Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Concept

Extra dimensions — where it appears

Spatial directions beyond the three observed, proposed in theories that unify gravity with the other forces. If present they must be small or hidden, since forces between masses would otherwise fall off faster than the inverse square, and measurements of gravity at short range test that.

Named by 2 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

How large the hidden dimensions would have to be. The size extra dimensions would need, for gravity's true scale to be at a TeV rather than at 10¹⁹ GeV, against how many of them there are — a logarithmic axis of metres, for three choices of the true scale. The relation is the one that makes the arrangement work: the Planck mass observed in four dimensions is M_*^(2+n)Rⁿ, so gravity is weak because its field spreads into a volume nothing else can enter. Solved for R at a true scale of a TeV: 1 dimension needs 2.9e+13 m, 2 dimensions needs 2.4e-3 m, 3 dimensions needs 1.0e-8 m, 4 dimensions needs 2.2e-11 m, 5 dimensions needs 5.4e-13 m, 6 dimensions needs 4.5e-14 m. The two horizontal lines are where experiment has been. One extra dimension would have to be of order a hundred astronomical units, which would have wrecked the orbits of the planets and is excluded absolutely. Two would have to be of order a millimetre — which is what made the arrangement famous, because a millimetre is a distance a laboratory can test, and torsion balances have since verified the inverse-square law down to fifty-two micrometres and excluded it. Three or more sit below a nanometre, where no gravitational measurement reaches, and are untouched.

The scale that may not be where it looks

Every Planck number assumes gravity is four-dimensional all the way down. If it is not — if the field spreads into dimensions compact enough to have escaped notice — the true scale where gravity becomes strong could be at a TeV, and the whole remoteness of the Planck scale would be an artefact of where the field lines go. It is the one part of the subject an experiment can address, and the experiments have addressed it.

astrophysics · Planck scale The same nudge in four kinds of space. A body on a circular orbit given 5 per cent more speed, integrated for up to 6 turns in the field a point mass would have in spaces of 2, 3, 4, 5 dimensions. In 2 dimensions it stays between 1.00 and 1.10 of the original radius; in 3 dimensions it stays between 1.00 and 1.23 of the original radius; in 4 dimensions it leaves after 1.93 turns; in 5 dimensions it leaves after 1.19 turns. In three dimensions the orbit is an ellipse that closes; in two it is a rosette that does not close but never wanders far; from four dimensions up there are no stable orbits at all, and a planet nudged by anything would spiral away or plunge.

The number of dimensions a planet can orbit in

Gauss's law says that a point source's field is its strength spread over the surface around it, and the size of that surface depends on how many dimensions space has. In three it grows as the square of the distance, and the field falls as the inverse square. Count differently and the field falls differently — and above three dimensions it falls so steeply that no planet could hold a stable orbit and no atom could hold its electron. The inverse-square law is not a fact about gravity or electricity. It is a fact about space, and it is one of the conditions for there being anything in space to orbit.

electromagnetism · Gauss's law

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Black holeDimensional analysisDimensionsEffective potentialEnergyFine tuningGauss's lawGravitationThe inverse-square lawMeasurementOrbitPlanck scale

All concepts