Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Wave packet — where it appears

A localised group built by adding waves of neighbouring wavelengths, whose width in space and spread in wavelength trade against each other. Its envelope travels at the group velocity and spreads at a rate set by the curvature of the dispersion relation, so a pulse in a dispersive medium cannot keep its shape.

Named by 15 essays across 5 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A packet on deep water, ω = √(gk), 1.6 s apart. A wave packet built from a Gaussian spread of wavenumbers about 1.57 per metre, drawn at two times 1.6 seconds apart, with its computed envelope ghosted around it. Between the two frames the envelope's peak moves 2.01 metres and the marked crest moves 3.95 metres, so the packet travels at 1.26 metres per second and the crests at 2.47 — a ratio of 0.51.

The packet that moves at another speed than its own crests

Watch a group of water waves and the individual crests run forward through it, rise in the middle, and vanish off the front. The group travels at half the speed of the crests, and both numbers are real.

waves · Wave packets A packet, and the wavenumbers it is made of. Above: a wave packet built by adding a continuum of plane waves centred on wavenumber 12 with a spread of 1.6. Below: the weight given to each wavenumber. The packet's width, measured as the standard deviation of its probability, is 0.442; the spread of wavenumbers is 1.131; their product is 0.500, which is a half and cannot be less. Narrowing one bracket widens the other by exactly as much. Nothing quantum has been used to draw either panel.

Sharpness has to be paid for

A wave with one exact wavelength has no beginning and no end. Making it short requires adding wavelengths, and the two widths trade against each other exactly — which is a fact about waves, with Planck's constant added only to convert the units.

quantum · Uncertainty Speed against wavelength. Phase and group speed for waves on water 4 m deep. Short waves are dispersive — the speed rises as the square root of the wavelength and the group travels at half the phase speed — and long ones all travel at √(gh) = 6.26 m/s together, which is why a tsunami keeps its shape across an ocean while a wind sea spreads out into swell.

The speed that depends on the length

Long waves on water travel faster than short ones, which is why a distant storm arrives as a slow swell and a tsunami crosses an ocean without spreading. One relation covers both, and the two familiar rules taught separately are its two limits.

fluids · Wave packets Two sources 4 wavelengths apart. Circular wavefronts from two sources, with the lines along which they arrive in step drawn through the pattern. Those lines are where the path difference is a whole number of wavelengths.

Why two lamps never interfere

Adding amplitudes is unconditional; fringes are not. What decides is whether the phase difference holds still for longer than a detector takes to record it — and a 10 nm slice of white light holds it for 100 femtoseconds, across a path of 30 micrometres.

optics · Coherence How far apart the two paths can be. Fringe visibility against the difference between the two path lengths, for light at 550 nm with a bandwidth of 100 nm. Each curve is the modulus of the Fourier transform of its own line shape, summed over the spectrum here rather than taken from a standard result, and the three shapes have the same width at half height. The conventional coherence length λ²/Δλ is 3.02 µm for this light, and what the curves show is that the convention is a rounding of three genuinely different behaviours: a flat band halves at 1.83 µm, a Gaussian line halves at 1.33 µm, a Lorentzian line halves at 0.68 µm. The flat band comes back — a rectangle's transform rings — and the Lorentzian's tails keep a little visibility very much further out than its width suggests. Nothing here is about the apparatus: the fade is the source forgetting its own phase.

How far a wave can remember

Split a beam, delay one half, and put them back together. The fringes are bright while the delay is short and fade as it grows, and the distance at which they die is fixed by nothing but the width of the source's spectral line. Watching them fade is reading the line shape.

optics · Coherence The narrow packet is the one that spreads. Three packets on deep water, ω = √(gk), all built on the same 4 m carrier and differing only in bandwidth — 10%, 18%, 28% of the carrier wavenumber. Each curve is the width of the emitted envelope, measured as the second moment of its intensity about its own centroid in a frame moving at the group velocity, divided by that width at the start. The starting widths are 4.50 m, 2.50 m, 1.61 m, and the order of the curves is the reverse of the order of the widths: the shortest packet, which is the one with the widest spectrum, is the one that comes apart first. The dashed curves are √(1 + (t/τ)²) with τ = σ₀²/|d²ω/dk²| — computed from the dispersion relation, not fitted. They agree with the measured widths to 0.3% at 10% bandwidth, 3.3% at 18% bandwidth, 8.5% at 28% bandwidth, and that ordering is the second thing the figure says: the closed form keeps only the curvature of ω(k), so it is exact for a narrow spectrum and starts to fail for a wide one, by about as much as the cubic term is worth. A packet with no bandwidth would never spread at all, and would also never begin or end.

The packet that will not keep its shape

A group velocity is only the first thing a dispersion relation says. The second is that the packet spreads — at a rate fixed by its own bandwidth and by the curvature of ω(k) — so a short pulse comes apart quickly and a long one hardly at all. It is a trade quantum mechanics is usually given credit for, and classical waves make it too.

waves · Wave packets A peak that leaves before it should have arrived. Two pulses at the far face of a cell, both normalised to the peak the vacuum one reaches. One has crossed empty space; the other has crossed a medium with two gain lines either side of its carrier, whose group index there is -3.85 — negative, so the envelope's peak should emerge early, and it does. Measured off the two curves the advance is 616 in units where the carrier period is 2π, against 582 predicted from the group index alone; the difference is the higher-order dispersion the group index leaves out. The advance is 0.21 of the pulse's own duration, and the peak leaves the far face before the input peak has entered the near one. Nothing has outrun anything. The emergent pulse is a reshaped version of the input's leading edge, which arrived in plenty of time and already contained — for a smooth pulse — everything needed to reconstruct the rest; the medium amplifies it by 1.14× and delivers it early. Give the pulse a genuine front, a moment before which it is exactly zero, and that front travels at the speed of light in every medium there is.

The speed that carries no signal

In the right medium a pulse's peak emerges from the far side before it entered the near one. The measurement is real, it has been made, and nothing has outrun light — because the peak of a smooth pulse was never carrying any information in the first place.

waves · Wave packets A bundle that swings and never spreads. A Gaussian of the ground state's own width, released at rest from x = 3 in a harmonic well and propagated on a grid by split-step Fourier, drawn at 0 of a period, 0.25 of a period, 0.5 of a period. The packet slides from side to side and its shape does not change: over 2.2 full periods the width moves by 6.6e-5 per cent, and its centre tracks x₀cos t to 8.6e-6. Every other initial width breathes. This one is the displaced ground state, and it is the closest a quantum state comes to being a classical oscillator — a definite thing at a definite place, moving on the classical trajectory, staying the size it was.

The state that swings like a pendulum

Most quantum states of an oscillator look nothing like a swinging weight. One family does: it follows the classical trajectory exactly, never spreads, and sits at the uncertainty minimum for ever — and it is the state a laser and a driven circuit actually produce.

quantum · Correspondence The delay that stops caring how thick the wall is. The Wigner phase time — how late the transmitted packet's peak arrives, compared with a free particle covering the same distance — for an electron under a 3 eV barrier, at 0.2 nm, 0.5 nm, 1 nm thick. 0.2 nm: 0.3728 fs at half the barrier height; 0.5 nm: 0.4372 fs at half the barrier height; 1 nm: 0.4388 fs at half the barrier height. The widths span a factor of 5.0 and the times span 1.18. A thicker barrier is exponentially harder to cross and the delay in crossing it barely moves — which is either a remarkable fact about tunnelling or a sign that the phase time is not a traversal time, and the rest of the essay is about which.

How long the crossing takes

Tunnelling has a probability, and asking how long it takes turns out to be a different kind of question. The delay a transmitted packet shows stops growing once the barrier is opaque, so a thicker wall is crossed in the same time — and several defensible clocks give several different answers.

quantum · Tunnelling A swing that dies away and comes back. The envelope of the mean position of a coherent state with 9 quanta on average, in an oscillator whose levels carry a small quadratic term, Eₙ = n + n²/240, over one revival time of 240 oscillator periods. The swing collapses within about 9.1 periods, when the packet has spread round its orbit, and it stays at zero for most of the run. It returns whole at half the revival time, on the opposite side, and whole again at the full revival time; the envelope is summed from the state's energy components and checked against α·exp(−2n̄ sin²χt) to a part in a hundred million. The dashed curve is a classical ensemble started from the same distribution, each member orbiting at the frequency its own energy gives: it collapses in the same way and never returns, its swing at the half and full revival times 0.1% and 0.1% of the start.

The return a classical cloud never makes

Put a swinging quantum packet in a well whose frequency depends a little on the amplitude and it spreads round its orbit until its swing has vanished. That part is not quantum at all: a cloud of classical oscillators does exactly the same. What no classical cloud can do is come back — and the quantum packet reassembles whole, on schedule, splitting into copies on the way, because its energies are discrete.

quantum · Correspondence The floor a state's survival cannot go below. The probability that a quantum state is still found in its initial state, against time measured as its energy spread times time over ħ, for four states with the same spread. The shaded region under cos²(ΔE t/ħ) is forbidden by Mandelstam and Tamm's theorem, and every curve — each a sum of phases over the state's energies — stays out of it. Two equally weighted levels run along its edge and reach an orthogonal state at exactly π/2, the fastest any state with this spread can. The same two levels driven off resonance, with the same spread, never get further than a survival of 0.500. Three equally spaced levels become orthogonal only at 1.7101, 1.0887 times the limit, and a coherent state never does, bottoming out at 0.0183. A spread of energy is permission to change, not an obligation.

The fastest a state can stop being itself

Time has no operator, so the energy–time relation cannot be the commutator inequality it resembles. What stands in its place is sharper: a state whose energy is spread by ΔE cannot become a different, orthogonal state in less than πħ/2ΔE, and cannot do it faster than its mean energy above the ground state allows either. Two equally weighted levels reach both limits exactly. Nothing else does.

quantum · Uncertainty A tiny ripple that grows, peaks, and gives the energy back. The highest point of a wave train's envelope against time, starting from an even train of amplitude 1 with a ripple of 1 per cent at the fastest-growing wavenumber, integrated from the nonlinear Schrödinger equation. For a while nothing happens that the eye could see; the ripple grows exponentially from a per cent. Then, near t = 5.6, the energy of a whole modulation period gathers into one crest 2.41 times the original amplitude — 1 + √2, the height of the Akhmediev breather this wavenumber produces. Then it spreads out again, and by t ≈ 11 the train is almost even once more, its highest point 1.01: the energy returns to where it came from, and the cycle repeats, the crest rising again near t = 17. The wave's total norm is conserved throughout to a part in a hundred million.

The even wave train that cannot stay even

In the mid-1960s a team at the National Physical Laboratory tried to make a long, perfectly regular train of waves in a towing tank, and could not: however carefully they set the paddle going, a few hundred metres down the tank the waves had bunched into groups. Their paddle was not at fault. A uniform train of steep waves on deep water is unstable — small modulations of its height grow, the energy of many waves gathers into a few, and then, astonishingly, gives itself back. Out of that instability comes a wave three times the height of the sea around it, with no history before and none after.

waves · Wave packets A wave that falls with nothing pulling it. The intensity of Berry and Balazs's Airy packet, |Ai(x − t²/4)|², drawn at six moments t = 0 to 5 in units where ħ = m = 1, each profile raised by its time. It is an exact solution of the free Schrödinger equation — no potential, no force — and equally of the equation that governs a light beam in the paraxial approximation, with t then the distance travelled. Its shape never changes and never spreads, and its main lobe, which starts at x = −1.02, moves along the parabola x = t²/4 (dashed): −0.77 at t = 1, −0.02 at t = 2, 1.23 at t = 3, 2.98 at t = 4, 5.23 at t = 5. A uniform acceleration of a half, with nothing accelerating it. The packet carries infinite energy, which is the price of the trick: its oscillating tail stretches to minus infinity, and the tail is what pushes the main lobe along.

The packet that bends with nothing pushing it

Every wave packet left to itself spreads, and every free particle moves in a straight line. In 1979 Berry and Balazs found a packet that does neither: it keeps its shape for ever, and its peak accelerates sideways along a parabola, in empty space, with no force acting. Nothing in it breaks Newton's laws — the packet's centre of mass stays exactly where it was, and only its bright head runs off, fed by a long dim tail — and the trick turns out to be the rainbow's: the bright lobe is the envelope of a family of straight rays. Thirty years later it was made with light, and then with electrons.

waves · Wave packets The readings of the moving clocks along one instant: a wave. The cosine of each moving clock's phase, read along a single laboratory instant, against position in light-periods of the clock, for clocks moving at 0.3c, 0.6c, 0.85c. The readings make a wave whose wavelength, measured from the drawing, is 3.18, 1.33, 0.62 light-periods: c²/(γvν₀), shrinking as the clocks move faster. For a clock that ticks at its rest energy over Planck's constant, ν₀ = mc²/h, that is h/γmv — de Broglie's wavelength, h over the momentum. Nothing about waves was assumed: only clocks, synchronised where they rest, read from a frame in which they move.

The wave a row of moving clocks leaves on an instant

Line up identical clocks, synchronise them where they stand, and send the whole row past a laboratory at a steady speed. On any one laboratory instant the clocks do not agree: the ones further ahead read less, by an amount that grows steadily along the row. The readings form a wave laid out in space, its crests are the moving row's instants, and they sweep along faster than light. Give each clock the frequency of its rest energy and the wavelength is exactly h/p. De Broglie's matter wave began, in 1923, as an argument about the relativity of simultaneity.

relativity · Simultaneity Two measures of how uncertain a split state is. For the two-peaked state, against half the separation of the peaks in units of their width: Heisenberg's product σₓσₚ divided by its minimum ħ/2 (solid), and the entropic sum Hₓ + Hₚ minus its minimum ln(πeħ) (dashed), both computed from the state's distributions. As the peaks separate the product grows without limit, 8.1 times the minimum at the right of the figure, because the variance counts the empty space between the peaks as uncertainty. The entropic excess levels off at 2 ln 2 − 1 = 0.386 (0.386 at the right): the position's entropy gains ln 2, one bit, for not knowing which peak, and the momentum's gives back 1 − ln 2 because its fringes pack it into narrow bands. The entropic relation says what is true of the state: it is a fraction of a coin toss away from a minimum-uncertainty packet, however far apart the two places are.

The sharpness a variance cannot see

Heisenberg's inequality is a statement about standard deviations, and a standard deviation is a poor measure of how sharply something is known. A particle that is certainly in one of two narrow places a metre apart has a position spread of half a metre, and satisfies the inequality with room to spare while being sharply localised. Measure uncertainty by information instead — by the Shannon entropy of each distribution — and the relation tightens: the sum of the two entropies has a floor that the split state cannot get under either, and the floor survives in places where the variance form says nothing at all.

quantum · Uncertainty

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

SuperpositionGroup velocityPhase velocityDispersionBandwidthBeatsFourier transformUncertainty principleCoherenceWavelengthCausalityClassical limit

All concepts