Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Larmor formula — where it appears

The power an accelerating charge radiates, proportional to the square of its acceleration and independent of its speed in the charge's own frame. It follows from the kink joining two static fields that do not line up, and it is why an antenna is a charge whose motion changes fast.

Named by 8 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The classical atom, and how long it lasts. An electron in a circular orbit of 5.29·10⁻¹¹ m loses energy at the rate the Larmor formula gives, so its radius obeys r³ = r₀³ − 4k²t/c³ and reaches zero in 1.556·10⁻¹¹ seconds — 16 picoseconds. It completes about 2.04·10⁵ orbits on the way, so the spiral is far too tight to draw. Nothing in this calculation is wrong: the acceleration is right, the radiated power is right, and the conclusion is that matter cannot exist. The curve is the shape of that conclusion.

A charge that turns must glow

An accelerating charge radiates, and a charge going round in a circle is accelerating. Apply that to an electron orbiting a nucleus and classical physics predicts that every atom collapses in sixteen picoseconds — a calculation with nothing wrong in it except its conclusion.

astrophysics · Radiating charge The shell of news, and the kink inside it. A charge that was moving at 0.6c to the right, stopped over a short interval, and has been at rest ever since. Outside the sphere of radius ct nothing has heard: the field there still points at the position the charge would have reached had it carried on, marked ahead of it. Inside, the field is that of a charge at rest. In between is a shell one deceleration-time thick, and across it the field line has to bend, because a field line cannot simply stop in empty space — the two ends are joined here to 8.5e-14 pixels. That bend is transverse to the radius, and it is the radiation. It is not an extra thing the charge emitted; it is the join between two static fields that do not line up, and it travels outward at c because that is where the news front is.

The field that points where the charge is now

The field here was set by what the charge was doing a distance over c ago, so it ought to point at where the charge used to be. For a charge moving steadily it points at where the charge is — not approximately, exactly — and nothing has outrun light. What breaks the arrangement is a change of motion, and the break is the whole of radiation.

electromagnetism · Retardation The self-force matters at 6.27 × 10⁻²⁴ s, and nowhere a charge has ever been. The ratio of the radiation reaction to the applied force, which is τ divided by the time the force takes to change, on a logarithmic axis. τ = μ₀q²/6πmc = 6.266e-24 s for an electron, and light crosses 1.879 femtometres in that time — two thirds of the classical electron radius. a 3 GHz accelerating cavity: 1.9e-14; a 500 nm optical field: 3.8e-9; an electron orbiting a proton, ground state: 4.1e-8; an X-ray at 0.1 nm: 1.9e-5; over a classical electron radius: 6.7e-1. The largest of them, "over a classical electron radius", is still 1.5e+0 times too slow. So the correction is never large for any force anybody can apply, and the only regime where it would be is one in which the charge's own structure has already made the whole description meaningless.

The force a charge exerts on itself

Larmor's formula says how much an accelerating charge radiates and says nothing about who pays. Conservation says the charge does, so there is a force on it — and the equation that force produces has a free particle accelerating for ever with nothing pushing it, or else beginning to move before it is pushed. Both solutions are absurd, and the interval over which they are absurd is smaller than the electron the equation was written for.

astrophysics · Radiating charge The power at stake, which is none. The power an electron radiates by Larmor's formula, against its acceleration, with 5 cases marked. a charge on a table: 9.8e+0 m/s², 5.49e-52 W; a laboratory centrifuge: 1.0e+6 m/s², 5.71e-42 W; a proton at the LHC: 1.9e+16 m/s², 2.06e-21 W; an electron in a linac: 2.0e+19 m/s², 2.28e-15 W; an electron in a hydrogen atom: 9.0e+22 m/s², 4.62e-8 W. The slope is two, measured on the drawn line. A charge held at one gravity radiates 5.49e-52 watts, which over the whole age of the universe comes to 2.39e-34 joules — far less than one photon of any kind. So the question of whether it radiates is not an experimental question about a charge on a table, and never has been. Every number here is a straight line on logarithmic axes with an exponent the figure measures.

Whether a charge on a table glows

The equivalence principle says a charge at rest in a gravitational field is a charge accelerating in empty space, and an accelerating charge radiates. Nothing is supplying the energy. The argument has run for eighty years, and its resolution is that radiation is not something a single observer can define.

astrophysics · Radiating charge Radiated while the push holds, paid for when it stops. The power a charge radiates, the power the radiation reaction force takes from its motion, and the rate of change of the Schott term mτ a·v, through a push that rises over the first 20 per cent of its duration, holds steady, and falls away over the last 20, in units of mτa₀² where a₀ is the steady acceleration. Radiated power is a², the reaction force's take is −ȧv, and the Schott rate is found by differencing a·v along the trajectory; at every instant the first equals the sum of the other two. While the push is steady the reaction force is exactly zero and the charge still radiates at the full rate, all of it drawn from the Schott term. When the push stops, ȧ is large and negative while the charge is moving fast, and the reaction force takes 0.775 units, more than the 0.750 radiated over the whole push. The difference is what it handed back while the push was starting: then the charge is still slow, the reaction force points along the rising acceleration, and it does 0.025 units of work on the charge instead of taking any. The totals agree to a part in a hundred thousand.

The bill that arrives when the pushing stops

A charge accelerating steadily radiates at the full Larmor rate while the radiation reaction force on it is exactly zero, so for as long as the push holds, nothing about the charge's motion pays a single watt. The energy is lent by the field that travels with the charge, the loan is called the Schott term, and it is repaid the moment the acceleration changes.

astrophysics · Radiating charge One turn of a circling charge, as it arrives. The radiation field reaching a distant observer in the plane of a charge's circular orbit, over one full turn, for speeds of 0.2c, 0.6c, 0.9c, each scaled to its own peak and plotted against arrival time as a fraction of the orbital period. At 0.2c the flash arrives 20.9 per cent of a turn wide at half height, having been emitted over 25.4 per cent; at 0.6c the flash arrives 6.0 per cent of a turn wide at half height, having been emitted over 14.2 per cent; at 0.9c the flash arrives 0.7 per cent of a turn wide at half height, having been emitted over 6.3 per cent. The slowest charge sends something close to a sine wave, with a trough 0.44 of its peak; the fastest sends a spike whose peak, divided by its speed, is 100 times a slow charge's, and a trough of 0.0028 of that peak. The field integrates to zero over every turn, as a radiation field must.

The flash a circling charge sends once a turn

A slow electron going round a magnet broadcasts one radio frequency. The same electron at nearly the speed of light, on a circle of the same kind, sends X-rays. Nothing about the mechanism changes between the two. The charge chases its own light, and the chase compresses one power of γ worth of emission into three.

astrophysics · Radiating charge Every colour a bound electron can meet. The light-scattering cross-section of one electron bound with a resonance at 2.105 eV (589 nm) and damped only by its own radiation, in units of the Thomson cross-section, against the frequency of the light in units of the resonance, on logarithmic axes spanning nine decades of frequency and twenty-five of cross-section. Far below the resonance it rises with slope 4.001, Rayleigh's fourth power: at a hundredth of the resonance it is 1.0 × 10⁻⁸ times the Thomson value. At the resonance it spikes to 2.5 × 10¹⁵ times the Thomson value, which is 3λ²/2π = 1.66 × 10⁻¹³ m² exactly, over a width of 2.0 × 10⁻⁸ of the resonant frequency. Above it the cross-section settles to the Thomson value, 6.652 × 10⁻²⁹ m² — 1.0002 times it at a hundred times the resonance — and stays within 10 per cent of it from 4.6 times the resonant frequency, 9.8 eV, to 29 keV, 3.5 decades, until the photon energy approaches the electron's rest energy, where the Klein–Nishina factor for a free electron takes it down to 0.431 of the Thomson value at 511 keV and 0.077 at 10 MeV.

The cross-section that forgets the colour

An electron on a spring, shaken by light, scatters it — weakly and very blue below its resonance, enormously at it, and above it by exactly the same amount whatever the colour. That flat stretch is the Thomson cross-section, 6.65 × 10⁻²⁹ m², and it is why an X-ray picture of a crystal is a map of electrons and why the corona is white.

astrophysics · Radiating charge An atom made of powers of n. Five properties of a hydrogen atom in a level of principal quantum number n, each divided by its value in the ground state, against n from 1 to 300 on logarithmic axes. The radius of a circular orbit rises as n², to 0.53 µm at n = 100; the orbital period as n³, to 1.5 × 10⁻¹⁰ s; the radiative lifetime of the circular state, from the Larmor loss on its orbit, as n⁵ — slope 5.000 — to 0.9 s. The binding energy falls as n⁻², to 1.36 meV, and the electric field that pulls the electron away falls as n⁻⁴, to 3.2 V/cm. Across n = 1 to 300 the lifetime changes by 2 × 10¹² and the ionising field by 8 × 10⁹.

The atom the size of a bacterium

Excite hydrogen's electron to the hundredth level and the atom is a micrometre across, bound by a thousandth of an electronvolt, pulled apart by the field of a torch battery, and — in its most circular state — able to live for nearly a second. Every one of those numbers is a power of n, and together they make the most exaggerated atom there is into one of the most useful.

quantum · Atomic spectra

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

AccelerationRadiationSynchrotron radiationCausalityDipole radiationEnergy conservationThe Lorentz factorRadiation reactionRelativistic beamingRetardationAtomic structureBlackbody radiation

All concepts