Concept

Supercooling — where it appears

Cooling a liquid below its freezing point without it freezing, possible because a new phase must first form a nucleus whose surface costs energy. Small, clean water droplets stay liquid down to about −38 °C, as most cloud droplets do.

Named by 4 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The entropy a substance keeps depends on how fast it was cooled. The entropy of a supercooled liquid in excess of its crystal's, against temperature, for a substance melting at 305 K with an entropy of fusion of 43 joules per kelvin per mole and a liquid heat capacity exceeding the crystal's by 62. The equilibrium curve — the one the liquid follows while it can still relax — falls steadily and would reach the crystal's entropy at 152.4 kelvin. It never gets there, because the liquid falls out of equilibrium first, at a temperature that depends on how long it is given: 0.01 s/K freezes at 196.1 K with 15.61 left, 1 s/K freezes at 188.1 K with 13.03 left, 100 s/K freezes at 182.1 K with 11.03 left. Ice's residual entropy is a count and does not move; a glass's is whatever it happened to have when it stopped being able to change, and that is a property of the experiment.

The entropy that depends on how fast it was cooled

Ice's residual entropy is a count, and it comes out the same whoever measures it. A glass's does not. A glass keeps whatever entropy it happened to have when its own relaxation time crossed the experiment's, so cooling ten times more slowly leaves less behind — and extrapolating the equilibrium liquid below that point takes its entropy under the crystal's at a finite temperature, which cannot happen and does not, for a reason that is still argued about.

thermodynamics · Third law
How supersaturated a cloud is, to an ice crystal. The supersaturation over ice of air that is just saturated over liquid water, eᵥᵥ/eᵢ − 1, in per cent, against temperature; dashed, the same computed from the chemical potentials, exp(LΔT/RT·Tₘ) − 1, with L the latent heat of melting per mole, ΔT the supercooling and Tₘ the melting point. A supercooled cloud is in balance with its droplets, so to any ice crystal inside it the air is 5.1 per cent supersaturated at −5 °C, 10.5 at −10, 22.0 at −20 and 41.2 at −35. Over the droplets themselves it is exactly saturated, so they neither grow nor shrink by vapour. The excess is the chemical-potential difference between supercooled water and ice, 217 J per mole at −10 °C, expressed as a pressure ratio.

The ice that grows by stealing from the droplets

Most clouds colder than freezing are not made of ice. They are made of droplets of liquid water, some tens of degrees below their freezing point, waiting for something to start them freezing. When a few ice crystals do appear among them, the crystals grow and the droplets shrink, without touching, because supercooled water has a higher chemical potential than ice and so a higher vapour pressure: air balanced with the droplets is ten per cent supersaturated, to an ice crystal, at minus ten degrees. A few crystals among a hundred thousand droplets each take everything, grow heavy enough to fall, and that is how most of the rain outside the tropics begins — as snow.

thermodynamics · Chemical potential
Why silt heaves and sand and clay do not. The relative rate at which water is drawn to a growing ice lens, against grain diameter on a logarithmic scale, for three loads on the soil above it, in a capillary model: the rate is the soil's permeability, which grows as the grain diameter squared, times the suction the lens can sustain less the load. The suction is capped both by the supercooling at the lens, here 2 K, and by the Gibbs–Thomson pressure at which ice would break into the pores. Coarse soil has open pores that ice simply invades, so the suction never exceeds the load: under 10 kPa, half a metre of soil, nothing heaves above 58 μm. Fine clay can sustain the full suction but passes water too slowly to feed it. Between lies a fastest grain size, 29 μm under 10 kPa, 10 μm under 30 kPa and 2.9 μm under 100 kPa: silt, the soil engineers have long called frost-susceptible. Real heave pressures exceed this model's, and the fit is to the shape, not the scale.

The frost that lifts by drinking

Frozen ground rises in winter, sometimes by tens of centimetres, and the usual explanation — water expands by nine per cent when it freezes — is wrong: soil soaked in benzene, which shrinks as it freezes, heaves too. The lift comes from layers of clear ice that grow by pulling liquid water up through the soil from below. Ice and water touching each other need not be at the same pressure, and when the water is free to flow, ice a degree below its melting point can push with 1.12 megapascals while it drinks — twelve times less than freezing water in a sealed pipe, and enough to lift a house at a tenth of a degree.

thermodynamics · Chemical potential
How much of supercooled water freezes in an instant. The fraction of a body of supercooled water that freezes at once when it is nucleated, against how far below 0 °C it had been cooled: the ice that forms releases latent heat until the whole of it is back at 0 °C, and freezing stops there until heat is taken away. Solid: with water's measured heat capacity, which rises steeply below about −20 °C; dashed: with the heat capacity it has at 0 °C. At −15 °C, 19.1 per cent freezes at once; at −20 °C, 25.7 per cent; at −38 °C, the coldest liquid water reaches before it freezes by itself, 51 per cent. The rest stays liquid at 0 °C. Water would have to be cooled about 80 degrees for all of it to freeze at once, and no liquid water survives that long.

The supercooled water that only partly freezes

Water can be cooled well below 0 °C and stay liquid, and when a crystal finally starts, the whole bottle seems to turn to ice at once. It does not. Freezing releases heat, and with nowhere for that heat to go in the instant of freezing, it warms everything back to 0 °C — at which point freezing must stop. Water cooled to −15 °C freezes about a fifth at once; to −38 °C, the coldest liquid water gets, about half. The rest has to wait for the surroundings to take the heat away, and a hand warmer is the same arithmetic run above body temperature.

thermodynamics · Phase change

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Chemical potentialHeat capacityLatent heatBergeron processClausius clapeyronDiffusion growthEnthalpyEntropyEquilibriumErgodicityFrost heaveGlass transition

All concepts