Illustrated Physics
physics, drawn
Series

Hydrostatics — the series

12 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Three vessels, one pressure. Three vessels filled to the same depth of 3 m. The pressure on each base is 29.4 kPa — identical, because pressure is set by depth — while the weight of water each holds differs by a factor of 4.7. The base of the flaring vessel carries more force than the water standing over it weighs.

    The pressure that only knows depth

    A litre of water and a swimming pool press equally hard on a floor at the same depth. Pressure in a still fluid is a scalar with no direction of its own, it depends on how far down and on nothing else, and the shape of the container falls out of the arithmetic entirely.

    part 1 · fluids
  2. Force multiplied, distance paid. Two pistons on one body of fluid, of areas in the ratio 16 to 1. A force of 200 N on the small one holds 3.20 kN on the large one, and pushing the small piston 16 cm raises the large one by 10.0 mm. The two products are the same number: nothing is gained except the shape of the bargain.

    Force multiplied, and nothing gained

    A push on a small piston becomes a much larger push on a large one, in the ratio of their areas, with no machinery in between except the liquid. What the liquid will not do is give anything away — the distances shrink by the same factor the forces grow by, and the product is untouched.

    part 2 · fluids
  3. The surface a spin decides. The free surface of a liquid in a dish of radius 0.5 m turning at 10, 20, 40 revolutions a minute. In the rotating frame the surface is a level set of gz − ½ω²r², so it is a paraboloid exactly and not to some approximation, and nothing about the liquid appears in its shape: the same curve is got with mercury, water or oil. The rim stands 14.0 mm, 55.9 mm, 223.6 mm above the centre at those rates. A parabola z = r²/4f has focal length f, so these surfaces are mirrors of focal length g/2ω² — 4.47 m at 10 rpm, 1.12 m at 20 rpm, 0.28 m at 40 rpm. That is checked here on the drawn curves rather than quoted: a vertical ray reflected off the surface at a quarter, a half, three quarters and the whole of the radius crosses the axis at the same height to 0.00%, which is what a mirror with no spherical aberration means. Doubling the spin quarters the focal length, and there is no other adjustment: the dish can only ever look straight up.

    The surface a spin decides

    Spin a dish of liquid and its surface settles into a paraboloid — exactly, with nothing about the liquid in the shape. A parabola of that form has a focal length of g over twice the spin rate squared, so a bucket of mercury turning at twenty revolutions a minute is a telescope mirror figured by a clock instead of by grinding.

    part 3 · fluids
  4. A siphon's pressure, and the 10.09 m it cannot pass. The absolute pressure of the liquid along a siphon, from the upper surface, over the crown, and down to an outlet 1.2 m below the surface, for 4 crown heights. The profile is hydrostatic and depends on nothing but height: the tube's shape, its length and its bore do not appear. At the crown the liquid is below atmospheric pressure by ρg times the lift, and the whole question of how high a siphon can reach is whether that number stays above the liquid's vapour pressure — 2.34 kPa for water at 20 °C, which puts the ceiling at 10.09 m. a 2 m crown sits at 81.7 kPa and holds, a 6 m crown sits at 42.5 kPa and holds, a 9.5 m crown sits at 8.1 kPa and holds, a 11.5 m crown sits at -11.5 kPa and is below the vapour pressure, so it boils. The ceiling is a property of the liquid, not of the mechanism: a degassed liquid that can be pulled into tension has no such limit, and siphons in a vacuum.

    The height a siphon cannot pass

    A siphon will not lift water more than about ten metres, and the usual explanation for the limit is also given as the explanation for the mechanism. It cannot be both. A siphon runs in a vacuum, with degassed water, over a crown no atmosphere could support.

    part 4 · fluids
  5. The wedge that proves it. A wedge of water 4 mm on its vertical side, at a depth of 3 m, with the pressure on each of its three faces as an unknown. The two force balances decide them. Horizontally, the sloping face's push has a component that must exactly cancel the vertical face's, and since the sloping face is longer by exactly the factor its slope reduces the component by, the two pressures are equal — the geometry cancels, at every angle, for every size. Vertically the same cancellation happens except for the wedge's own weight, which needs the bottom face to carry 0.0667 per cent more. That excess falls in proportion to the size of the wedge, so at a point it is nothing and the three pressures are one number. Pressure being the same in every direction is the conclusion of that argument, not an assumption in it.

    The push that has no direction

    That the pressure at a point in a still fluid is the same whichever way the surface faces is not a definition. It is a theorem, and its proof is an argument about how two kinds of force scale with size — which is also the exact statement of when it stops being true.

    part 5 · fluids
  6. Water gets denser the deeper it is. The density of seawater at 0 °C and a salinity of 35 against depth, from the surface to the 10.99 km of the Challenger Deep, with the pressure integrated down the column from the equation of state rather than assumed. At the surface it is 1028.1 kg/m³. At the ocean's mean depth of 3.68 km it is 1045.3, 1.67 per cent more; at the bottom of the deepest trench it is 1076.5, 4.71 per cent more. An incompressible ocean would be the vertical line. The curve is almost straight; what curvature it has, too little to see here, is the water stiffening as it is squeezed: its secant bulk modulus rises by 3.24 pascals for every pascal of pressure.

    The sea that stands lower because water gives

    Water is the textbook incompressible fluid, and at the bottom of the ocean it is 4.7 per cent denser than at the top. That squeezing lowers the whole sea by about thirty metres, adds the weight of 266 metres of water to the pressure in the deepest trench, and speeds sound up so steadily with depth that it digs a channel in which a low note can cross an ocean.

    part 6 · fluids
  7. The deepest water reads warmer than the water above it. A column of seawater 10.9 km deep whose potential temperature — the temperature each parcel would have if brought to the surface without gaining or losing heat — falls from 20 °C at the top to 1 °C in the deep, and the temperature a thermometer lowered into it would read. The two agree near the surface and part company with depth: the thermometer reads a minimum of 1.38 °C near 3.9 km and then rises to 2.35 °C at the bottom, although the water there is the same water, with the same potential temperature, 1.00 °C, as the water two kilometres higher. The warming is compression alone; no heat reaches the deep trench from anywhere.

    The water that warms on the way down

    Lower a thermometer into the Mariana Trench and it reads colder and colder for four kilometres and then starts to warm, reaching about two and a half degrees at the bottom, eleven kilometres down. No heat is coming up from the sea floor to do it. The water at the bottom is the same water as the water two kilometres higher, carried down and squeezed, and squeezing warms it. In fresh water near four degrees the same squeezing does nothing at all, and below four degrees it cools — so a parcel of cold lake water pushed deep enough keeps sinking on its own.

    part 7 · fluids
  8. The rise a watt-year buys at each depth. The rise in sea level, in millimetres, from one watt-year per square metre of heat (3.16 × 10⁷ joules) stored in a thin layer at each depth, for two water columns: a subtropical one, 24 °C at the surface cooling to 1.5 °C in the deep, and a polar one, 1.5 °C at the surface and 0.5 °C below. In the warm column the yield is 2.36 mm at the surface, falls to 1.02 mm near 2.0 km where the water is cold but the pressure still modest, and recovers to 1.49 mm at 6 km as pressure takes over. In the polar column the same heat buys 0.63 mm at the surface and 1.13 mm at 4 km. A joule stored in cold, deep water raises the sea about twice as much as one stored in the cold water above it.

    The rise a joule of heat buys

    Warm a column of seawater and it stands taller without weighing any more, so the sea rises while the pressure on the sea floor stays exactly the same. How much it rises depends on where the heat goes. Seawater's expansion coefficient grows with temperature and with pressure, so a joule stored in warm tropical water lifts the sea more than six times as far as the same joule in Arctic surface water. Cold water in the deep, squeezed by four kilometres above it, expands about twice as much per joule as the same cold water at the surface. That is why the budget of sea-level rise turns on thousandths of a degree in the least-measured part of the ocean.

    part 8 · fluids
  9. The level at which a hinged gate swings open. The height of the centre of pressure on a vertical gate, as a fraction of its height H, against the depth of water above the gate's bottom (solid), approaching the centroid at half the height (dotted) as the water deepens; the dashed lines are hinges at 0.3H, 0.4H, 0.45H. A gate hinged on a horizontal axis and resting against a sill on the downstream side is held shut while the centre of pressure is below its hinge and swung open the moment it passes above. A hinge at 0.3H opens when the water is 0.90H deep, before it reaches the gate's top; at 0.4H, at 1.33H; at 0.45H, at 2.17H. A hinge at or above the centroid never opens at any depth, and the opening level grows steeply as the hinge approaches it — the setting is a choice of hinge position, made once, with no mechanism, sensor or power.

    The floodgate that opens at a chosen depth

    Hang a flat gate on a horizontal hinge across a channel and it can be made to stay shut while the water rises, press harder against its seat for a while, and then swing open on its own at one particular level — with no float, no motor and no sensor, only the position of the hinge. The trick is that the water's push on a submerged surface acts below the surface's middle by an amount that shrinks as the water deepens, so the point the push acts at climbs as the flood rises. Put the hinge on that climb and the gate opens where the climb crosses it.

    part 9 · fluids
  10. One height inside the bottle where the pressure is the air's. Gauge pressure against height inside a sealed bottle with an open tube reaching down to 10 cm above its outlet, while it is bubbling, at three water levels: 30.0, 22.0, 13.0 cm. Each line rises at the same hydrostatic slope, ρg, from the air pocket at the top, which is below atmospheric, to the outlet at the foot. All three cross atmospheric pressure at the tube's tip — 7.4 mm below it, the extra a bubble needs to leave a 2 mm tube — and so all three reach the outlet at the same 906 Pa above atmospheric, whatever the level. Dashed: an open bottle at the same levels, whose pressure at the outlet is 2937, 2154, 1273 Pa.

    The bottle that pours at one rate however full it is

    Water running from a hole in the foot of an open bottle slows as the bottle empties, because the pressure at the hole is the depth of water above it. Seal the bottle and push an open tube through the stopper, down into the water, and it stops slowing: the flow holds steady from full until the level reaches the bottom of the tube. Nothing regulates it. The tube's tip is the one point inside where the pressure is the atmosphere's, the water above it hangs from an air pocket below atmospheric, and the outlet sees only the height of the tip.

    part 10 · fluids
  11. Three vessels emptying through the same hole. The water level against time in three vessels that each hold 25 litres to a depth of 35 cm and drain through the same 0.8 mm hole in the floor, the outflow following Torricelli's law. The cylinder empties in 16.0 hours, but its level falls fast at first and slowly at the end — a parabola in time — and it is half empty in depth after only 32% of the run. The bowl whose radius grows as the fourth root of the height lowers its level at one rate from top to bottom, a straight line, and empties in 12.9 hours. A straight-sided cone sloping outwards, the shape a potter can actually throw, comes between: half its depth goes in 49% of its run.

    The vessel whose level falls evenly

    Water leaves a hole in the floor of a vessel faster when the vessel is full, because the pressure at the hole is the depth of water above it. In a cylinder that makes the level fall quickly at first and slowly at the end, so hour marks on its wall crowd towards the bottom. A level that falls at one rate needs a vessel that widens as the outflow quickens: its radius must grow as the fourth root of the height. The Egyptians who made the oldest surviving water clock, about 1400 BC, gave it sloping sides, which halves the error of a cylinder. They also gave it a scale for every month, because the hours they wanted to count were not all the same length.

    part 11 · fluids
  12. Two columns of air side by side, falling at different rates. The air pressure against height inside a 100 m building kept at 21 °C (solid) and outside it at −10 °C (dashed), relative to the pressure outside at the ground, for a building whose openings are equal at top and bottom. Both fall by about 12 Pa a metre, the weight of a metre of air on each square metre, but the cold outside air is 12 per cent denser and its pressure falls faster. The two lines cross at the neutral plane, half-way up (dot). Below it the outside pressure is higher and pushes air in at every crack; above it the inside pressure is higher and pushes air out — 69 Pa at the roof, 69 Pa at the ground. The building is a chimney.

    The building that breathes through its doors

    In winter the lobby doors of a tall building are hard to push open and, once open, let in a gale, though there is no wind outside. The building is a chimney. Its warm air and the cold air outside are two columns of fluid standing side by side, and the lighter one loses pressure more slowly with height, so the two pressures can be equal at only one level. Below it the outside pushes in through every crack; above it the inside pushes out. The difference is a few tens of pascals, the weight of a few millimetres of water, and over the area of a door it is the push of a strong hand — set entirely by hydrostatics, and running backwards in summer.

    part 12 · fluids

All series