Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Series

Pendulum — the series

10 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. The pendulum's phase portrait. Angle plotted against angular velocity. Closed loops are swinging back and forth; the open curves above and below are rotating all the way round; the dashed curve between them is the separatrix.

    The pendulum, and the small lie that makes it simple

    A pendulum's period does not depend on how far it swings. This is one of the most useful false statements in physics, and it is worth knowing exactly how false.

    part 1 · mechanics
  2. The pendulum's period against its amplitude. The exact period of a simple pendulum divided by the small-angle period, plotted against amplitude. The small-angle formula is the horizontal line at one; the exact curve leaves it slowly and then climbs without limit as the amplitude approaches a half turn.

    The period that depends on the swing, computed exactly

    A pendulum's period is not independent of amplitude. The exact answer is an elliptic integral, it has no elementary form, and plotting it shows precisely where the famous approximation earns its keep and where it collapses.

    part 2 · mechanics
  3. One equation, and the number that decides what it does. The same oscillator released from rest at one unit of displacement, with 4 different amounts of velocity-proportional loss. Every curve is a numerical integration of a single equation with no case analysis in it; what changes between them is one dimensionless number, the damping ratio. Below one, the two exponents are a complex conjugate pair and the motion crosses zero over and over inside a decaying envelope. At one they collide into a real double root and the trace reaches the axis and stops. Above one they are two distinct real numbers, the slower of them dominates, and the return is sluggish — an overdamped system takes longer to come back than a critically damped one, which is the thing the word 'over' is doing in its name. The ratios drawn are 0.15, 0.5, 1, 2, and the first zero crossing happens at 1.75 s for ζ = 0.15, 2.42 s for ζ = 0.5, never for ζ = 1, never for ζ = 2.

    The three ways of coming to rest

    An oscillator with friction in it can swing and fade, arrive and stop, or crawl back so slowly it looks stuck. One equation and one number decide which. The number is not what most people would guess, and neither is the value that returns fastest.

    part 3 · mechanics
  4. Two pivots with one period, and the length between them. The period of a uniform bar 1 m long swung about a pivot, against the distance of that pivot from its centre of mass. Close to the centre the period runs away, because there is almost no restoring torque; far from it the bar behaves more and more like a simple pendulum. In between is a minimum at h = k = 0.2887 m, the radius of gyration, and because there is a minimum every period above it belongs to two pivots at once — here 0.4 m and 0.2083 m, whose product is k² and whose periods agree to 2.2e-16 seconds. Suspend the bar from those two knife edges in turn, adjust until the periods match, and the equivalent simple pendulum is the distance between them: 0.6083 m. Then g = 4π²(h+h′)/T² gives 9.8100 m/s², recovered from the drawing to 1.8e-16. The mass of the bar, the distribution of that mass, and the position of the centre of mass appear nowhere in the answer.

    The length nobody has to measure

    A pendulum's period depends on its length, so a pendulum will measure gravity — except that a real swinging bar has no single length, and finding where its mass effectively sits is far harder than timing it. Kater's answer was to build the instrument so that the awkward quantity cancels, leaving a distance between two knife edges that a rule can read to five figures.

    part 4 · mechanics
  5. The potential a shaken pivot creates. The effective potential of a pendulum whose pivot is shaken vertically, against the angle from hanging, for shaking rates of 8, 14, 20, 30 times the pendulum's own frequency at an amplitude of 0.12 of its length. The shaking averages to no force at all — it is up as often as down — and yet it adds a term to the potential, because the pendulum's position is correlated with the phase of the shake rather than independent of it. The added term is proportional to sin²θ, so it is largest sideways and zero at both the hanging and the inverted positions, and it turns the maximum at 180° into a minimum once 14× and 20× and 30× the natural frequency is reached. The criterion is (aΩ)² > 2gL: the shake speed must beat the speed a fall through the pendulum's own length would give. Upside down then becomes a stable equilibrium, with a restoring force and a period of its own.

    Held up by a force that averages to nothing

    Shake a pendulum's pivot up and down fast enough and the pendulum will stand upside down, balanced, and push back if it is nudged. The shaking supplies no average force at all — it is up as often as it is down — and the reason it nevertheless holds is that the pendulum's position and the phase of the shake are not independent.

    part 5 · mechanics
  6. Four beads, four heights, one arrival time. One arch of a cycloid of radius 1, drawn with four beads on it at heights 0.061, 0.235, 0.592, 2.000 — a range of 33.0 to one. Each bead's time to slide, from rest and without friction, to the bottom of the arch is computed as a quadrature of ds/v along the curve as drawn, and the four answers are 1.003205 s, 1.003205 s, 1.003205 s, 1.003205 s: identical to 6.9e-13 of themselves. The closed form for this curve is π√(a/g) = 1.003205 s, which the quadrature reproduces without being told it. A bead let go at the cusp travels 5.7 times as far as the lowest one and arrives with it, because the extra distance is exactly paid for by the extra speed the extra height buys.

    The curve that does not ask where it started

    A pendulum's period depends on how far it swings, and the dependence is small but never zero. There is exactly one curve for which it is zero, and the reason has nothing to do with pendulums: on that curve the height above the bottom is proportional to the square of the distance travelled along it, which makes the motion harmonic by construction rather than by approximation.

    part 6 · mechanics
  7. A pendulum swung 30° with a sideways push, seen from above. The path of the bob of a 1 m pendulum free to swing in any direction, seen from directly above, released 30° from the vertical with a sideways push that would, for a small swing, make an ellipse 0.3 as wide as it is long. The path is an ellipse that turns: its long axis advances 5.30° every half swing, in the same sense as the bob goes round, where Airy's small-amplitude rate (3/8) ωab/L² gives 5.06°. Nothing outside the pendulum turns it — the pivot is fixed and there is no Earth rotation in this calculation. A pendulum on a turning Earth that is meant to show the Earth's rotation has this turning to contend with too.

    The ellipse a pendulum turns by itself

    Let a pendulum swing in any direction and give it a small sideways push, and its bob traces an ellipse. For a small swing the ellipse closes. For a larger one it turns, steadily, in the sense the bob is going round — with nothing outside the pendulum turning it. Airy worked out the rate in 1851, the same year Foucault hung his pendulum in the Panthéon, and the two effects are the same size for a pendulum a metre long whose ellipse is a twentieth of a millimetre wide.

    part 7 · mechanics
  8. Where to strike so the pivot feels nothing. The impulse the pivot has to supply, as a fraction of the blow, against where along the body the blow lands, measured from the pivot, for a uniform rod pivoted at one end and for a 0.84 m wooden bat held 15 cm from its knob, with the blow's position as a fraction of the length beyond the grip. For the rod the reaction is 1 − 3q/2L, positive for blows nearer the pivot, negative beyond, and zero at 0.6667 of the length. For the bat it is zero 51.9 cm from the grip, 17.1 cm from the end of the barrel. A blow there sets the body turning about the pivot as though the pivot were not needed.

    The point that takes the blow without a jolt

    Hit a stick held at one end and the hand feels a jolt — forwards if the blow lands near the hand, backwards if it lands near the tip, and nothing at all if it lands two-thirds of the way along. That point is the centre of percussion, and it is exactly where a simple pendulum with the same period would end: two different questions about a swinging body with one answer.

    part 8 · mechanics
  9. Where a kick lands decides whether the clock gains. A pendulum's state as a point on a circle: horizontally its angle, vertically its angular speed, both scaled by the swing, so that undisturbed it goes round the grey circle clockwise once a period and its phase is the angle round the circle from the top. An escapement's kick raises its speed: an upward jump. Kicked at the bottom of the swing (top of the circle), the point jumps straight outward — a bigger swing, phase unchanged. Kicked 42° of phase before the bottom, the jump also carries it forward round the circle, by 9.8°, and the pendulum arrives early; kicked the same amount after the bottom, it is set back by 9.8° and arrives late. The kick is exaggerated here to 0.32 of the top speed to make the angles visible.

    The kick that does not change the beat

    A pendulum clock has to push its pendulum, or friction would stop it within minutes, and every push risks disturbing the very period the clock exists to keep. In 1826 George Airy worked out exactly when a push does no harm: at the bottom of the swing, where the pendulum is moving fastest, an impulse changes how far it swings and leaves the timing untouched. A push before the bottom makes the clock gain; after it, lose. Three centuries of escapement design are a search for a mechanism that pushes where Airy said — or that pushes in the wrong place in a way that cancels some other error.

    part 9 · mechanics
  10. A gridiron of steel and brass drawn to the length that holds. The rods of a gridiron pendulum, to scale, for a seconds pendulum of 0.994 m: steel rods (dark) hang from the suspension and carry cross-bars from which brass rods (light) push upward, and from their tops the next steel rods hang down again, until the last carries the bob. Steel expands downward, lowering the bob; brass expands upward, raising it. They cancel when the steel's total length times its expansion equals the brass's: 2.52 m of steel against 1.52 m of brass, a ratio of 0.605. That is why gridirons are built of so many rods — the steel alone is 2.53 times the pendulum's length, folded into 3 stages. With zinc instead of brass, which expands 1.58 times as much, 1.61 m of steel would do. Real gridirons double every rod, side by side, so that the bob hangs symmetrically.

    The pendulum that must not grow when it warms

    A pendulum clock keeps time by the length of its pendulum, and every material grows when it is warmed. A steel rod a metre long lengthens by a hundredth of a millimetre for each degree, and the clock loses half a second a day — a minute a fortnight between a cold winter and a warm summer, far worse than anything the clockmaker's escapement could cause. The cure, found in the 1720s, was to let the pendulum grow in two directions at once: one part downward, another upward, in exactly the proportion that leaves the bob where it was. The same trick, with different metals, kept the best clocks to a hundredth of a second a day for two centuries, and its limits are set by heat that does not spread evenly or quickly.

    part 10 · mechanics

All series