Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Gravitational waves — where it appears

Ripples of spacetime curvature that stretch one transverse direction while squeezing the other, travelling at the speed of light. They are quadrupolar because mass and momentum are conserved, which is why they are so feeble: the strain from a merging pair of black holes reaches Earth at about a part in 10²¹.

Named by 7 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

What a passing wave does to a ring. A ring of 8 free masses at 4 phases of a passing gravitational wave, in both polarisations. The upper row is the + mode: one diameter lengthens while the perpendicular one shortens, and half a cycle later they swap. The lower row is the × mode, which is the same pattern rotated by forty-five degrees rather than ninety — the signature of a spin-2 field, and the reason a detector is built as two arms at a right angle. The drawn strain is 0.42; a real one is 10⁻²¹, so the deformation is exaggerated 4.2·10²⁰ times. At that true strain a four-kilometre arm changes length by 4·10⁻¹⁸ m.

The wave that stretches one way and squeezes the other

A gravitational wave passing through a ring of free masses lengthens one diameter while shortening the perpendicular one, then swaps. The two conservation laws that forbid anything simpler are why the effect is a part in a thousand million million million.

astrophysics · Gravitational waves How long an orbit has before the waves take it. The time a circular orbit has left before gravitational radiation brings it together, against its separation, for four pairs of masses. Both axes are logarithmic and every curve has the same measured slope, 4.00: the lifetime goes as the fourth power of the separation, so halving an orbit shortens its remaining life by a factor of sixteen. The Earth's orbit is 13 decades above the age of the universe and the neutron-star binary is below it, which is the whole difference between a system that is losing energy and a system that is going to merge.

The orbit that has to shrink

Two masses in orbit radiate gravitational waves and lose energy, so the orbit tightens, so they go faster and radiate harder. The runaway takes 10²³ years for the Earth and the Sun and eight minutes for the last thousand kilometres of a black-hole pair — and the same one-line formula gives both.

astrophysics · Gravitational waves Where the instrument can hear. The response of an L-shaped interferometer to the plus polarisation, over the whole sky: azimuth across, cosine of the polar angle up, so that equal areas of the picture are equal areas of the sky. The plus pattern is largest directly overhead and underfoot and along the arms, and vanishes on four lines where a wave stretches both arms equally and the interferometer has nothing to compare. The average of the square over the whole sky is 0.2333, summed over a hundred and sixty thousand directions, and the two polarisations' averages add to 0.4000 — two fifths exactly, whatever the polarisation angle. Averaged over that angle as well, each polarisation contributes a fifth, and that fifth is what turns a strain sensitivity into a range: it is why a detector's quoted reach is substantially less than what it would manage for a source overhead. There is no direction in which the instrument is deaf to both polarisations at once, and none in which it is fully sensitive either.

What the instrument actually hears

A gravitational-wave detector is not a ruler laid against a stretching space. It is a clock comparison, its response falls to nothing at frequencies where the wave turns over while the light is still in the arm, and there are directions in the sky where it is deaf.

astrophysics · Gravitational waves The quantity that went down, and the one that went up. The books for GW150914: two black holes of 36 and 29 solar masses merging into one of 62, with a final spin of 0.67. 3.0 solar masses left as gravitational waves, so the mass fell by 4.6 per cent. The total horizon area rose, from 107417 to 168330 in units of the Sun's gravitational radius squared — an increase of 57 per cent. The two progenitors are taken as non-spinning, which is the assumption that makes the test hardest to pass: a spinning hole of the same mass has a smaller horizon, so any spin they actually had would only widen the gap. Mass is the quantity that behaves the way energy usually does and it is not the one with a direction. Area is, and it is the reason the area has been read as an entropy ever since.

The area that is not allowed to shrink

Two black holes merge and the result weighs less than the sum, because three solar masses left as gravitational waves. The horizon area went up by more than half. Mass is the quantity that behaves like energy and it is not the one with a direction; area is, and the theorem saying so has been tested against a real merger.

astrophysics · Horizons A few cycles, and everything about them is two numbers. The strain radiated by a remnant of 62 solar masses spinning at 0.68 of its maximum, as it settles down, with the decaying envelope of its fundamental mode drawn over it. The fundamental rings at 274 hertz and decays in 3.7 milliseconds, which is 1.0 cycles — this is not a bell and it does not sustain. Every frequency and every decay time in the sum is fixed by the mass and the spin alone; nothing about what made the remnant survives into them. What does depend on the collision is how loudly each mode is excited, and the relative amplitudes here are the rough values a merger of two comparable masses produces rather than a prediction.

A few cycles that are only mass and spin

After the orbit is gone there is one object left, distorted, and it settles down by radiating at frequencies that belong to it rather than to the collision. For a black hole those frequencies are fixed by the mass and the spin and by nothing else — so the first mode measured is a measurement and every mode after it is a test, and the test is that four curves in one plane pass through one point.

astrophysics · Gravitational waves The ring does not come back. A ring of freely floating masses at four phases of a passing gravitational wave and once after it has gone. The first four are the familiar picture: stretched one way, then the other, with the area unchanged. The fifth is the one the standard picture does not draw — the ring is permanently deformed, by 25 per cent of the largest deformation the wave itself produced, and nothing brings it back. The masses are not oscillating about a new centre; they are at rest, at new separations. Both the oscillation and the offset are exaggerated enormously: the real strain at 440 megaparsecs is 9.9e-22 and the real permanent offset is 2.5e-22, so the drawing magnifies both by about 2e+20. What is honest in the picture is the ratio between them.

The ring that does not come back

Every picture of a passing gravitational wave shows a ring of free masses stretched, squeezed and let go. The last frame is wrong. The ring ends a different shape — permanently, with the masses at rest at new separations — by about a fifth of the largest distortion the wave itself produced. What sources the offset is the energy the wave carried away, so the wave is remembering itself, and nobody has measured it.

astrophysics · Gravitational waves Four states of light, each with the same area of noise. The field of a single mode of light drawn as a point in a plane whose two axes are its two quadratures — the parts of the wave in step with a reference and a quarter-cycle out of step. The distance from the centre is the amplitude and the angle is the phase. Each state is a cloud of 400 sampled measurements with its two-standard-deviation outline, in units where the vacuum's noise is one in every direction. The vacuum is a round cloud at the centre. Steady laser light is the same round cloud moved away from the centre. Light squeezed by 4 dB is an ellipse of the same area: narrower than the vacuum by a factor of 0.63 in one direction and wider by 1.58 in the other. Pointed along the direction from the centre it is quiet in amplitude; pointed across it, quiet in phase. The sampled spreads were checked against each state's widths.

The noise pushed below the floor

A perfectly steady laser beam still flickers, by an amount set by the vacuum itself, and for most of the twentieth century that flicker was treated as the floor of any optical measurement. It is a floor only for one shape of noise. Light can be made quieter than the vacuum in one property by being made louder in another — and the price, the fragility and the use of that trade are all visible in how the noise is shaped, which is why the world's gravitational-wave detectors now run on it.

quantum · Photon

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

MeasurementStrainBlack holeConservation lawsDetectorEnergyHorizonsMass-energyPolarisationRadiationSpinAngular distribution

All concepts