Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Reflection — where it appears

The return of a wave at a boundary, with an amplitude fixed by the mismatch between the two media and a phase that may or may not be inverted. It is total past a critical angle and absent when the impedances match, and neither of those depends on how much light there was.

Named by 6 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Snell's law, found by searching. Paths from a point in a medium of index 1 to a point in one of index 1.5, and the optical path length of each against where it crosses the boundary. The curve is that length; the marked point is its minimum, located by golden-section search and not by any use of a law of optics. The angles there are 55.80° and 33.46°, which satisfy n₁sin θ₁ = n₂sin θ₂ to 1.0e-8. Every other drawn path is longer, and the flatness of the curve near the bottom is why light is not fussy: a path a tenth of the way off costs almost nothing.

The path that does not change

Reflection, refraction and the angle of the rainbow are not three laws. They are one condition — that the optical path length is stationary — and the word stationary rather than shortest is the whole of what makes an elliptical mirror and a rainbow the same statement.

optics · Fermat Stationary, and not always shortest. Three mirrors through the same point, with the same source and the same detector, and the length of the reflected path against where on the mirror the ray strikes. The actual ray is the one at the centre in all three, because the tangent there is horizontal and the two angles are equal whatever the curvature. Its path is a minimum at 0.6× the ellipse's curvature, every path equal at 1× the ellipse's curvature, a maximum at 1.6× the ellipse's curvature. On the most curved mirror every path the light did not take is shorter than the one it did, so the principle cannot be stated as least time and survive; it has to be stated as stationary time, and the difference is not a technicality.

The path that takes the longest time

Light is said to take the quickest route. Put a source and a detector in front of a mirror curved a little more than the ellipse through them, and the route it takes is slower than every route beside it — by construction, not by exception. The principle was never about least; it was about stationary, and the difference is where optics stops being geometry.

optics · Fermat What a thermal camera reads off a shiny surface. The temperature a camera calibrated for a black body reports, against the emissivity of the surface it is pointed at, for surfaces truly at 323 K, 373 K, 473 K in a room at 293 K. Every curve begins at the true temperature when the emissivity is one and ends at the room's temperature when it is zero, because a surface that emits nothing reflects everything and the camera is then looking at the room. polished aluminium at 0.05 reads 312 K; stainless steel, oxidised at 0.8 reads 451 K; matt black paint at 0.95 reads 468 K; human skin at 0.98 reads 471 K for a surface truly at 473 K. That is not a fault in the instrument. It follows from Kirchhoff's law — a poor emitter is a poor absorber and therefore a good reflector — so the shortfall in a shiny surface's own glow is made up almost exactly by whatever is reflected in it, and no measurement of the light leaving a surface can separate the two without knowing the emissivity in advance.

The glow that says nothing about the surface

A thermal camera pointed at a saucepan of boiling water reads a hundred degrees. Pointed at a polished aluminium block at the same temperature it reads about twenty-five, and the instrument is working perfectly. What it is measuring is emissivity as much as temperature — and a surface's emissivity is forced to equal its absorptivity, at every wavelength and every angle, by an argument with no physics of matter in it at all.

thermodynamics · Blackbody A reflection is shifted twice, and not by the same factor. A wave of unit frequency sent at a reflector closing at 90 km/h, in air. The target meets the fronts sooner than they arrive at a fixed point, so what reaches it is 1.072886 — the observer shift, which multiplies by (c + v)/c. It then re-emits what it received, and now it is a source running after its own wavefronts, which divides by (c − v)/c: the echo comes back at 1.157233. The two operations are different functions and only their product is symmetric, so the round trip is (c + v)/(c − v) rather than the square of either. The shift is 15.7233 per cent where a single one would be 7.2886 — a factor of two to first order in v/c and not exactly two at any speed. For light the same round trip is (1 + β)/(1 − β), which is the square of 1.000000083, and that number is the whole content of the relativistic Doppler effect rather than an approximation to it.

The shift a mirror gives twice

A moving reflector is a receiver and a source in one, so it shifts a wave twice — and the two shifts are different functions of the speed, which is why the round trip is not the square of either. Everything a speed radar does follows from that, including the two things it cannot do.

waves · Doppler A reflection that keeps the angle to gravity and not to the wall. An internal wave beam of frequency 0.5N reflecting from a slope of 12°, with the wavelength ratio for slopes of 12°, 20°, 28° computed beside it. The frequency fixes the angle the energy makes with the horizontal — 30.0° here — because the restoring force is gravity and gravity is vertical, so the reflected beam must leave at that same angle whatever the wall is doing. Incident and reflected rays are therefore not mirror images, and the wavelength changes on reflection by sin(θ+α)/sin(θ−α). A flat floor gives one, checked exactly. A slope approaching the ray's own angle gives infinity, checked as the limit, and that is where a basin's internal tide is compressed until it breaks.

The reflection that changes the wavelength

An internal wave's frequency fixes the angle its energy makes with gravity, so a sloping wall cannot send it back the way a mirror would. The reflected beam leaves at the same angle to the vertical rather than the same angle to the wall, its wavelength changes by a factor that diverges when the slope matches the ray, and in a closed basin the changes accumulate until every ray in the fluid lies on one line.

fluids · Stratification How close a network gets to a load that stores charge. The fraction of a wave's amplitude reflected from a resistance shunted by a capacitance, with RCωc = 2, against frequency in units of the band edge ωc, for the load alone and for networks of inductors and capacitors whose values, with an ideal transformer at the source, were optimised numerically to keep the reflection low across the band. The bare load holds it to 0.707 across the band; the 1-element network holds it to 0.392 across the band; the 2-element network holds it to 0.320 across the band; the 3-element network holds it to 0.289 across the band. The dashed line is Bode and Fano's floor, exp(−π/RCωc) = 0.208, which no network of any size can go beneath over the whole band; each added element brings the design closer to it, and each buys its flatter band with a reflection that climbs to total just beyond the band edge.

The mismatch no network can remove

A quarter-wave layer or a taper can match a resistance to a resistance as well as anyone likes. Put a capacitance across the load and that stops being true for every network that could ever be built from lossless parts: Bode and Fano proved that the total amount of match available is fixed by the load's resistance and capacitance, so a network can only move it about — and a flat match across a band can never be better than e to the minus π over the load's time constant times the band.

waves · Impedance

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

BandwidthOptical path lengthVariational principleAbsorptionAnalyticityAnisotropyBeat frequencyBlackbodyBoundary conditionBuoyancy frequencyCapacitanceCaustic

All concepts