Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Orbit — where it appears

The path a body follows under a central attraction, closed only for the inverse square and the linear spring and precessing for everything else. Its size and shape are fixed by the energy and the angular momentum, and its orientation needs a third conserved quantity.

Named by 4 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The blow-out band has two edges, not one. The ratio of radiation force to gravity against grain radius, with the radiation-pressure efficiency included: a grain much smaller than the wavelength of the light barely interacts with it — the efficiency falls as the fourth power of the size, which is Rayleigh's law — so the ratio stops rising and turns over. The dashed line is the same ratio with the efficiency taken as one, which is the usual drawing and is right only to the right of the turnover at 115 nm. The consequence is that a grain can be too small to be blown out as well as too large. Taking the threshold at a half — the value at which a grain released from a circular orbit is unbound — the band runs from 48.2 nm to 574 nm, and the largest ratio any grain of this material reaches is 1.87. Everything outside that band stays, and what stays does not stay put: it spirals.

The size the light cannot blow away

Radiation pressure and gravity both fall as the inverse square of distance, so their ratio is a property of the grain and not of where it is. What follows is a band of sizes that get blown out — with a lower edge as well as an upper one — and a drag, on everything else, that is the same pressure read one order further in v/c.

astrophysics · Radiation pressure The arrow the orbit cannot turn. A Kepler orbit of eccentricity 0.6, integrated for two revolutions, with the Laplace–Runge– Lenz vector constructed from the position and velocity at five points along it. Every one of the five is the same arrow: its length varies by 3.7e-11 over the whole run and its direction by 2.1e-10 radians. It points at the perihelion and its length is 0.600000, which is the orbit's eccentricity measured independently from the closest and furthest radii as 0.600000. Energy and angular momentum fix the size and shape of an orbit and say nothing about which way it points; this vector is the missing statement, and only an inverse square has one.

The arrow that says which way the orbit points

Energy and angular momentum fix the size and shape of an orbit and say nothing about its orientation. The inverse-square force has a third conserved quantity that supplies it — a vector pointing at the perihelion whose length is the eccentricity — and no other force law does.

astrophysics · Orbit stability A rosette: the orbit of a body whose inertia is its energy. An orbit of eccentricity 0.45 under inertia from energy, Newton's pull, integrated for 7 revolutions from the closest approach of a body with k/Lc = 0.35. The dashed curve is the Newtonian ellipse from the same starting position and momentum, which closes on itself. The integrated orbit does not: its closest approach moves forward by 24.3° each revolution, against the exact 24.3° of 2π(1/Γ − 1) with Γ = √(1 − k²/L²c²). The dots are the successive closest approaches.

The orbit special relativity cannot close

An inverse-square orbit closes on itself because of a conserved vector that nothing else has. Give the orbiting body an inertia that grows with its speed, as special relativity requires, and the vector turns — the orbit becomes a rosette, advancing by a sixth of Mercury's famous 43 arcseconds a century. A different theory that respects special relativity just as well turns the rosette backwards by the same amount. The 43 is not special relativity plus a correction; it is a measurement of what gravity pulls on.

astrophysics · Orbit stability The same nudge in four kinds of space. A body on a circular orbit given 5 per cent more speed, integrated for up to 6 turns in the field a point mass would have in spaces of 2, 3, 4, 5 dimensions. In 2 dimensions it stays between 1.00 and 1.10 of the original radius; in 3 dimensions it stays between 1.00 and 1.23 of the original radius; in 4 dimensions it leaves after 1.93 turns; in 5 dimensions it leaves after 1.19 turns. In three dimensions the orbit is an ellipse that closes; in two it is a rosette that does not close but never wanders far; from four dimensions up there are no stable orbits at all, and a planet nudged by anything would spiral away or plunge.

The number of dimensions a planet can orbit in

Gauss's law says that a point source's field is its strength spread over the surface around it, and the size of that surface depends on how many dimensions space has. In three it grows as the square of the distance, and the field falls as the inverse square. Count differently and the field falls differently — and above three dimensions it falls so steeply that no planet could hold a stable orbit and no atom could hold its electron. The inverse-square law is not a fact about gravity or electricity. It is a fact about space, and it is one of the conditions for there being anything in space to orbit.

electromagnetism · Gauss's law

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Central forceEffective potentialGeneral relativityThe inverse-square lawPrecessionAberrationAngular momentumConservation lawsConserved quantityCross-sectionDegeneracyDimensions

All concepts