Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Earnshaw theorem — where it appears

The theorem that no arrangement of fixed charges or magnets can hold an object in stable equilibrium by static forces alone. Such fields have no minimum in empty space, so working levitation needs motion, feedback, diamagnetism or superconductivity.

Named by 2 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Four places where three charges' fields cancel. Field lines in the plane of three equal positive point charges at the corners of an equilateral triangle, with every point where the field is zero marked. There are four: one at the centre, and three more on the lines from the centre to the middle of each side, 0.164 of a side from the centre. Four is (n − 1)² for three charges, the largest number Maxwell conjectured any three charges could make. Each zero is a saddle: along some directions the field pushes a test charge back and along others away, so none of them can hold anything still.

The zeros a handful of charges can make

Between two equal charges there is a point where their fields cancel. With three there can be two such points, or one, or four. Every such point is a saddle, never a place where a charge could rest. In two dimensions the count is fixed by algebra: n equal line charges make exactly n − 1 zeros, the roots of a polynomial's derivative. In three dimensions nobody knows the answer. In 1873 Maxwell conjectured that n point charges can make at most (n − 1)² zeros. Three charges on a triangle make exactly four, and the conjecture has not been proved even for three charges.

electromagnetism · The field concept Two stiffnesses, positive together only in a band. The stiffness of the trap for a field-following magnet above a ring base, against height in units of the ring's radius: vertically, proportional to the curvature of the field strength along the axis; sideways, proportional to the curvature of |B| across it, B′²/4B − B″/2. Below half a radius the field's fall is still steepening, the vertical stiffness is negative, and a magnet nudged downward keeps going. Above √(2/5) = 0.632 radii the field strength no longer rises away from the axis, the sideways stiffness is negative, and a magnet drifts off to the side. Only between 0.500 and 0.632 radii are both positive — 6.6 mm of height for a 10 cm ring. For the nominal top, floating at 0.565, the trap's natural frequencies are 1.36 Hz vertically and 0.82 Hz sideways.

The window a spinning magnet floats in

No arrangement of fixed magnets can hold another magnet still in mid-air, and a spinning top made of a magnet floats above a magnetised base for minutes. The spin does not cancel the theorem; it changes what the top's energy depends on, from one component of the field to the field's strength, which can have a minimum. But the minimum exists only in a band of height a few millimetres thick, for a weight right to a couple of per cent, at a spin neither too slow nor too fast, and the well holding the top is about as deep as the energy of a twenty-gram weight dropped fifty micrometres.

electromagnetism · Magnetism

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Adiabatic invariantElectric fieldField linesGyroscopeLaplace equationMagnetic dipoleMagnetic levitationMagnetic trapNull pointPrecessionSaddle pointStability

All concepts