Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Centrifugal force — where it appears

The outward term Newton's law acquires in a rotating frame, proportional to the distance from the axis and absent from any inertial description. It is not a reaction to the centripetal force and has no third-law partner, which is the test that separates it from a real interaction.

Named by 6 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

One puck, two frames. A puck slides outward from the centre of a turntable at 1.4 m/s across a table of radius 1 m, which turns through 0.55 of a revolution in the 0.71 seconds the crossing takes. On the left, in the room: a straight line, because no force acts along it. On the right, on the turntable: a spiral, because the coordinates turned underneath it. The two panels are the same numbers with the same clock — the second is the first with the angle rotated by −Ωt — so whatever is bending the path on the right is arithmetic, and it is still worth a name, because on a turning planet the right-hand panel is the one everybody lives in.

The forces that are not there

Writing Newton's law in a frame that is turning produces three extra terms. Nothing was added to the world to make them appear and nothing is removed by calling them fictitious — one of them flattens the planet, one of them turns the weather, and both are computable to four figures.

mechanics · Circular motion The term that abolishes the inner orbits. The effective potential of the Schwarzschild geometry per unit mass, in units of c², at 4 angular momenta, against radius in Schwarzschild radii. Newton's version has a minimum — a stable circular orbit — at L̃²/GM for every angular momentum there is, however small, and it is the dashed curve at the same L̃, here with its minima at 10.13, 7.61, 6.00, 5.12 rs. General relativity adds one term, −GM L̃²/c²r³, and that minimum stops existing below a definite angular momentum. At L̃ = 4.50 GM/c the barrier and the well are still separate, at 1.83 and 8.29 rs. The two merge at L̃ = √12 GM/c, at 3 rs = 6GM/c² — the innermost stable circular orbit, where the curve drawn here has neither a maximum nor a minimum but a single inflection. Below that momentum — the curve at L̃ = 3.20 GM/c — there is no stationary point anywhere outside the horizon, so no circular orbit exists at all, at any angular momentum whatever. None of that is a property of matter; it is a statement about the geometry, and it fixes the energy of the innermost orbit at √(8/9) = 0.94281 of mc², so 5.719% of the rest mass has been radiated by anything that reached it. Every well drawn here was located on the emitted curve by golden section and checked against the closed form.

The orbit that cannot be made smaller

Newtonian gravity allows a stable circular path at every radius, however tight, and there is no innermost one. General relativity adds a single term to the expression that says so, and below 6GM/c² no stable circular path exists at any angular momentum whatever. Anything arriving there has radiated 5.72% of its rest mass, which is eight times what hydrogen fusion converts.

astrophysics · Orbit stability The surface a spin decides. The free surface of a liquid in a dish of radius 0.5 m turning at 10, 20, 40 revolutions a minute. In the rotating frame the surface is a level set of gz − ½ω²r², so it is a paraboloid exactly and not to some approximation, and nothing about the liquid appears in its shape: the same curve is got with mercury, water or oil. The rim stands 14.0 mm, 55.9 mm, 223.6 mm above the centre at those rates. A parabola z = r²/4f has focal length f, so these surfaces are mirrors of focal length g/2ω² — 4.47 m at 10 rpm, 1.12 m at 20 rpm, 0.28 m at 40 rpm. That is checked here on the drawn curves rather than quoted: a vertical ray reflected off the surface at a quarter, a half, three quarters and the whole of the radius crosses the axis at the same height to 0.00%, which is what a mirror with no spherical aberration means. Doubling the spin quarters the focal length, and there is no other adjustment: the dish can only ever look straight up.

The surface a spin decides

Spin a dish of liquid and its surface settles into a paraboloid — exactly, with nothing about the liquid in the shape. A parabola of that form has a focal length of g over twice the spin rate squared, so a bucket of mercury turning at twenty revolutions a minute is a telescope mirror figured by a clock instead of by grinding.

fluids · Hydrostatics Three centuries of finding nothing. The upper limit on η against the year it was set, on a logarithmic scale. Newton (1687) reached 1e-3; Bessel (1832) reached 2e-5; Eötvös (1922) reached 5e-9; Dicke (1964) reached 1e-11; Braginsky (1972) reached 1e-12; Eöt-Wash (2008) reached 2e-13; MICROSCOPE (2022) reached 1e-15. That is 12 orders of magnitude in 335 years, and every one of those measurements returned zero. A sequence of null results is not a sequence of failures. Each one is a statement that a principle assumed by every theory of gravity holds to a new level, and each new level excludes a class of theories that would have shown a departure there — a long-range force coupling to something other than mass-energy, a scalar partner to the graviton, a violation arising at some energy scale. The measurement is worth making again precisely because it has always come out the same way, which is what makes any departure decisive.

The fall that does not depend on what is falling

Everything falls at the same rate, and the statement has been tested for three hundred years by people looking for the exception. Twelve orders of magnitude have been added to the limit and every measurement has returned zero. The last three orders came not from a better instrument but from finding something bigger to fall towards.

astrophysics · Equivalence principle A gas pressed against the wall of a spinning tube. The density of uranium hexafluoride gas in a rotor spinning at a steady rate, relative to its density on the axis, on a logarithmic scale, against the distance from the axis as a fraction of the radius, for wall speeds of 300, 450 and 600 m/s at 300 K. In the turning frame the gas sits in the centrifugal potential −½mω²r² and settles into the same exponential that thins the atmosphere with height: n ∝ exp(mω²r²/2kT). At 600 m/s the density at the wall is e^25.4 — about 10¹¹ — times that on the axis; at 300 m/s, e^6.4. Almost all the gas lies in a thin layer against the wall, and the middle of the rotor is close to vacuum.

The spin that sorts by a difference of mass

In a spinning tube a gas settles against the wall the way the atmosphere settles towards the ground, with an exponential whose scale is set by the rotor's speed rather than by gravity. Heavier molecules settle more steeply, and the ratio of two isotopes changes from axis to wall by a factor that depends on the difference of their masses, not on the ratio. That one change from a ratio to a difference is why a spinning rotor separates uranium-235 from uranium-238 more than fifty times as strongly per stage as the porous barriers that first did it — and why the history of the machine is a history of how fast a material can turn before it flies apart.

mechanics · Circular motion Three throws in a spinning room. Balls thrown at 5 m/s from the floor of a station 10 m in radius, spun at 0.99 rad/s (9.5 turns a minute) so that its floor presses with one g, as seen by someone standing in it: at 45° spinward, at 45° antispinward and straight up; with the Earth's parabolas for the two 45° throws dashed. Distances along the floor and heights in metres. On the Earth both 45° throws land 2.55 m away. In the station the spinward throw lands 1.52 m away and the antispinward one 3.06 m away, and the ball thrown straight up comes down 1.30 m ahead of the thrower, spinward. Nothing acts on any of the balls in flight. Each flies straight across the station while the floor turns beneath it, and what the thrower sees as gravity bending the path is the room rotating.

The throw a spinning station bends

A space station spun fast enough presses its floor up against its crew with the force of the Earth's gravity, and from the inside it can feel like home. Throw a ball, and the illusion fails. Nothing acts on the ball once it leaves the hand: it flies in a perfectly straight line across the station while the floor turns beneath it, and what the thrower sees as a parabola is a chord of a circle seen from a turning room. In a station ten metres across, a ball thrown up a metre comes down a metre ahead of the hand, a ball thrown with the spin falls short and one thrown against it carries long, and a dropped spanner lands a metre behind the point beneath it. How big a station must be to feel like the Earth is a question projectiles answer.

mechanics · Projectile

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Rotating frameInertial frameAngular momentumAngular velocityApparent weightArtificial gravityBoltzmann distributionCircular motionConic sectionCoriolis effectCoriolis forceEffective potential

All concepts