nucleus is nearly all surface, so the surface cost beats the volume gain until a critical radius is reached.

Named by 5 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The small bubble empties into the large one. Two soap bubbles of radius 4 mm and 12 mm joined by an open tube. The excess pressure inside each is 4γ/R — 72.8 Pa and 24.3 Pa — so the 4 mm bubble is at the higher pressure and blows itself into the other. The smaller a bubble gets the harder it pushes, so the process runs away rather than settling: there is no equilibrium anywhere except both bubbles equal.

The small bubble blows up the big one

Connect two soap bubbles of different size and the small one empties into the large one. Everybody expects the opposite, and the reason it happens is one equation with a radius in the denominator — which also means the process runs away rather than settling.

fluids · Surface tension The phase boundary of water, from one equation. Pressure against temperature for water on a logarithmic pressure axis spanning 6.6 decades. The vaporisation curve is integrated from Clausius–Clapeyron between the triple point at 273.16 kelvin and 611.7 Pa and the critical point at 647.096 kelvin, with a single latent heat of 43.32 kilojoules per mole — the value the two published points on the curve imply. The measured latent heats are 45.05 at the triple point and 40.65 at the reference point, and the fitted value sits between them, because a constant latent heat is an average over the interval. The sublimation curve below the triple point is not measured but predicted, from the two latent heats adding where all three boundaries meet: 51.1 kilojoules per mole, which reaches 103.2 Pa at 253.1 kelvin against a measured 253.15. The melting curve is drawn at the slope Clapeyron gives it, -13.5 megapascals per kelvin, which is a volume ratio and nothing else: water's solid is 917 against 1000 kilograms per cubic metre for its liquid, so melting shrinks it and the line leans backwards. Across the whole 6.6 decades of this axis that line moves 5.2 kelvin, and one atmosphere shifts the melting point by 0.0075 kelvin. At 1 atmosphere the boundary is crossed at 373.1 kelvin, where water boils. The one place the curve fails is its top end: a constant latent heat reaches 37.4 MPa at the critical temperature where the measured critical pressure is 22.1 MPa, 70 per cent high, because the latent heat falls to zero at the critical point and this curve does not know that.

A boiling point is a pressure, not a temperature

Nothing about water names one hundred degrees; the air does. Where a liquid turns to vapour in its bulk is fixed by what pushes on it, which makes the familiar figure a coordinate on a curve — 71 °C on Everest, 119.5 °C in a sealed pot — and one latent heat draws the whole curve.

thermodynamics · Phase change The part of the curve no fluid follows. Van der Waals' isotherms in reduced units, at 5 temperatures either side of the critical one, so that nothing about any particular substance appears. Above the critical temperature the pressure falls monotonically as the volume grows, which is what a fluid does. Below it the curve develops a loop with a rising section in the middle, and that section says the pressure increases as the substance expands — a material with negative compressibility, which cannot exist, because any fluctuation would run away. What happens instead is drawn as the horizontal line: the substance separates into two phases at one pressure, and the volume moves along the line as the proportions change. Its height, 0.6470 of the critical pressure, is fixed by requiring the two areas the line cuts off to be equal, which is the condition that the two phases have the same Gibbs energy. It meets the curve at volumes 0.603 and 2.349, a ratio of 3.9, and those are the densities of the liquid and its vapour. The two turning points of the loop, at 0.72 and 1.53, bound the part that is not merely unobserved but impossible; between them and the construction the substance can be made to sit, superheated or supercooled, until something nucleates.

The part of the curve no fluid follows

One equation for a real gas produces isotherms with a rising middle section, which says a substance would expand as the pressure on it grows. Nothing does that. What replaces it is a horizontal line whose height is fixed by making two areas equal, and the condition is not a convenience.

thermodynamics · Phase change A pore that lifts 100 m has to be 0.1 µm or finer. Capillary rise against pore radius, both logarithmic, for a liquid of surface tension 72.8 mN/m at a contact angle of 20°. The relation is a straight line of slope −1 — halve the pore and double the rise — and the two horizontal marks are the height in question, 100 m, and the 10.3 m that one atmosphere supports. 0.01 µm lifts 1394.7 m; 0.1 µm lifts 139.5 m; 1 µm lifts 13.9 m; 5 µm lifts 2.8 m; 20 µm lifts 69.7 cm; 50 µm lifts 27.9 cm. The conducting vessels of a tree are tens of microns across and lift under a metre; the pores in the membranes between them are tens of nanometres and would lift kilometres. Those are the same expression at two scales, and only one of them is a pipe.

The column that is pulled, not pushed

A capillary fine enough to lift a hundred metres is far too fine to carry any flow, and one wide enough to carry the flow lifts under a metre. Neither is how the water gets up a tree. The column is under tension — an absolute pressure of −0.88 MPa at the top, which a gas cannot have — held together by cohesion and prevented from tearing by pores a few tens of nanometres across.

fluids · Capillarity The barrier a new phase has to climb. The free energy of a droplet against its radius, at four supersaturations. Two terms compete: the volume term is a gain and goes as r³, the surface term is a cost and goes as r². At small radius the surface wins, so a droplet that forms by chance is more expensive than the vapour it came from and evaporates again; past a critical radius the volume wins and the droplet grows without limit. The maximum between them is the barrier. At S = 1.5 the critical radius is 2.66 nm and the barrier 533.8 kT, S = 2 the critical radius is 1.56 nm and the barrier 182.6 kT, S = 3 the critical radius is 0.98 nm and the barrier 72.7 kT, S = 5 the critical radius is 0.67 nm and the barrier 33.9 kT. The critical radius contains a few hundred molecules at low supersaturation and a handful at high, which is the first sign that a theory built on a surface tension and a bulk free energy is being applied outside its comfort. Both the critical radius and the barrier are located here by searching the drawn curve and checked against the closed forms 2γ/|Δg| and 16πγ³/3Δg², which agree to a part in a thousand.

The barrier a new phase has to climb

Water vapour three times supersaturated is thermodynamically desperate to condense and will sit there indefinitely if it is clean enough. The obstacle is that a droplet has to start small, and a small droplet is nearly all surface — so the first nanometre of every phase transition costs energy rather than releasing it, and what decides whether anything happens is the height of that cost divided by kT.

thermodynamics · Phase change

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

MetastabilitySurface tensionThe Boltzmann factorCavitationFree energyLaplace pressureLatent heatPressureCapillarityCapillary lengthCompressibilityContact angle

All concepts