Correspondence — the series · Illustrated Physics

Where the particle is likely to be found. A particle confined between two walls one unit apart. States 1, 4, 16 are drawn, each riding on a line at its own energy — 1E₁, 16E₁, 256E₁ — because the energies go as n². The curves are |ψ|², the probability of finding the particle at each position. The dashed line on each is the classical answer: a ball bouncing between the walls at constant speed is equally likely to be anywhere, and the quantum density oscillates about it and converges onto it as n rises.

Where the quantum picture hands back the old one

A confined particle's probability density oscillates violently at every quantum number, and never stops. What makes the classical answer come back is not that the oscillations die away — it is that nothing can resolve them.

part 1 · quantum

An average that follows Newton's law exactly. The centre of a wavepacket in a harmonic well, and the classical orbit started from the same place, drawn on top of each other. They agree to 5.5e-6 over 2.2 periods, which is the split-step integrator's own error and not a physical gap. This is exact and it is exact for every state of a harmonic oscillator, however wide, however lumpy, however far from classical: the theorem needs ⟨−V′(x)⟩ = −V′(⟨x⟩), which for a linear restoring force is true term by term. It is worth being suspicious of how strong that looks. The harmonic oscillator is the one potential where the average force over a state and the force at the state's centre cannot differ, so it is the worst possible example from which to conclude that quantum averages follow classical paths.

The average that obeys Newton

Ehrenfest's theorem says the centre of a wavepacket moves according to the average force over the state. That is exact, it is often quoted as the reason classical mechanics survives, and the two statements are not the same — because the average of a force is the force at the average only when the force is linear, which is to say almost never.

part 2 · quantum

A bundle that swings and never spreads. A Gaussian of the ground state's own width, released at rest from x = 3 in a harmonic well and propagated on a grid by split-step Fourier, drawn at 0 of a period, 0.25 of a period, 0.5 of a period. The packet slides from side to side and its shape does not change: over 2.2 full periods the width moves by 6.6e-5 per cent, and its centre tracks x₀cos t to 8.6e-6. Every other initial width breathes. This one is the displaced ground state, and it is the closest a quantum state comes to being a classical oscillator — a definite thing at a definite place, moving on the classical trajectory, staying the size it was.

The state that swings like a pendulum

Most quantum states of an oscillator look nothing like a swinging weight. One family does: it follows the classical trajectory exactly, never spreads, and sits at the uncertainty minimum for ever — and it is the state a laser and a driven circuit actually produce.

part 3 · quantum

A swing that dies away and comes back. The envelope of the mean position of a coherent state with 9 quanta on average, in an oscillator whose levels carry a small quadratic term, Eₙ = n + n²/240, over one revival time of 240 oscillator periods. The swing collapses within about 9.1 periods, when the packet has spread round its orbit, and it stays at zero for most of the run. It returns whole at half the revival time, on the opposite side, and whole again at the full revival time; the envelope is summed from the state's energy components and checked against α·exp(−2n̄ sin²χt) to a part in a hundred million. The dashed curve is a classical ensemble started from the same distribution, each member orbiting at the frequency its own energy gives: it collapses in the same way and never returns, its swing at the half and full revival times 0.1% and 0.1% of the start.

The return a classical cloud never makes

Put a swinging quantum packet in a well whose frequency depends a little on the amplitude and it spreads round its orbit until its swing has vanished. That part is not quantum at all: a cloud of classical oscillators does exactly the same. What no classical cloud can do is come back — and the quantum packet reassembles whole, on schedule, splitting into copies on the way, because its energies are discrete.

part 4 · quantum

A quasi-probability that goes negative. The Wigner function of the oscillator's state at a quarter of its revival time, with 4 quanta on average: two copies of the packet, at x = ±2.83, in equal superposition. It is computed from the wavefunction by the Wigner transform on a lattice, and it integrates to one. The two copies are the two positive blobs. Between them lies a pattern of stripes with no classical counterpart, running from 0.289 down to −0.289, where the shaded warm regions and their outlines mark negative values. A negative probability is not a probability, so this distribution cannot describe a cloud of classical particles. The stripes are also taller than the blobs, so the interference carries more structure than the copies themselves: the highest stripe reaches 0.289 and the centre of a blob 0.159.

The probability that goes below zero

Classical mechanics describes an uncertain state as a cloud of points in the plane of position and momentum. Quantum mechanics has an exact counterpart, the Wigner function, whose shadows are the true position and momentum distributions — and which goes negative. It goes negative for a single photon, for every superposition of two packets, and for every pure state that is not a Gaussian. Where it is negative no classical cloud can imitate the state, and losing energy to the surroundings erases the negative regions first.

part 5 · quantum